WEBVTT

1
00:00:10.115 --> 00:00:11.575
<v Speaker 1>It is six thirty one.</v>

2
00:00:11.675 --> 00:00:13.415
I'm gonna call the meeting to order.

3
00:00:13.805 --> 00:00:17.415
This is a school committee meeting. We'll do a roll call.

4
00:00:19.915 --> 00:00:23.815
Dr. Welch present. Ms. Collins.

5
00:00:24.045 --> 00:00:25.815
<v Speaker 2>Searching for my glasses for present.</v>

6
00:00:26.315 --> 00:00:30.135
<v Speaker 1>Mr. Patel? Here. Ms. Brunell. Here I am present.</v>

7
00:00:32.515 --> 00:00:35.095
And that is all we have for now. So we have a quorum.

8
00:00:36.405 --> 00:00:38.975
Just so everybody knows, this meeting is being telecast

9
00:00:39.235 --> 00:00:40.375
or broadcast telecast.

10
00:00:41.205 --> 00:00:44.135
Broadcast on Wait, what year is it? Telecast.

11
00:00:45.765 --> 00:00:48.615
It's being broadcast on Pegasus and on Zoom.

12
00:00:48.675 --> 00:00:50.495
And recorded for future consumption.

13
00:00:51.325 --> 00:00:55.975
Alright, so we will begin now with a pledge

14
00:00:55.975 --> 00:00:57.775
of allegiance, followed by a moment of silence.

15
00:01:04.785 --> 00:01:08.135
<v Speaker 3>Allegiance</v>
<v Speaker 2>To the United, United States of America.</v>

16
00:01:08.875 --> 00:01:11.455
To the Republic. Republic for which it stands. One nation.

17
00:01:11.595 --> 00:01:14.775
One nation under God, indivisible, with liberty

18
00:01:15.155 --> 00:01:16.335
and justice for all.

19
00:01:25.905 --> 00:01:29.535
<v Speaker 1>Thank you. We take that moment of silence</v>

20
00:01:30.235 --> 00:01:32.775
to honor all of our troops serving domestically

21
00:01:32.775 --> 00:01:37.455
and abroad announcements.

22
00:01:38.555 --> 00:01:43.255
Dr. Stash, I don't have any, any members

23
00:01:43.255 --> 00:01:45.095
of the committee with an announcement tonight.

24
00:01:46.755 --> 00:01:49.895
Seeing none public speak.

25
00:01:50.795 --> 00:01:53.895
Public speak is scheduled for a period of 15 minutes.

26
00:01:54.085 --> 00:01:56.695
Each speaker will be permitted a maximum of three minutes

27
00:01:56.695 --> 00:01:59.295
during which time they can speak about topics within the

28
00:01:59.295 --> 00:02:01.415
scope of responsibility of the school committee.

29
00:02:01.475 --> 00:02:02.335
All remarks will be

30
00:02:02.335 --> 00:02:03.535
addressed through the school committee chair.

31
00:02:03.535 --> 00:02:05.295
Public speak is not a time for debate

32
00:02:05.555 --> 00:02:09.055
or response to comments by the school committee.

33
00:02:09.295 --> 00:02:11.535
I know we have a couple. Thank you.

34
00:02:15.115 --> 00:02:19.095
Thanks Ms. Fleming,

35
00:02:19.995 --> 00:02:21.695
if you please come to that podium right there.

36
00:02:22.675 --> 00:02:24.135
And I'm gonna start. I explain.

37
00:02:24.715 --> 00:02:25.455
I'm gonna start a

38
00:02:25.625 --> 00:02:29.975
timer at, it's three minutes.

39
00:02:30.475 --> 00:02:34.535
At two and a half I'll raise my hand to let you know

40
00:02:34.615 --> 00:02:35.655
that you have 30 more seconds

41
00:02:36.355 --> 00:02:39.815
and then I, at three minutes I will cut you off.

42
00:02:40.085 --> 00:02:41.735
Okay. Ready? And if you could please

43
00:02:41.735 --> 00:02:43.015
introduce yourself at the beginning.

44
00:02:43.085 --> 00:02:44.085
Okay. All yours.

45
00:02:45.025 --> 00:02:46.895
<v Speaker 4>Hello, my name is Kathy Fleming</v>

46
00:02:46.895 --> 00:02:49.015
and I am the head, girls, track and field

47
00:02:49.015 --> 00:02:51.175
and cross country coach at Natick High School.

48
00:02:52.355 --> 00:02:54.335
I'm here to advocate for the development

49
00:02:54.335 --> 00:02:58.855
of an approximately 900 meter crushed stone, wood chip,

50
00:02:58.875 --> 00:03:02.005
or firmly packed dirt running

51
00:03:02.105 --> 00:03:05.365
and walking path surrounding the perimeter

52
00:03:05.365 --> 00:03:07.365
of the athletic fields at Natick High School.

53
00:03:08.125 --> 00:03:11.165
I believe this project addresses two important needs,

54
00:03:11.305 --> 00:03:12.805
the safety of our student athletes

55
00:03:13.425 --> 00:03:15.685
and the greater recreational access

56
00:03:15.745 --> 00:03:17.045
for the entire community.

57
00:03:17.935 --> 00:03:19.005
Let's start with the safety.

58
00:03:19.705 --> 00:03:22.965
Our high school track teams regularly include more

59
00:03:22.965 --> 00:03:24.085
than 200 athletes.

60
00:03:24.865 --> 00:03:28.125
At times. These athletes are all training at the same time.

61
00:03:28.195 --> 00:03:29.445
Sharing one track.

62
00:03:31.025 --> 00:03:33.725
We have distance runners, sprinters, boys

63
00:03:33.725 --> 00:03:35.765
and girls, all doing interval training.

64
00:03:36.945 --> 00:03:40.325
One track is being asked to accommodate a tremendous number

65
00:03:40.325 --> 00:03:43.325
of athletes with very different, different training needs

66
00:03:43.465 --> 00:03:46.245
and dev d different training speeds.

67
00:03:47.235 --> 00:03:48.685
This creates congestion.

68
00:03:49.075 --> 00:03:51.245
Most importantly, potential safety concerns.

69
00:03:52.155 --> 00:03:54.525
When athletes are running at different speeds

70
00:03:54.525 --> 00:03:57.125
and competing, completing different workouts in the same

71
00:03:57.125 --> 00:03:59.965
limited space, the opportunity for collisions

72
00:03:59.965 --> 00:04:02.205
and injuries increases dramatically.

73
00:04:02.965 --> 00:04:04.445
I have seen collisions already,

74
00:04:04.555 --> 00:04:09.005
however, luckily nobody has been hurt too badly just yet.

75
00:04:09.885 --> 00:04:13.125
A perimeter trail would provide an additional

76
00:04:13.215 --> 00:04:14.605
designated training area.

77
00:04:15.075 --> 00:04:17.325
This would move a significant amount

78
00:04:17.325 --> 00:04:20.005
of activity off the track, allowing athletes

79
00:04:20.185 --> 00:04:21.725
who need the track for speed work

80
00:04:22.025 --> 00:04:23.285
and specialized training

81
00:04:23.625 --> 00:04:25.445
to use it more safely and effectively.

82
00:04:26.185 --> 00:04:29.525
But this proposal is much more than just about athletics.

83
00:04:30.275 --> 00:04:33.605
It's an opportunity to give native community a recreational

84
00:04:33.925 --> 00:04:35.925
resource that can be enjoyed every day.

85
00:04:36.685 --> 00:04:39.605
Residents could walk, jog, exercise in a safe,

86
00:04:39.605 --> 00:04:40.845
clearly defined area.

87
00:04:41.605 --> 00:04:44.645
Families, spectators, and visitors all could benefit.

88
00:04:45.825 --> 00:04:48.125
We are proposing a crust, stone, or wood ship

89
00:04:48.225 --> 00:04:51.525
or firmly packed dirt sur surface.

90
00:04:51.695 --> 00:04:54.005
We're not proposing asphalt

91
00:04:54.025 --> 00:04:56.725
or anything like that, something softer on the legs.

92
00:04:57.025 --> 00:04:59.445
It will make productive use of the space

93
00:04:59.445 --> 00:05:01.365
that is currently underutilized.

94
00:05:01.945 --> 00:05:04.165
As the town considered potential renovations

95
00:05:04.265 --> 00:05:06.565
to the football field athletic complex,

96
00:05:07.005 --> 00:05:09.485
I would strongly encourage encouraging this trail

97
00:05:09.905 --> 00:05:11.005
in the planning process.

98
00:05:11.885 --> 00:05:13.245
Coordinating the project

99
00:05:13.635 --> 00:05:16.205
with other improvements could create efficiencies in

100
00:05:16.485 --> 00:05:17.845
construction, grading and drainage.

101
00:05:18.355 --> 00:05:20.845
Okay. It improves athlete safety,

102
00:05:21.315 --> 00:05:22.885
expands recreational access

103
00:05:23.065 --> 00:05:24.885
and creates a shared community space

104
00:05:25.075 --> 00:05:28.525
that can serve Natick residents for years to come

105
00:05:28.715 --> 00:05:29.965
with a modest investment.

106
00:05:30.685 --> 00:05:33.245
I respectfully ask the town town

107
00:05:33.245 --> 00:05:36.605
to consider a conversation about inco incorporating this 900

108
00:05:36.615 --> 00:05:41.005
meter trail into the future athletic complex planning.

109
00:05:41.055 --> 00:05:42.055
Thank you.

110
00:05:43.995 --> 00:05:48.925
<v Speaker 1>With one second to go. Outstanding. It is 6 37. Dr.</v>

111
00:05:48.955 --> 00:05:51.205
Folkman has arrived. Ms. Vickers.

112
00:05:58.255 --> 00:06:00.765
<v Speaker 5>Hello, B Brinley Vickers Precinct eight.</v>

113
00:06:01.445 --> 00:06:04.805
I am here this evening for the Natick High School cross

114
00:06:04.805 --> 00:06:06.965
country and Track Boosters Club.

115
00:06:07.585 --> 00:06:11.925
We are the hosts of the Frosty 5K. This is our fifth annual.

116
00:06:12.465 --> 00:06:16.365
We support all three seasons of runners, outdoor

117
00:06:17.015 --> 00:06:19.605
cross country in the fall, indoor track

118
00:06:19.605 --> 00:06:21.965
and field in the winter and outdoor track and field.

119
00:06:22.025 --> 00:06:25.725
In the spring we have hot chocolate and a dj.

120
00:06:28.225 --> 00:06:32.445
As I said, it's our fifth annual. It is a lot of fun.

121
00:06:32.865 --> 00:06:34.565
We have raffles and prizes

122
00:06:34.785 --> 00:06:36.805
and we hope that everyone will come join

123
00:06:36.805 --> 00:06:38.125
us and support the kids.

124
00:06:38.535 --> 00:06:39.535
Thank you so much.

125
00:06:40.375 --> 00:06:45.305
<v Speaker 1>Thank you. And Ms. Stave.</v>

126
00:06:45.305 --> 00:06:48.705
Leo Carroll. Did I say that right? Yes, you did. Thank you.

127
00:06:53.615 --> 00:06:55.425
<v Speaker 6>Good evening, members of the school committee.</v>

128
00:06:55.765 --> 00:06:57.825
My name is Alina Staley O'Carroll

129
00:06:58.245 --> 00:07:00.705
and I have two children in the Natick School system,

130
00:07:00.985 --> 00:07:03.785
a fourth grader at Brown and a sixth grader at Kennedy.

131
00:07:04.775 --> 00:07:06.665
When I spoke here just a few weeks ago,

132
00:07:07.185 --> 00:07:08.465
I emphasized the importance

133
00:07:08.465 --> 00:07:10.665
of finding the right balance in our use

134
00:07:10.665 --> 00:07:11.865
of classroom technology.

135
00:07:12.445 --> 00:07:15.385
And I'd like to return to that same idea tonight.

136
00:07:15.695 --> 00:07:18.145
Drawing on my own recent teaching experience

137
00:07:18.145 --> 00:07:20.545
and conversations with my friends

138
00:07:20.605 --> 00:07:21.945
who are Natick parents as well.

139
00:07:23.305 --> 00:07:25.665
I have been teaching college students for over 20 years

140
00:07:25.725 --> 00:07:27.665
and during that time, my colleagues

141
00:07:27.665 --> 00:07:30.665
and I have been navigating the growing role

142
00:07:30.665 --> 00:07:32.225
of technology in the classrooms.

143
00:07:32.255 --> 00:07:33.865
Most recently, the challenges

144
00:07:33.865 --> 00:07:35.985
and opportunities presented by ai.

145
00:07:37.085 --> 00:07:40.185
And while I want my students to become proficient

146
00:07:40.185 --> 00:07:42.665
with these tools, I certainly include a lot of assignments

147
00:07:43.325 --> 00:07:46.425
in classroom and on homeworks where it is appropriate

148
00:07:46.425 --> 00:07:47.465
to use AI in tech.

149
00:07:48.015 --> 00:07:49.305
I've also moved much

150
00:07:49.485 --> 00:07:52.385
of their everyday work back to pen and paper.

151
00:07:52.495 --> 00:07:54.105
I've banned laptops in my classes.

152
00:07:55.045 --> 00:07:58.025
And just since September I've noticed a marked improvement

153
00:07:58.025 --> 00:07:59.065
in my students' attention

154
00:07:59.245 --> 00:08:01.825
and engagement during class compared

155
00:08:01.825 --> 00:08:02.945
with what I did in the spring.

156
00:08:03.845 --> 00:08:05.705
Why am I telling you about my college experience?

157
00:08:05.705 --> 00:08:08.065
Because I believe a similar balance would benefit

158
00:08:08.245 --> 00:08:09.305
our middle schoolers.

159
00:08:10.165 --> 00:08:11.385
And I would especially like

160
00:08:11.385 --> 00:08:13.185
to focus on their day-to-day sort

161
00:08:13.185 --> 00:08:16.105
of low stakes assignments in math and writing.

162
00:08:17.605 --> 00:08:19.585
In conversations with other Natick parents,

163
00:08:20.225 --> 00:08:22.385
I have heard very similar observations

164
00:08:22.385 --> 00:08:24.305
to my own experience about the benefits

165
00:08:24.305 --> 00:08:25.745
of pen and paper learning.

166
00:08:27.045 --> 00:08:29.665
We noticed that when our kids work on paper, they tend

167
00:08:29.665 --> 00:08:31.745
to slow down, they tend to focus more,

168
00:08:31.935 --> 00:08:34.265
they engage more thoughtfully with the material,

169
00:08:34.895 --> 00:08:36.545
they develop their ideas better,

170
00:08:37.775 --> 00:08:39.225
they can erase their mistakes.

171
00:08:39.405 --> 00:08:41.545
And what is very important particular

172
00:08:41.545 --> 00:08:44.425
for my son is they can go back and check their earlier work.

173
00:08:44.885 --> 00:08:47.505
And that is something that is not always possible when

174
00:08:47.505 --> 00:08:49.745
assignments are presented, kind of like one question,

175
00:08:49.885 --> 00:08:53.105
one screen at a time, and that they don't often go back.

176
00:08:53.105 --> 00:08:57.285
In that case, I would love to see us build on these benefits

177
00:08:57.305 --> 00:09:01.805
by encouraging more handwritten note taking in class

178
00:09:02.625 --> 00:09:04.045
and everyday assignments

179
00:09:04.045 --> 00:09:06.045
that are completed at home on paper rather

180
00:09:06.045 --> 00:09:07.085
than on Chromebooks.

181
00:09:08.465 --> 00:09:11.285
Of course, technology can add genuine value to teachers

182
00:09:11.305 --> 00:09:12.645
and especially to grading.

183
00:09:13.505 --> 00:09:16.325
And I'm not against technology in classroom, I just think

184
00:09:16.325 --> 00:09:18.165
that it would be beneficial to

185
00:09:19.035 --> 00:09:20.645
move low stakes to pen and paper.

186
00:09:21.585 --> 00:09:23.045
I'm also coming across more

187
00:09:23.045 --> 00:09:24.365
and more research that suggests

188
00:09:24.365 --> 00:09:25.805
that handwriting can improve learning

189
00:09:25.825 --> 00:09:27.525
and retention compared with typing.

190
00:09:28.645 --> 00:09:29.645
I just read that Sweden,

191
00:09:29.645 --> 00:09:32.245
which apparently was a leader in digitalization once,

192
00:09:32.425 --> 00:09:34.685
is now moving back to textbooks and pen and paper.

193
00:09:36.465 --> 00:09:38.645
And while I appreciate the ease of grading

194
00:09:38.645 --> 00:09:40.645
that technology brings to teachers, believe me,

195
00:09:40.645 --> 00:09:43.125
especially this time in the semester, I think

196
00:09:43.125 --> 00:09:46.405
that the benefits of tech can need not be mutually exclusive

197
00:09:46.405 --> 00:09:49.005
with sort of back to basic pen, paper and textbooks.

198
00:09:49.265 --> 00:09:51.245
And I would like to encourage the school committee

199
00:09:51.265 --> 00:09:53.845
to consider working with teachers and parents on this issue.

200
00:09:55.935 --> 00:09:57.165
<v Speaker 1>Thank you. Thank you.</v>

201
00:10:01.865 --> 00:10:05.005
All right. That is everybody for public speak,

202
00:10:05.545 --> 00:10:10.085
so we will move on to our various representatives.

203
00:10:10.385 --> 00:10:11.845
Mr. Wood, I see you're online.

204
00:10:12.345 --> 00:10:14.605
Is he a co-host? Great. Mr. Wood,

205
00:10:15.405 --> 00:10:16.405
<v Speaker 7>I am online.</v>

206
00:10:16.405 --> 00:10:17.805
Mr. Chair, thank you very much.

207
00:10:18.765 --> 00:10:22.045
I am, I'm at home fighting a cold and sipping tea.

208
00:10:22.805 --> 00:10:24.405
I apologize for not being with you all in person.

209
00:10:26.245 --> 00:10:28.885
I have nothing to say currently,

210
00:10:29.065 --> 00:10:31.565
but I'll be monitoring. I'm here if you need me.

211
00:10:32.135 --> 00:10:35.805
<v Speaker 1>Thank you. Our students are here.</v>

212
00:10:35.825 --> 00:10:37.765
Do our student reps have anything to share tonight?

213
00:10:38.565 --> 00:10:42.685
We have no updates. Alright, Ms. Gomes,

214
00:10:47.145 --> 00:10:48.885
<v Speaker 8>No updates at this time. Thank you.</v>

215
00:10:49.475 --> 00:10:53.285
<v Speaker 1>Okay, we will move on to the consent agenda.</v>

216
00:10:53.965 --> 00:10:57.005
I am gonna pull out item D, the vote

217
00:10:57.005 --> 00:10:59.165
to approve the memorial building project invoices

218
00:10:59.165 --> 00:11:00.525
as voted by the SPC.

219
00:11:00.915 --> 00:11:02.245
Anybody else with anything?

220
00:11:02.825 --> 00:11:05.525
If not, I'll take a motion. Dr. Welch,

221
00:11:06.225 --> 00:11:09.845
<v Speaker 9>Can we pull out the minutes for November 2nd please?</v>

222
00:11:10.585 --> 00:11:11.965
<v Speaker 1>So it's a whole item, so we'll pull</v>

223
00:11:11.965 --> 00:11:13.045
the whole item out. Yeah,

224
00:11:13.045 --> 00:11:14.725
<v Speaker 9>The, so that can't be pulled out under the rules,</v>

225
00:11:14.945 --> 00:11:16.365
not individually understood, but

226
00:11:16.365 --> 00:11:17.365
<v Speaker 1>It's okay.</v>

227
00:11:17.365 --> 00:11:19.365
It's still one vote, so it like, we'll pull that out.

228
00:11:19.605 --> 00:11:21.845
Anything else? All right. Motion on the other things.

229
00:11:21.865 --> 00:11:26.165
Motion to approve A and C in the consent agenda. Second.

230
00:11:26.545 --> 00:11:30.125
Motion by Ms. Brunell, seconded by Mr. Patel. All in favor?

231
00:11:31.185 --> 00:11:33.285
Any opposed? Six. Zero. Zero.

232
00:11:33.865 --> 00:11:38.005
So we'll take them in in the order of the items. Dr. Welch,

233
00:11:39.705 --> 00:11:40.705
<v Speaker 9>Mr.</v>

234
00:11:40.705 --> 00:11:42.725
Chairman, I'm just gonna move to amend the minutes

235
00:11:43.475 --> 00:11:44.645
from November 2nd.

236
00:11:47.185 --> 00:11:50.485
The proposed amendment is to strike November 11 at the top

237
00:11:50.485 --> 00:11:52.685
of the draft and replace it with November two.

238
00:11:54.585 --> 00:11:56.405
<v Speaker 1>So just a ty, a typo. Perfect.</v>

239
00:11:58.425 --> 00:11:59.965
So did you just make a motion? I,

240
00:12:00.085 --> 00:12:01.085
<v Speaker 9>I did.</v>

241
00:12:01.085 --> 00:12:02.405
I second. I moved to amend them as such.

242
00:12:02.405 --> 00:12:03.805
<v Speaker 1>Perfect. So that's a motion</v>

243
00:12:03.905 --> 00:12:05.485
by Dr. Welch and seconded by Ms.

244
00:12:05.485 --> 00:12:06.485
Brunell. Any debate

245
00:12:07.155 --> 00:12:09.365
<v Speaker 10>That was a motion to amend?</v>

246
00:12:10.025 --> 00:12:11.565
Second but approve all of them.

247
00:12:11.565 --> 00:12:14.085
<v Speaker 1>Correct. Ask the motion maker</v>

248
00:12:15.025 --> 00:12:16.685
<v Speaker 9>Are can those, I don't, I'm,</v>

249
00:12:17.075 --> 00:12:18.605
help me understand under the rules there,

250
00:12:18.665 --> 00:12:20.005
can those be made as one motion?

251
00:12:20.005 --> 00:12:21.205
Does it have to be two motions?

252
00:12:22.145 --> 00:12:24.285
<v Speaker 1>It can be one. It can be</v>
<v Speaker 9>One. Assume</v>

253
00:12:25.225 --> 00:12:27.325
<v Speaker 1>You just, I think Ms. Collins is asking if you will</v>

254
00:12:27.555 --> 00:12:30.685
specify exactly which part of the, of

255
00:12:30.685 --> 00:12:32.125
that item needs to be updated.

256
00:12:32.475 --> 00:12:36.725
<v Speaker 9>Yeah, the, the minutes that are dated in the name</v>

257
00:12:36.725 --> 00:12:38.085
of the file, November 2nd,

258
00:12:38.265 --> 00:12:40.805
are just titled November 11th at the top of that page.

259
00:12:41.425 --> 00:12:44.525
<v Speaker 11>And will you also move to approve item B?</v>

260
00:12:44.545 --> 00:12:48.405
And Ms. Collins, I think is suggesting that you also

261
00:12:49.545 --> 00:12:52.725
say move to approve the open session minutes

262
00:12:52.955 --> 00:12:54.245
<v Speaker 1>With the one change. Yes,</v>

263
00:12:54.445 --> 00:12:55.565
<v Speaker 9>I would absolutely move</v>

264
00:12:55.565 --> 00:12:58.565
to approve the open session minutes from April 27th. It's

265
00:12:58.565 --> 00:13:03.485
<v Speaker 11>Committee work</v>
<v Speaker 9>And May 4th in addition to proposing</v>

266
00:13:03.485 --> 00:13:06.605
to amend the minutes from November 2nd. Second.

267
00:13:06.865 --> 00:13:09.845
<v Speaker 11>That's</v>
<v Speaker 1>The one. Dr. Welch and Ms. Brunell, any debate?</v>

268
00:13:11.225 --> 00:13:14.245
All in favor? Any opposed? 6 0 0.

269
00:13:15.715 --> 00:13:18.365
That one is good. And then on item D, vote

270
00:13:18.365 --> 00:13:19.605
to approve memorial building project

271
00:13:19.605 --> 00:13:21.085
invoices as voted by the SBC.

272
00:13:21.085 --> 00:13:22.005
There's nothing actually linked.

273
00:13:23.225 --> 00:13:24.325
Is there anything to approve?

274
00:13:27.685 --> 00:13:31.065
If not, do you know? Sorry. That's okay.

275
00:13:31.245 --> 00:13:34.385
On on the, the Memorial Building Project invoices.

276
00:13:34.565 --> 00:13:36.065
Oh no, there's nothing, nothing there.

277
00:13:36.065 --> 00:13:37.505
So we just put it as a placeholder. Good.

278
00:13:37.605 --> 00:13:39.585
So we don't have

279
00:13:39.585 --> 00:13:40.625
to do anything 'cause there's nothing there.

280
00:13:40.625 --> 00:13:41.825
Perfect. Moving on.

281
00:13:45.085 --> 00:13:47.465
So we'll go to the superintendent's report, Dr. Pash.

282
00:13:48.855 --> 00:13:52.545
<v Speaker 12>Okay, so we're going to do the NPS spotlight.</v>

283
00:13:52.745 --> 00:13:54.145
I hope everybody's been enjoying that.

284
00:13:54.185 --> 00:13:55.385
I know you're gonna enjoy today.

285
00:13:55.925 --> 00:13:57.825
I'm really pleased to welcome Mr.

286
00:13:57.825 --> 00:14:01.225
Steve Miller, the direct arcade to 12 director of Fine

287
00:14:01.225 --> 00:14:03.225
and Performing Arts and members

288
00:14:03.285 --> 00:14:05.705
of the Natick High School Theater Company's cast

289
00:14:05.765 --> 00:14:06.865
of Dear Evan Hansen.

290
00:14:06.865 --> 00:14:09.185
We're super excited to have you all here.

291
00:14:09.205 --> 00:14:10.625
We called Pegasus ahead of time

292
00:14:10.625 --> 00:14:12.385
and we said they may just sing.

293
00:14:12.445 --> 00:14:14.185
We hope you do so welcome.

294
00:14:14.325 --> 00:14:15.585
And we're looking forward to kind of

295
00:14:16.175 --> 00:14:17.785
what you wanna share with us. Thank

296
00:14:17.785 --> 00:14:18.785
<v Speaker 13>You.</v>

297
00:14:18.785 --> 00:14:19.065
Can I give you a little background first?

298
00:14:19.295 --> 00:14:20.295
<v Speaker 9>We'd love it.</v>
<v Speaker 12>Fantastic.</v>

299
00:14:20.485 --> 00:14:22.145
<v Speaker 14>I'm just gonna move this so that people can,</v>

300
00:14:22.565 --> 00:14:23.625
how many people are gonna be

301
00:14:23.625 --> 00:14:24.625
<v Speaker 13>Coming up?</v>

302
00:14:24.625 --> 00:14:27.025
Three. And we need one chair. Okay, awesome. Thank you.

303
00:14:28.565 --> 00:14:30.505
So dear Evan Hansen is the show.

304
00:14:30.605 --> 00:14:33.025
It is the first Friday, oh there it is.

305
00:14:33.335 --> 00:14:34.785
It's the first Friday in December.

306
00:14:34.815 --> 00:14:36.705
It's at seven 30, which is December 4th.

307
00:14:37.005 --> 00:14:38.785
And then it is Saturday at two o'clock.

308
00:14:38.785 --> 00:14:41.585
That's December 5th and it's seven 30 as well.

309
00:14:42.045 --> 00:14:45.425
And so why you have here is that there's a plan is

310
00:14:45.455 --> 00:14:47.585
that this is a, this is an important show,

311
00:14:47.585 --> 00:14:49.225
but it's also a show that deals with mental health.

312
00:14:49.725 --> 00:14:53.125
And so the creators of the show really wanted

313
00:14:53.125 --> 00:14:56.765
to get across this idea that loneliness does not need

314
00:14:56.765 --> 00:14:58.485
to be a a life sentence.

315
00:14:59.145 --> 00:15:01.005
But in trying to get that across, they deal

316
00:15:01.005 --> 00:15:03.205
with some pretty heavy topics and some pretty heavy themes.

317
00:15:03.585 --> 00:15:05.445
And so there is a death by suicide.

318
00:15:05.445 --> 00:15:07.045
There's a character considered suicide,

319
00:15:07.075 --> 00:15:08.485
there's family dysfunction.

320
00:15:08.985 --> 00:15:10.525
And so there's some real challenges.

321
00:15:10.525 --> 00:15:12.285
So we created a team that came in

322
00:15:12.825 --> 00:15:15.685
and would meet with us for during auditions that were there

323
00:15:15.745 --> 00:15:18.405
as far as for some of the more challenging rehearsals.

324
00:15:18.745 --> 00:15:19.725
And so we're trying to think about

325
00:15:19.725 --> 00:15:20.725
how do we care for our actors?

326
00:15:21.215 --> 00:15:23.205
We're then thinking about how do we partner with parents?

327
00:15:23.225 --> 00:15:24.965
We parent meetings and we had a consent letter.

328
00:15:25.545 --> 00:15:28.885
And then we also are bringing in counselors, not just

329
00:15:28.885 --> 00:15:31.285
for these meetings, we're also gonna have audience support,

330
00:15:31.285 --> 00:15:32.605
like how do we support our audience?

331
00:15:32.905 --> 00:15:35.325
And so at the nights of the show

332
00:15:35.465 --> 00:15:38.605
and in the afternoon there'll be people available outside

333
00:15:39.145 --> 00:15:42.405
out in the foyer if someone needs someone to talk to,

334
00:15:42.405 --> 00:15:44.085
whether they're concerned about themselves or somebody else.

335
00:15:44.355 --> 00:15:47.445
They'll also be information as far as in our playbill as far

336
00:15:47.445 --> 00:15:49.205
as what you can do, numbers that you can call.

337
00:15:49.825 --> 00:15:54.365
And we are thinking about doing some stuff that as a cast,

338
00:15:54.425 --> 00:15:57.565
we might have a talk back from actors as far as to

339
00:15:58.305 --> 00:15:59.765
the audience on Saturday afternoon.

340
00:15:59.765 --> 00:16:00.645
And we're playing something special

341
00:16:00.665 --> 00:16:01.565
as far as for our last show.

342
00:16:01.565 --> 00:16:02.805
And I'll, I'll leave it at that.

343
00:16:03.065 --> 00:16:04.765
So let me set up the scene

344
00:16:05.425 --> 00:16:08.725
and then they're going to present a scene from sincerely me,

345
00:16:08.725 --> 00:16:09.965
which is in Act one.

346
00:16:10.545 --> 00:16:14.125
So here's what has happened at the beginning of the show.

347
00:16:14.155 --> 00:16:16.205
Evan Hansen is really, really struggling

348
00:16:16.545 --> 00:16:18.165
and he is going to therapy

349
00:16:18.345 --> 00:16:19.965
and he's tasked with writing these letters.

350
00:16:20.355 --> 00:16:22.085
Dear Evan Hansen, how's your day gonna go?

351
00:16:22.085 --> 00:16:23.165
And he's written this letter

352
00:16:23.465 --> 00:16:26.365
and through a turn of events there's some confusion.

353
00:16:26.705 --> 00:16:28.205
And it is believed that, dear

354
00:16:28.315 --> 00:16:30.285
that e Evan Hansen has become good

355
00:16:30.285 --> 00:16:31.765
friends with Connor Murphy.

356
00:16:32.145 --> 00:16:34.565
That's not true, but people believe it.

357
00:16:35.025 --> 00:16:38.045
And through this turn of events, what's unfortunate is

358
00:16:38.045 --> 00:16:40.285
that Connor Murphy does die by suicide.

359
00:16:40.545 --> 00:16:42.965
His family and other people believe that he

360
00:16:42.965 --> 00:16:47.205
and Evan are super close and it just gets bigger and bigger.

361
00:16:47.545 --> 00:16:50.045
And it initially, Evan was not planning this.

362
00:16:50.065 --> 00:16:51.605
It was not something he set out to do.

363
00:16:52.105 --> 00:16:56.445
And in this scene what's tempting is this idea

364
00:16:56.445 --> 00:16:57.805
that you could change your life.

365
00:16:57.805 --> 00:16:59.285
You could have the things that you are missing

366
00:17:00.025 --> 00:17:02.885
if you just kind of didn't correct misinformation.

367
00:17:03.345 --> 00:17:06.645
And so Evan now has this great family in the Murphy's.

368
00:17:07.115 --> 00:17:10.165
He's also with the young lady of his dreams.

369
00:17:10.485 --> 00:17:14.085
Connor Murphy's younger sister, who's 16 is the girl

370
00:17:14.085 --> 00:17:15.645
that he has idolized his entire life.

371
00:17:15.985 --> 00:17:18.165
And so now he has an opportunity to get close to her.

372
00:17:18.785 --> 00:17:22.485
And so Evan at this point only has a couple friends though

373
00:17:22.485 --> 00:17:23.925
he doesn't really recognize him as friends,

374
00:17:23.935 --> 00:17:25.565
which is also something about the show.

375
00:17:25.565 --> 00:17:27.365
Sometimes we miss the stuff that we have,

376
00:17:27.655 --> 00:17:29.085
which is something we're exploring.

377
00:17:29.905 --> 00:17:32.085
And Evan is friends with a guy named Jared

378
00:17:32.185 --> 00:17:33.525
who also doesn't have a whole lot of friends.

379
00:17:33.865 --> 00:17:35.885
And they've decided to create emails

380
00:17:35.885 --> 00:17:39.125
because Evan has gotten himself into trouble trying to cover

381
00:17:39.145 --> 00:17:41.165
and make up this story about he, how close he

382
00:17:41.265 --> 00:17:43.725
and Connor were, that there's all these secret emails.

383
00:17:44.065 --> 00:17:46.245
And so he and Jared are getting together in this scene

384
00:17:46.665 --> 00:17:48.645
to write secret emails to prove

385
00:17:49.185 --> 00:17:50.765
how close he and Connor were.

386
00:17:52.005 --> 00:17:53.525
Connor comes back as a character,

387
00:17:53.525 --> 00:17:55.645
but the character is mainly in Evan's head

388
00:17:55.865 --> 00:17:57.165
and sometimes in Jared's head.

389
00:17:57.165 --> 00:17:59.965
So you'll see Connor, but Connor isn't really there

390
00:18:00.655 --> 00:18:02.445
right now, only in Evan's head.

391
00:18:02.745 --> 00:18:05.805
And so they're trying to come up with a way of, boy,

392
00:18:05.805 --> 00:18:08.445
we have a pretty good opportunity to make life really great.

393
00:18:08.465 --> 00:18:10.645
And all you gotta do is reinvent yourself a little bit

394
00:18:10.945 --> 00:18:12.525
and look what's possible.

395
00:18:12.795 --> 00:18:14.765
I'll let the actors come up, introduce themselves

396
00:18:15.065 --> 00:18:16.485
and then we'll get into sincerely me.

397
00:18:16.585 --> 00:18:18.645
I'm gonna attempt to play a background track

398
00:18:19.145 --> 00:18:20.285
and might not be the greatest,

399
00:18:20.285 --> 00:18:21.285
but we're gonna do the best we can

400
00:18:26.275 --> 00:18:27.275
<v Speaker 15>There.</v>

401
00:18:28.325 --> 00:18:29.785
<v Speaker 16>Do we need one more microphone, do you think?</v>

402
00:18:31.345 --> 00:18:35.905
<v Speaker 17>I think we're pretty loud. Yeah, we can. Alright,</v>

403
00:18:36.405 --> 00:18:38.425
<v Speaker 13>So tell him, tell him who you are and what role you play.</v>

404
00:18:38.925 --> 00:18:40.945
<v Speaker 15>I'm Jake Coten. I play Evan Hansen.</v>

405
00:18:43.885 --> 00:18:47.585
<v Speaker 16>I'm Josephine Hogan. I play Jared. I'm Jen Alvarado.</v>

406
00:18:47.585 --> 00:18:48.745
I I play Connor Murphy.

407
00:18:49.695 --> 00:18:51.785
<v Speaker 13>Alright. You're, do you want the chair or you guys?</v>

408
00:18:51.925 --> 00:18:53.505
You good with that? No, we're good. Alright.

409
00:18:53.505 --> 00:18:55.145
You just gonna do it? Alright. Alright, let's do it.

410
00:18:55.355 --> 00:18:56.905
Let's hope I get the right track here.

411
00:19:05.655 --> 00:19:09.145
<v Speaker 16>Dear Evan Hansen, we've been way too out of touch.</v>

412
00:19:10.365 --> 00:19:11.745
Things have been crazy

413
00:19:12.085 --> 00:19:14.625
and it sucks that we don't talk that much.

414
00:19:15.525 --> 00:19:18.825
But I should tell you that I think of you each night.

415
00:19:20.345 --> 00:19:24.465
I close my eyes and fantasize and pure white. Why

416
00:19:24.465 --> 00:19:25.385
<v Speaker 15>Would you write that? I'm just</v>

417
00:19:25.385 --> 00:19:26.385
<v Speaker 16>Trying to tell the</v>
<v Speaker 15>Truth.</v>

418
00:19:26.385 --> 00:19:28.265
Listen, if you're not gonna take this seriously, okay?

419
00:19:28.265 --> 00:19:29.945
You need to calm yourself. This has to be perfect.

420
00:19:29.945 --> 00:19:31.985
These emails have to prove that we were actually friends.

421
00:19:32.245 --> 00:19:34.385
If they have to be completely realistic,

422
00:19:35.105 --> 00:19:38.105
<v Speaker 16>I gotta tell your life without Jeff has been hard,</v>

423
00:19:38.255 --> 00:19:41.785
hard has been bad, has been rough, jenky

424
00:19:42.285 --> 00:19:44.505
and I miss talking about life

425
00:19:44.605 --> 00:19:46.745
and other stuff. Very specific.

426
00:19:46.895 --> 00:19:50.345
<v Speaker 15>Shut up.</v>
<v Speaker 16>I like my parents, says that</v>

427
00:19:50.905 --> 00:19:54.225
I love my parents, but each day is another fight.

428
00:19:55.445 --> 00:19:57.145
If I stop smoking drugs,

429
00:19:57.215 --> 00:20:00.745
that everything might be outright smoking drugs

430
00:20:00.975 --> 00:20:03.345
<v Speaker 15>Just fixes</v>
<v Speaker 16>Realistic about this</v>

431
00:20:03.345 --> 00:20:04.425
Don't even sound like honor.

432
00:20:04.705 --> 00:20:06.305
<v Speaker 15>I wanna show that I was like a good friend</v>

433
00:20:06.305 --> 00:20:07.345
that I was trying to help him get better.

434
00:20:07.405 --> 00:20:08.405
You know?

435
00:20:08.805 --> 00:20:13.545
<v Speaker 16>Oh my God, if I stop smoking, crack, crack.</v>

436
00:20:13.925 --> 00:20:18.105
If I stop smoking pot, then everything might be outright.

437
00:20:19.055 --> 00:20:23.585
I'll take your advice, try to be more nice.

438
00:20:23.935 --> 00:20:26.185
I'll turn it around. Wait and see

439
00:20:28.535 --> 00:20:30.505
because all that it takes is a little,

440
00:20:33.535 --> 00:20:34.585
it's easy to change.

441
00:20:36.565 --> 00:20:37.905
Oh, 10 Charlie,

442
00:20:38.525 --> 00:20:41.785
all you gotta do is just believe you can be

443
00:20:41.925 --> 00:20:46.545
who you wanna. Are we done yet?

444
00:20:47.085 --> 00:20:48.125
<v Speaker 15>I can't just give them one email.</v>

445
00:20:48.365 --> 00:20:50.165
I wanna sure that I was like a good friend. Okay.

446
00:20:50.165 --> 00:20:51.805
Please stop. Hyper. I'm not hyperventilating.

447
00:20:53.025 --> 00:20:56.845
I'm not having any trouble breathing. Dear Connor Murphy.

448
00:20:57.185 --> 00:21:01.485
Yes. I also miss our talk. Stop doing drugs.

449
00:21:01.595 --> 00:21:04.845
Just try to take deep breaths and go on walks.

450
00:21:05.665 --> 00:21:09.085
I'm sending pictures of the most amazing trees.

451
00:21:09.465 --> 00:21:13.885
No, you'll be obsessed with all my forest expertise.

452
00:21:14.365 --> 00:21:17.285
Absolutely not, dude, I'm proud of you.

453
00:21:17.755 --> 00:21:21.005
Just keep pushing through. You're turning around.

454
00:21:21.605 --> 00:21:23.285
I can see just switch.

455
00:21:24.995 --> 00:21:27.525
Because all that it takes is little quick

456
00:21:28.065 --> 00:21:30.605
and it's easy

457
00:21:30.665 --> 00:21:33.805
to change if you give it your attention.

458
00:21:34.945 --> 00:21:38.045
All you gotta do is just believe you can be

459
00:21:38.145 --> 00:21:39.325
who you want to be.

460
00:21:40.175 --> 00:21:43.885
Since me, my sister's hot. What the hell?

461
00:21:46.345 --> 00:21:50.885
Thanks for every note she said. You're Connor Murphy.

462
00:21:51.345 --> 00:21:53.285
I'm just glad to be your friend.

463
00:21:54.705 --> 00:21:58.565
Our friendship goes beyond your average kind of bond.

464
00:21:59.505 --> 00:22:03.685
But not because we're gay. No, not because we're gay.

465
00:22:04.385 --> 00:22:06.045
We are close, but not that way.

466
00:22:06.545 --> 00:22:10.005
The only man that I love is my dad.

467
00:22:10.715 --> 00:22:14.125
Well anyway, you're getting better every day.

468
00:22:14.585 --> 00:22:19.045
I'm getting better every day. Keep getting better every day.

469
00:22:20.105 --> 00:22:21.285
Hey, hey, hey, hey.

470
00:22:21.745 --> 00:22:25.565
You know that it takes this little free invention.

471
00:22:26.795 --> 00:22:30.405
It's easy to change and give it your your a attention.

472
00:22:31.545 --> 00:22:35.565
All you gotta do is just believe you can be who you want.

473
00:22:35.745 --> 00:22:40.565
Be sincerely miss you dearly.

474
00:22:42.475 --> 00:22:43.965
<v Speaker 3>Sincerely me.</v>

475
00:22:45.275 --> 00:22:48.445
<v Speaker 15>Sincerely me. Sincerely me.</v>

476
00:22:51.355 --> 00:22:52.355
Sincerely me.

477
00:23:16.985 --> 00:23:19.365
<v Speaker 1>Should we bring up, they should come and see.</v>

478
00:23:19.535 --> 00:23:22.165
Would you be willing to sit for a few minutes with us?

479
00:23:22.185 --> 00:23:24.085
Oh, we might have. As is our tradi.

480
00:23:24.105 --> 00:23:26.765
You can get a chair as is our tradition

481
00:23:26.955 --> 00:23:28.005
with the NPS spotlight.

482
00:23:28.005 --> 00:23:31.125
Sometimes members have questions, if that's all right.

483
00:23:31.275 --> 00:23:32.485
Yeah. With you all. That's

484
00:23:32.485 --> 00:23:33.485
<v Speaker 15>Perfect.</v>

485
00:23:33.485 --> 00:23:33.805
That's great. Alright,

486
00:23:34.195 --> 00:23:36.845
<v Speaker 1>Does anybody have any questions or comments? Dr. Fugman,</v>

487
00:23:37.695 --> 00:23:39.725
<v Speaker 18>First of all, you guys are amazing, thank you.</v>

488
00:23:40.835 --> 00:23:45.685
Very talented. And the play that you all chose to be part

489
00:23:45.685 --> 00:23:47.605
of is so important.

490
00:23:48.705 --> 00:23:51.165
And I'm wondering if you each wanna share something

491
00:23:51.165 --> 00:23:54.685
that you've learned, something that you may wanna advice,

492
00:23:54.685 --> 00:23:57.405
you might wanna give a real friend, not a pretend friend,

493
00:23:57.405 --> 00:23:58.925
but a real friend that you have based on

494
00:23:58.925 --> 00:24:01.925
what you learned from being part of this play.

495
00:24:06.125 --> 00:24:09.205
<v Speaker 19>I think that it's good to just, I dunno, stick up</v>

496
00:24:09.205 --> 00:24:10.925
for your friends and like be there for them.

497
00:24:12.285 --> 00:24:14.465
And it's hard 'cause that's sort of

498
00:24:14.465 --> 00:24:16.465
what the main message is, is that like hope

499
00:24:16.465 --> 00:24:18.985
and it'll be with each other through it.

500
00:24:19.015 --> 00:24:21.465
Talking to the microphone, I'll,

501
00:24:21.935 --> 00:24:23.105
I'll talk into the microphone.

502
00:24:23.765 --> 00:24:25.625
You have to help your friends

503
00:24:26.165 --> 00:24:29.345
and be with them when like life gets hard.

504
00:24:29.735 --> 00:24:30.945
Yeah. Yep.

505
00:24:32.145 --> 00:24:33.345
<v Speaker 20>I think sort of one of the themes</v>

506
00:24:33.345 --> 00:24:35.545
that at least my character Evan learns is that like,

507
00:24:35.735 --> 00:24:37.265
it's better to be true to yourself

508
00:24:37.725 --> 00:24:39.905
and be honest than it is to lie.

509
00:24:40.425 --> 00:24:42.785
'cause not to spoil the show.

510
00:24:43.285 --> 00:24:45.705
And a lot of the things that he

511
00:24:46.825 --> 00:24:50.315
gets from not telling the truth are not real

512
00:24:50.455 --> 00:24:53.955
and are not like continuously attainable,

513
00:24:54.655 --> 00:24:55.755
you know? Yeah.

514
00:24:56.145 --> 00:25:00.315
<v Speaker 16>Yeah. I think one thing that's really important is like,</v>

515
00:25:00.315 --> 00:25:02.075
mostly just don't lie.

516
00:25:02.435 --> 00:25:05.955
'cause a lot of lies they can grow

517
00:25:05.955 --> 00:25:07.795
and fester into something you don't want.

518
00:25:08.735 --> 00:25:11.675
You know, like me being your best

519
00:25:11.775 --> 00:25:12.955
pal in the whole wide world.

520
00:25:13.035 --> 00:25:14.995
I don't know this kid, I don't know that guy.

521
00:25:16.905 --> 00:25:17.915
<v Speaker 19>Yeah. Yep, yep, yep.</v>

522
00:25:18.525 --> 00:25:20.395
<v Speaker 1>Other questions or comments from the committee?</v>

523
00:25:22.735 --> 00:25:26.235
So I'll just say, and I mentioned it

524
00:25:26.235 --> 00:25:29.755
before, dear Van Hansen is my favorite show

525
00:25:30.655 --> 00:25:32.635
and was fortunate enough to see it

526
00:25:32.705 --> 00:25:34.155
with the original cast on Broadway.

527
00:25:34.155 --> 00:25:36.635
Oh, that's really cool. And is a big, my wife

528
00:25:36.915 --> 00:25:39.235
and I have been, when we found out

529
00:25:39.235 --> 00:25:40.595
that Dear Evan Enhancement was coming to the high school,

530
00:25:40.705 --> 00:25:44.635
it's like, we, we are gonna be, it's, we're so excited

531
00:25:44.635 --> 00:25:46.515
to come see it, this performance.

532
00:25:46.775 --> 00:25:48.155
I'm like, I shouldn't say it.

533
00:25:48.155 --> 00:25:51.235
My dad might be watching like, it's like the chills.

534
00:25:51.235 --> 00:25:54.075
He would say goosebumps the whole time. So it's right.

535
00:25:54.075 --> 00:25:57.555
Like I mute. Yeah. It's, it's awesome.

536
00:25:57.855 --> 00:25:58.875
And I can't wait to see it.

537
00:25:58.875 --> 00:26:00.035
And it's such an important show

538
00:26:00.035 --> 00:26:02.075
and I would encourage anybody if you're not familiar

539
00:26:02.105 --> 00:26:05.275
with it, to, to go see it.

540
00:26:05.305 --> 00:26:08.355
It's an important show with a really great message.

541
00:26:08.425 --> 00:26:11.395
It's also, there's a lot of social media that plays a part.

542
00:26:11.455 --> 00:26:13.595
I'm not, I'm not spoiling anything I don't think,

543
00:26:13.935 --> 00:26:18.635
but it's, it's really good for this time

544
00:26:18.825 --> 00:26:19.955
that we are all living in.

545
00:26:20.175 --> 00:26:22.035
And I hope everybody goes to see it.

546
00:26:22.035 --> 00:26:23.435
Thank you for, for being here.

547
00:26:24.315 --> 00:26:26.835
I can't remember the last time we had such a great musical

548
00:26:26.835 --> 00:26:28.075
performance at a school committee meeting.

549
00:26:28.495 --> 00:26:31.875
So I appreciate you all being here.

550
00:26:31.975 --> 00:26:33.435
I'm sure you wanna stay for the rest of the meeting,

551
00:26:34.735 --> 00:26:35.995
but if you don't have, but if you

552
00:26:35.995 --> 00:26:37.395
don't, that's okay as well.

553
00:26:38.655 --> 00:26:40.195
So thank you. Thank you.

554
00:26:40.195 --> 00:26:41.715
<v Speaker 19>Thank you. Thank you so much.</v>

555
00:26:47.475 --> 00:26:49.325
<v Speaker 3>It's so good. It's beautiful. Yeah.</v>

556
00:26:51.385 --> 00:26:54.605
That's not an easy thing. Thank you. Thank you.

557
00:27:00.865 --> 00:27:04.045
<v Speaker 1>All right. All right, we're gonna go,</v>

558
00:27:06.695 --> 00:27:08.845
we're gonna go a little out of order tonight.

559
00:27:10.365 --> 00:27:11.405
I know. Exciting, right?

560
00:27:11.505 --> 00:27:13.245
You didn't see this coming plot twist.

561
00:27:14.295 --> 00:27:17.645
We're gonna jump down to section eight to the,

562
00:27:19.625 --> 00:27:21.365
to the high school practice field.

563
00:27:23.275 --> 00:27:26.125
Does it make sense to do eight a first?

564
00:27:27.885 --> 00:27:30.285
Probably just to bring us up to speed. What do you think?

565
00:27:30.285 --> 00:27:31.045
Sure. Is that all right with you?

566
00:27:31.055 --> 00:27:32.165
We'll be, it's fairly fast.

567
00:27:38.485 --> 00:27:39.545
All right. So we're gonna do the,

568
00:27:39.925 --> 00:27:42.305
the original contract scope and financial summary.

569
00:27:42.325 --> 00:27:43.325
Mr. Gill, is that you?

570
00:27:45.335 --> 00:27:47.465
<v Speaker 21>Sure. So if we can go to the next slide.</v>

571
00:27:48.325 --> 00:27:51.625
You know, we started this in, in May.

572
00:27:51.845 --> 00:27:54.145
We got approval for design work.

573
00:27:54.965 --> 00:27:59.145
We contracted with tying bonds for about just under 25,000.

574
00:27:59.515 --> 00:28:01.345
We've pretty much spent almost all of that.

575
00:28:04.365 --> 00:28:08.185
You know, we've got some work that, that, that moved.

576
00:28:08.185 --> 00:28:10.225
If we go to the next slide, the prior year background,

577
00:28:10.225 --> 00:28:12.345
the superintendent and town administrator issued a joint

578
00:28:12.345 --> 00:28:14.945
memorandum addressing practice field design.

579
00:28:15.005 --> 00:28:18.345
It was studied and given some options

580
00:28:19.365 --> 00:28:23.225
and some

581
00:28:23.225 --> 00:28:26.505
of those materials were shared back in February of 26.

582
00:28:27.205 --> 00:28:30.705
If we go to the next slide, we have six items here

583
00:28:32.345 --> 00:28:35.625
with the joint memorandum executed contract.

584
00:28:35.625 --> 00:28:36.905
We had a purchase order.

585
00:28:37.045 --> 00:28:40.945
We paid for the field study and design preliminary concepts.

586
00:28:41.335 --> 00:28:45.785
Basically still a rectangular field lined with for football,

587
00:28:45.805 --> 00:28:47.625
soccer, field hockey and lacrosse.

588
00:28:48.485 --> 00:28:51.785
And then we had a, a presentation from tying bonds

589
00:28:54.135 --> 00:28:55.465
current capital plan.

590
00:28:55.765 --> 00:28:58.185
It was in the FY 27 to 31 plan.

591
00:28:58.315 --> 00:29:00.745
It'll be in FY 28 to 32,

592
00:29:02.315 --> 00:29:05.185
which is still in the, in kind of the draft phase.

593
00:29:05.185 --> 00:29:08.945
It'll be for about 2.5 million. That does include lights.

594
00:29:09.285 --> 00:29:13.785
And that price also includes the synthetic portion

595
00:29:13.965 --> 00:29:14.985
of the field as well.

596
00:29:17.895 --> 00:29:22.625
Says relationship there. Yep.

597
00:29:22.625 --> 00:29:25.865
Still the 200 K and the approved allocation.

598
00:29:26.125 --> 00:29:29.585
And then we've basically spent the initial,

599
00:29:29.765 --> 00:29:31.905
the initial design amount to bring us to a budget.

600
00:29:32.605 --> 00:29:34.985
Almost all of it. We spent about 97%.

601
00:29:35.125 --> 00:29:37.985
So the balance is still available to contribute

602
00:29:37.985 --> 00:29:40.065
to the design and the construction of the field.

603
00:29:40.725 --> 00:29:42.805
And that's all over

604
00:29:42.805 --> 00:29:45.085
and above the $2.5 million request,

605
00:29:45.535 --> 00:29:48.125
which is a fairly conservative estimate for the budget.

606
00:29:50.625 --> 00:29:55.245
If we jump to slide nine, we've got it here on

607
00:29:55.345 --> 00:29:57.285
for a school committee vote to decide.

608
00:29:57.345 --> 00:29:58.525
But if you wanted to decide

609
00:29:58.545 --> 00:30:01.685
before then, that'd be fine to

610
00:30:03.465 --> 00:30:06.405
put it on before town meeting to vote

611
00:30:06.945 --> 00:30:08.045
to proceed with a project.

612
00:30:08.385 --> 00:30:11.045
And it's kind of up to this committee if you wanna recommend

613
00:30:11.355 --> 00:30:13.725
whether it's a synthetic field or natural grass.

614
00:30:14.855 --> 00:30:17.365
We've got the athletic director

615
00:30:17.705 --> 00:30:21.245
and art goodin, the town's, fields

616
00:30:21.825 --> 00:30:23.965
and recreation fields

617
00:30:23.965 --> 00:30:26.485
and natural resources director here

618
00:30:27.305 --> 00:30:28.965
to opine on that in greater detail.

619
00:30:30.945 --> 00:30:34.565
But the, the short of it is, you know, this was something

620
00:30:34.565 --> 00:30:36.525
that was asked for half of this committee was,

621
00:30:36.825 --> 00:30:39.325
was different when it was originally brought up.

622
00:30:39.685 --> 00:30:42.485
'cause it was my, my first, first few months here

623
00:30:43.425 --> 00:30:46.205
to pursue it because the athletic director

624
00:30:46.225 --> 00:30:49.205
and folks in in town fair number

625
00:30:49.205 --> 00:30:50.445
of kids have had a hard time

626
00:30:51.195 --> 00:30:54.365
with our athletic teams always being able to find consistent

627
00:30:54.785 --> 00:30:56.925
and safe practice and play space.

628
00:30:58.785 --> 00:31:01.325
So we, we asked for it back then,

629
00:31:01.345 --> 00:31:03.005
and then it sort of got tabled.

630
00:31:03.065 --> 00:31:05.765
But I think the issue still remains.

631
00:31:05.785 --> 00:31:08.965
And with that, I guess I would turn it over to

632
00:31:10.755 --> 00:31:12.725
Matt Breneman and, and I heim.

633
00:31:12.955 --> 00:31:15.125
<v Speaker 1>Okay. And just as a reminder,</v>

634
00:31:16.185 --> 00:31:18.045
and you can, you can see the slide.

635
00:31:19.385 --> 00:31:22.125
Our plan for tonight is the presentation for Mr. Brennaman.

636
00:31:22.945 --> 00:31:24.205
And then committee will have the

637
00:31:24.205 --> 00:31:25.365
opportunity to ask questions.

638
00:31:25.625 --> 00:31:28.165
We will not be taking public comment or question tonight.

639
00:31:29.425 --> 00:31:31.365
We will on the December 7th meeting,

640
00:31:31.665 --> 00:31:33.125
the committee will have an opportunity

641
00:31:33.145 --> 00:31:35.325
to discuss this on January 11th.

642
00:31:35.415 --> 00:31:38.805
We'll have a public forum where anybody from the public can,

643
00:31:39.065 --> 00:31:42.245
can ask questions, make their comments, all of those things.

644
00:31:42.665 --> 00:31:44.405
And we are tentatively scheduled

645
00:31:44.405 --> 00:31:46.325
to vote on our recommendation at the end

646
00:31:46.325 --> 00:31:47.445
of January, January 25th.

647
00:31:47.835 --> 00:31:48.925
Anytime between now

648
00:31:48.925 --> 00:31:49.925
and then, members

649
00:31:49.925 --> 00:31:53.325
of the public can ob can certainly email the committee their

650
00:31:53.485 --> 00:31:56.845
comments or questions on this particular topic.

651
00:31:58.785 --> 00:32:00.645
And before we get started, I have to,

652
00:32:00.715 --> 00:32:02.165
this is a big moment in history.

653
00:32:02.715 --> 00:32:05.205
Five mats at the table at one time.

654
00:32:05.345 --> 00:32:09.365
That's gotta be a record of Matts in one table. Yeah.

655
00:32:09.365 --> 00:32:12.925
Alright. All right Mr. Breman, welcome. Thanks

656
00:32:12.925 --> 00:32:13.925
<v Speaker 22>For having me.</v>

657
00:32:13.925 --> 00:32:15.205
Appreciate it. Now I,

658
00:32:15.365 --> 00:32:19.045
I thought it was a favor putting me up in the agenda,

659
00:32:19.105 --> 00:32:21.245
but following that crew is probably a little unfair.

660
00:32:21.965 --> 00:32:24.885
I don't expect to be wowed like they just did.

661
00:32:24.885 --> 00:32:27.205
Unfortunately, he was standing over here.

662
00:32:28.325 --> 00:32:31.525
I was gonna wrap it, but my throat's a little sore.

663
00:32:32.585 --> 00:32:34.765
So yeah, thanks. And, and Custo, I don't know how many

664
00:32:34.765 --> 00:32:36.325
of you, everyone knows Custodial,

665
00:32:36.325 --> 00:32:37.845
who's our assistant athletic director.

666
00:32:38.305 --> 00:32:40.605
And then obviously Art Goodin is a supervisor

667
00:32:41.205 --> 00:32:42.525
in charge of land facilities.

668
00:32:42.645 --> 00:32:44.685
Forestry Natural Resources is here.

669
00:32:45.825 --> 00:32:48.725
You know, he's done a lot of work researching.

670
00:32:48.725 --> 00:32:50.245
This is an expert in the field as well.

671
00:32:51.905 --> 00:32:55.405
So sort of the goal of this is to kind of give you

672
00:32:56.085 --> 00:32:57.885
a big picture overview of

673
00:32:58.065 --> 00:32:59.645
how we're currently using the fields,

674
00:33:00.705 --> 00:33:02.645
the limitations we currently face,

675
00:33:03.785 --> 00:33:06.165
and then, you know, what opportunities

676
00:33:06.745 --> 00:33:09.085
and needs we have sort of moving forward.

677
00:33:09.905 --> 00:33:12.445
So what I'm gonna hopefully do is just sort of start with a,

678
00:33:12.945 --> 00:33:14.245
how we're using the fields right now,

679
00:33:15.795 --> 00:33:17.165
talk about their limitations

680
00:33:17.665 --> 00:33:19.445
and then we'll get into kind of needs at the end.

681
00:33:19.545 --> 00:33:22.165
So you, you can see in the, the image up there,

682
00:33:22.185 --> 00:33:26.085
but you know, sort of our main facilities we use

683
00:33:27.105 --> 00:33:28.525
and not, we're not limited to these,

684
00:33:28.525 --> 00:33:29.965
but the Memorial Stadium complex

685
00:33:30.025 --> 00:33:31.165
is kind of what we're talking about.

686
00:33:32.225 --> 00:33:35.765
So sort of right center there with the track

687
00:33:35.765 --> 00:33:38.365
around it is the synthetic turf field.

688
00:33:39.585 --> 00:33:41.765
That's our most utilized field.

689
00:33:41.765 --> 00:33:46.245
And we'll talk about it a little bit more in to the left of

690
00:33:46.245 --> 00:33:48.125
that is the, is the field we're gonna spend some time

691
00:33:48.125 --> 00:33:49.885
talking about, especially the limitations of it.

692
00:33:49.885 --> 00:33:51.605
That's the practice field.

693
00:33:51.825 --> 00:33:54.565
And you can even really see a little bit from this picture

694
00:33:54.655 --> 00:33:56.365
above, you know, right down the middle

695
00:33:56.475 --> 00:33:57.685
it's, you know, it's kind of dirt.

696
00:33:57.945 --> 00:34:00.525
And then there are two other multi-use grass fields

697
00:34:01.235 --> 00:34:04.885
that we still use for competitions and practices.

698
00:34:04.885 --> 00:34:08.325
The, the one sort of in the bottom left center is

699
00:34:08.475 --> 00:34:10.805
what we'll refer to as the varsity soccer field.

700
00:34:11.145 --> 00:34:14.845
And then the other one kind of along West Street is what,

701
00:34:14.845 --> 00:34:17.245
what I call the, what we call the frost soccer field.

702
00:34:18.505 --> 00:34:21.645
So that's a big picture. Look at the stadium.

703
00:34:21.825 --> 00:34:22.885
The facilities we have,

704
00:34:23.145 --> 00:34:25.405
we do have other fields we use in both

705
00:34:25.435 --> 00:34:27.845
seasons at the high school.

706
00:34:27.945 --> 00:34:32.165
We utilize the softball fields both during the fall

707
00:34:32.265 --> 00:34:35.405
for soccer as well as a little bit of football at times.

708
00:34:36.165 --> 00:34:38.565
And then obviously softball in the spring.

709
00:34:39.465 --> 00:34:42.005
And then we do use some offsite facilities.

710
00:34:42.005 --> 00:34:44.045
We'll talk about coal a little bit more.

711
00:34:44.345 --> 00:34:47.165
And then we'll also talk about Kennedy a little bit as well.

712
00:34:48.025 --> 00:34:49.445
So who uses the fields?

713
00:34:49.705 --> 00:34:54.285
We have 22 total teams, upwards of about 800 athletes

714
00:34:54.285 --> 00:34:56.445
that use the complex in the fields.

715
00:34:56.445 --> 00:34:58.165
Obviously you heard a little bit earlier,

716
00:34:58.515 --> 00:35:01.325
outdoor track is the biggest number, you know,

717
00:35:01.325 --> 00:35:05.325
they use in the spring as well as in the winter and fall.

718
00:35:06.225 --> 00:35:10.125
Our outdoor track cross country teams use the track soccer.

719
00:35:10.225 --> 00:35:13.405
We have six different teams across both genders.

720
00:35:13.405 --> 00:35:17.325
We have, you know, varsity JV and freshmen lacrosse.

721
00:35:17.345 --> 00:35:18.685
We have five total teams.

722
00:35:19.285 --> 00:35:22.725
We only have two levels for our women's teams football.

723
00:35:22.725 --> 00:35:25.685
We have three full teams Unified track,

724
00:35:26.365 --> 00:35:27.365
which is a co-ed team.

725
00:35:27.425 --> 00:35:28.965
We have upwards of 80 kids.

726
00:35:29.615 --> 00:35:31.085
Field hockey, we have three levels.

727
00:35:31.625 --> 00:35:34.165
And then our ultimate Frisbee teams as well,

728
00:35:34.165 --> 00:35:35.325
which we have two levels up.

729
00:35:35.425 --> 00:35:40.365
So it's a lot of different teams, both genders across spring

730
00:35:40.665 --> 00:35:42.005
and fall.

731
00:35:42.865 --> 00:35:45.125
And a high number of athletes utilize these.

732
00:35:45.225 --> 00:35:48.365
And, and in terms of like the length of time

733
00:35:48.425 --> 00:35:49.965
and we start using 'em, you know,

734
00:35:49.965 --> 00:35:51.125
if you start in the calendar year,

735
00:35:51.345 --> 00:35:52.885
we start the third Monday in March

736
00:35:53.425 --> 00:35:55.085
and go through the end of June.

737
00:35:55.555 --> 00:35:58.365
There's a little bit of rest time on the fields in July.

738
00:35:59.185 --> 00:36:02.085
And then we start back up in mid-August

739
00:36:02.085 --> 00:36:03.125
and go through Thanksgiving.

740
00:36:04.525 --> 00:36:06.025
So sort of near constant use.

741
00:36:06.125 --> 00:36:08.505
So looking at, you know, sort of

742
00:36:08.505 --> 00:36:10.745
how we utilize the fields on a daily basis.

743
00:36:11.005 --> 00:36:15.305
And I will say we are giving this from the perspective

744
00:36:15.445 --> 00:36:17.865
of Natick High School, especially in native public schools.

745
00:36:18.285 --> 00:36:19.665
We didn't really address youth.

746
00:36:19.785 --> 00:36:20.865
I mean, we can answer some

747
00:36:20.865 --> 00:36:22.705
of those questions if you have 'em.

748
00:36:22.805 --> 00:36:24.185
But when we're talking about, you know,

749
00:36:24.185 --> 00:36:26.545
right here we're talking about Nat High School,

750
00:36:26.545 --> 00:36:27.865
especially in native public schools.

751
00:36:27.925 --> 00:36:30.105
So during the day both fall

752
00:36:30.105 --> 00:36:34.265
and spraying our PE classes, utilized the turf

753
00:36:35.085 --> 00:36:37.905
pretty consistently, you know, that's obviously impacted

754
00:36:38.005 --> 00:36:40.585
by weather and it's impacted by their curriculum.

755
00:36:41.285 --> 00:36:44.385
You know, I would say we're averaging about two to four days

756
00:36:44.765 --> 00:36:46.945
of PE use, you know, sort of Monday

757
00:36:46.965 --> 00:36:49.305
to Friday at the facility.

758
00:36:49.685 --> 00:36:52.305
And then after school, basically at 2 45

759
00:36:52.845 --> 00:36:54.905
Natick high school athletics takes over

760
00:36:56.365 --> 00:36:58.585
and we're using the entire

761
00:36:59.145 --> 00:37:03.825
facility basically from 2 45 till eight to nine ish.

762
00:37:03.945 --> 00:37:07.665
I mean, generally our practices are going from 2 45, 3

763
00:37:07.665 --> 00:37:09.985
o'clock to five o'clock, five 15.

764
00:37:10.525 --> 00:37:12.825
And then five 15 we start our games

765
00:37:13.615 --> 00:37:16.865
with either a sub varsity game or a varsity game.

766
00:37:16.885 --> 00:37:19.625
And we're usually on the field till about 8 30, 9 o'clock.

767
00:37:20.565 --> 00:37:22.425
And generally the way the week runs Monday

768
00:37:22.445 --> 00:37:24.545
to Wednesday is field hockey games.

769
00:37:24.545 --> 00:37:26.585
Tuesday and Thursday soccer games.

770
00:37:27.125 --> 00:37:30.785
And then Fridays, you know, we have our, our football games.

771
00:37:30.965 --> 00:37:32.865
But that ebbs and flows a little bit

772
00:37:32.925 --> 00:37:33.985
as we go through the season.

773
00:37:35.045 --> 00:37:38.265
In the spring. Again, the day is, you know, daily use

774
00:37:38.265 --> 00:37:41.385
by PE class is the same, you know, in the spring

775
00:37:42.285 --> 00:37:44.545
we have our lacrosse teams out there, usually Tuesday,

776
00:37:44.985 --> 00:37:47.625
Thursday, Friday, outdoor track, unified track,

777
00:37:47.785 --> 00:37:50.185
and then also our middle school track teams utilize it

778
00:37:52.045 --> 00:37:53.385
and linked in there.

779
00:37:53.385 --> 00:37:54.625
Hopefully you guys took a look.

780
00:37:55.015 --> 00:37:59.265
There's some documents that show how we're using the,

781
00:37:59.405 --> 00:38:02.065
the fields right now, sort of on a day-to-day basis.

782
00:38:02.165 --> 00:38:04.025
And you can see where all our teams are.

783
00:38:04.405 --> 00:38:07.425
You know, we're, we're using every single field up there

784
00:38:07.725 --> 00:38:08.985
pretty much every day.

785
00:38:09.885 --> 00:38:11.585
And then just sort of an overview of

786
00:38:11.585 --> 00:38:13.065
what we do on a week to week basis.

787
00:38:16.645 --> 00:38:17.655
Turf access to native.

788
00:38:17.715 --> 00:38:20.375
And, and the thing I'll say, I I,

789
00:38:20.415 --> 00:38:22.575
I don't think I put it in here, but I think over the last

790
00:38:22.645 --> 00:38:25.095
year 98%

791
00:38:25.315 --> 00:38:29.135
of our varsity games have been played on synthetic turf.

792
00:38:29.555 --> 00:38:32.455
So the reality is that's where our coaches want to practice.

793
00:38:32.575 --> 00:38:33.575
I mean, you know, Matt

794
00:38:33.575 --> 00:38:35.205
and I meet with the coaches all the time

795
00:38:35.665 --> 00:38:38.285
and one of their first questions typically is

796
00:38:38.625 --> 00:38:41.685
how can we get more time on the turf?

797
00:38:42.425 --> 00:38:45.365
And we try and balance it equitably as best we can.

798
00:38:46.085 --> 00:38:47.645
We try and get all the teams out there.

799
00:38:47.665 --> 00:38:49.765
We start with a varsity, you know, focus.

800
00:38:49.765 --> 00:38:51.805
Obviously we look at who's got games coming up

801
00:38:51.805 --> 00:38:52.925
and where they're at in their season.

802
00:38:53.905 --> 00:38:58.005
But we're trying, you know, our coaches want more time on

803
00:38:58.005 --> 00:38:59.445
the turf rather than less certainly.

804
00:39:00.145 --> 00:39:03.325
So our synthetic turf access in Natick, you know,

805
00:39:03.325 --> 00:39:04.845
we have three different fields.

806
00:39:05.485 --> 00:39:07.485
Memorial Stadium, which is our, you know,

807
00:39:07.485 --> 00:39:08.805
obviously our primary stadium.

808
00:39:09.265 --> 00:39:11.965
We have first and full priority there.

809
00:39:12.385 --> 00:39:14.125
And again we have full access to, to it.

810
00:39:14.125 --> 00:39:16.525
And we're using it basically from the beginning

811
00:39:16.525 --> 00:39:18.805
of the school day till eight, nine o'clock at night.

812
00:39:20.315 --> 00:39:22.005
Cold turf is a one, is one

813
00:39:22.005 --> 00:39:23.845
that we have some limited access to.

814
00:39:23.925 --> 00:39:25.365
I don't know how many of you are familiar with.

815
00:39:25.705 --> 00:39:29.405
So Cole, there was significant investment in that project

816
00:39:29.505 --> 00:39:30.885
by Natick Soccer Club.

817
00:39:31.785 --> 00:39:34.285
So they have a memorandum on understanding with the town

818
00:39:34.285 --> 00:39:38.925
that coal turf, the town access

819
00:39:39.225 --> 00:39:41.485
and runs from basically eight to four

820
00:39:41.865 --> 00:39:45.045
and then from four on Natick Soccer Club has priority there.

821
00:39:45.065 --> 00:39:47.885
Now I, I will be honest, Natick Soccer Club has been a very

822
00:39:47.885 --> 00:39:49.325
good partner with us

823
00:39:49.825 --> 00:39:53.325
and they're willing to work with us in terms of sort

824
00:39:53.325 --> 00:39:55.085
of collaborating and giving us more access

825
00:39:55.085 --> 00:39:56.125
than just four o'clock.

826
00:39:56.195 --> 00:39:58.925
Because if we only had it to four o'clock, it,

827
00:39:58.985 --> 00:40:00.445
it would be sort of devastating

828
00:40:00.465 --> 00:40:02.245
to our programs to be honest.

829
00:40:02.905 --> 00:40:04.685
So what we do is Tuesday, Thursday

830
00:40:05.195 --> 00:40:07.845
when our field hockey team doesn't have games,

831
00:40:08.195 --> 00:40:10.805
they usually give us till 4 30, 4 45 out there.

832
00:40:11.405 --> 00:40:14.125
Monday, Wednesday, Friday we're out there till 4, 4 15,

833
00:40:15.025 --> 00:40:16.765
you know, and sometimes there's some flexibility

834
00:40:16.765 --> 00:40:17.885
to have a little more access.

835
00:40:17.985 --> 00:40:22.205
But we do have limited access to Cole Kennedy Middle School,

836
00:40:22.745 --> 00:40:24.365
Natick Public Schools has full

837
00:40:24.365 --> 00:40:25.565
access to it, whatever we use.

838
00:40:25.585 --> 00:40:27.965
But it's a middle school priority right now.

839
00:40:29.625 --> 00:40:34.045
It is used by the Kennedy ASAP program after school.

840
00:40:34.505 --> 00:40:37.845
And it is used by the Kennedy Middle School as well

841
00:40:37.845 --> 00:40:41.485
as Wilson to some degree middle school programs,

842
00:40:41.535 --> 00:40:44.565
field hockey and cross country utilize that space as well

843
00:40:44.805 --> 00:40:47.445
as their recreational sports activities.

844
00:40:47.825 --> 00:40:49.965
So the reality is, we, we get at,

845
00:40:50.155 --> 00:40:52.805
when I say we Natick High School, get sort

846
00:40:52.805 --> 00:40:55.845
of limited access there, our primarily we're using that

847
00:40:56.515 --> 00:40:59.205
Mondays and Wednesdays at like 4 30, 4 45

848
00:40:59.225 --> 00:41:00.725
for our freshman field hockey games.

849
00:41:01.225 --> 00:41:03.885
And then every once in a while on Fridays, our field,

850
00:41:03.905 --> 00:41:05.645
our varsity field hockey team will use it

851
00:41:05.825 --> 00:41:06.885
if it's not booked up.

852
00:41:07.505 --> 00:41:10.565
So that's sort of our synthetic turf access across Natick.

853
00:41:13.265 --> 00:41:15.765
So I obviously, the big thing here for us is

854
00:41:16.355 --> 00:41:19.885
that our current field space has limitations

855
00:41:19.885 --> 00:41:23.245
that impact our ability to function as well as we could.

856
00:41:24.825 --> 00:41:28.005
We don't have enough space on grass

857
00:41:28.225 --> 00:41:30.965
or turf to meet our needs.

858
00:41:31.785 --> 00:41:36.085
We have little to no full field access for our teams.

859
00:41:36.185 --> 00:41:38.405
If you look at any of those charts, you can see that

860
00:41:38.405 --> 00:41:42.245
during practice time there is almost no time where

861
00:41:43.205 --> 00:41:47.285
a single team has access to the turf field by themselves.

862
00:41:48.145 --> 00:41:50.805
Our closest to that is our football team.

863
00:41:51.285 --> 00:41:55.965
A couple hours a week has access for varsity

864
00:41:55.965 --> 00:41:57.085
and JV together.

865
00:41:57.505 --> 00:42:00.685
But that's, you know, over 65, 70 kids.

866
00:42:02.225 --> 00:42:04.245
And even that has become more

867
00:42:04.245 --> 00:42:06.005
and more limited as, as our soccer

868
00:42:06.025 --> 00:42:08.365
and field hockey coaches have wanted more access there.

869
00:42:08.965 --> 00:42:11.085
So this limits what we can do at practice.

870
00:42:11.385 --> 00:42:13.805
Our, our soccer teams almost never,

871
00:42:13.975 --> 00:42:16.845
never other than weekends a little bit when they choose the

872
00:42:16.845 --> 00:42:19.925
right time, have the ability to have a full field turf,

873
00:42:20.165 --> 00:42:22.445
synthetic surf turf soccer practices.

874
00:42:22.525 --> 00:42:25.765
I think between those two teams this year they played 40

875
00:42:25.825 --> 00:42:29.405
of their 42 games on synthetic turf surfaces.

876
00:42:30.305 --> 00:42:31.965
And then one of the, the issues we have is

877
00:42:31.965 --> 00:42:33.005
obviously conflict there.

878
00:42:33.865 --> 00:42:36.085
The spring, this is where it's probably most evident.

879
00:42:36.985 --> 00:42:39.245
We have to shut down turf usage

880
00:42:39.745 --> 00:42:41.685
during any of our track meets.

881
00:42:41.685 --> 00:42:44.445
So that's middle school track meets, unified track meets

882
00:42:44.545 --> 00:42:47.565
and our men's and women's track competitions.

883
00:42:47.905 --> 00:42:51.085
So during those times we have to use, we have to move our,

884
00:42:51.915 --> 00:42:54.965
what, what is primarily lacrosse practices onto the grass

885
00:42:54.975 --> 00:42:58.205
field, which can sort of continues the use there.

886
00:42:58.905 --> 00:43:00.965
The other reality of that conflict is

887
00:43:01.745 --> 00:43:03.485
pretty much all our games

888
00:43:03.485 --> 00:43:06.525
that we play at home now varsity competitions are six

889
00:43:06.525 --> 00:43:09.045
o'clock start or six 30.

890
00:43:09.265 --> 00:43:10.885
So like Monday and

891
00:43:10.945 --> 00:43:14.565
and Wednesday we do, we usually do a five 15 sub varsity.

892
00:43:14.565 --> 00:43:16.005
It's our JV field hockey game

893
00:43:16.025 --> 00:43:18.205
and then a six 30 to 6 45 start

894
00:43:18.705 --> 00:43:20.525
for our varsity field hockey team,

895
00:43:20.525 --> 00:43:23.205
which obviously means later finishes for them.

896
00:43:23.665 --> 00:43:26.285
You know, and, and you think about, you know,

897
00:43:26.605 --> 00:43:27.645
managing homework, sleep time

898
00:43:27.645 --> 00:43:28.645
and different things like that.

899
00:43:29.705 --> 00:43:31.565
So that's another piece of that conflict.

900
00:43:32.585 --> 00:43:37.085
We only have the one field that has full equitable access,

901
00:43:37.115 --> 00:43:39.405
like a DA access, the ramps, up to the stands,

902
00:43:40.565 --> 00:43:43.365
adequate lighting and access to,

903
00:43:44.345 --> 00:43:45.725
you know, bathroom facilities.

904
00:43:45.945 --> 00:43:48.605
So that's why we're putting all our games, you know, into

905
00:43:48.605 --> 00:43:50.445
that one, into that one place.

906
00:43:52.345 --> 00:43:54.725
The, the other, the other reality is that

907
00:43:54.725 --> 00:43:57.325
because of our limited field access, we have

908
00:43:57.325 --> 00:44:00.565
to displace our, our field hockey team, you know,

909
00:44:00.665 --> 00:44:02.445
almost every practice they have.

910
00:44:02.585 --> 00:44:04.765
So we, we carpool

911
00:44:04.765 --> 00:44:07.845
and bus our varsity JV

912
00:44:08.065 --> 00:44:10.685
and freshman field hockey teams over to Cole

913
00:44:10.905 --> 00:44:13.805
and Kennedy to accommodate field space for them.

914
00:44:13.945 --> 00:44:16.485
And you know, they, the questions are why the,

915
00:44:16.955 --> 00:44:18.805
it's not just randomly chosen.

916
00:44:18.865 --> 00:44:21.045
We didn't chose them 'cause we don't value field hockey.

917
00:44:21.465 --> 00:44:24.925
Partly they need, it's a, that's a full turf sport.

918
00:44:25.185 --> 00:44:28.325
So they need access to synthetic turf at all times.

919
00:44:30.385 --> 00:44:33.005
And the, the issues with, you know, that's,

920
00:44:33.185 --> 00:44:36.165
we don't have 11 v 11 lines there for soccer.

921
00:44:36.645 --> 00:44:38.645
'cause actually our soccer coaches have said if we can get

922
00:44:38.645 --> 00:44:41.605
more time, we go over to Cole if that's an option.

923
00:44:42.225 --> 00:44:44.365
But we also don't have the full size goals there.

924
00:44:45.135 --> 00:44:46.925
There are no football lines, there's no

925
00:44:49.735 --> 00:44:51.285
field goals for kicking as well.

926
00:44:51.585 --> 00:44:53.485
So field hockey just sort of gets left in

927
00:44:53.485 --> 00:44:55.205
that position just based on access.

928
00:44:56.635 --> 00:44:59.445
Another piece of our limitations is that, you know,

929
00:44:59.445 --> 00:45:03.365
we do have plenty of open space on the complex, but,

930
00:45:03.385 --> 00:45:05.285
and we will get to this a little bit more in a second

931
00:45:05.815 --> 00:45:07.125
field three basically,

932
00:45:07.225 --> 00:45:09.285
or our practice field is underutilized.

933
00:45:09.785 --> 00:45:11.485
The only sports that we put on

934
00:45:11.485 --> 00:45:14.045
that practice field right now are practices

935
00:45:14.105 --> 00:45:15.405
for freshman football

936
00:45:15.985 --> 00:45:20.605
and practices for JV ultimate Frisbee.

937
00:45:20.665 --> 00:45:22.565
You know, the reality is, and again we'll look at it in a

938
00:45:22.565 --> 00:45:24.925
second, that it's just, it's not a field that can be used

939
00:45:24.925 --> 00:45:26.365
for anything else at this point.

940
00:45:27.225 --> 00:45:29.485
And then also because we only have one

941
00:45:30.405 --> 00:45:33.565
synthetic turf surface and we're using that so much,

942
00:45:34.225 --> 00:45:35.645
we do lose some games.

943
00:45:35.785 --> 00:45:37.605
So when we have weather cancellations

944
00:45:37.665 --> 00:45:38.765
or field closures,

945
00:45:40.185 --> 00:45:42.445
it generally means we're gonna lose sub varsity games.

946
00:45:43.265 --> 00:45:46.525
The reality is that the expense of busing

947
00:45:47.255 --> 00:45:50.965
those sports out individually at times isn't,

948
00:45:51.735 --> 00:45:54.605
isn't a decision that all schools will support.

949
00:45:54.625 --> 00:45:57.285
So often if we, if we're running our varsity game on the

950
00:45:57.285 --> 00:45:59.965
turf field, but we can't use the grass, we'll lose

951
00:45:59.965 --> 00:46:00.965
that JV game.

952
00:46:02.385 --> 00:46:04.565
You know, so the, those are sort of the sort

953
00:46:04.565 --> 00:46:07.365
of big picture limitations when you're looking at our

954
00:46:07.365 --> 00:46:08.685
current field space and usage.

955
00:46:09.715 --> 00:46:12.405
Alright, so obviously the, you know, the,

956
00:46:12.465 --> 00:46:15.205
the place we're looking right now is the practice field

957
00:46:16.025 --> 00:46:18.365
and it just, you know, first

958
00:46:18.385 --> 00:46:19.965
and foremost, it's limited in

959
00:46:19.965 --> 00:46:22.125
what you can play on it right now because of the way,

960
00:46:22.645 --> 00:46:24.925
because of the, some of the, the grading down in

961
00:46:25.505 --> 00:46:27.965
and the path down in, it's not wide enough to play

962
00:46:28.865 --> 00:46:30.445
any sports other than football.

963
00:46:30.445 --> 00:46:32.205
Even football isn't a full width field.

964
00:46:33.425 --> 00:46:35.045
The playing surface is uneven.

965
00:46:35.105 --> 00:46:37.925
You, you'll notice around the yard markers,

966
00:46:38.225 --> 00:46:40.885
it dips like there's big divots across it.

967
00:46:40.945 --> 00:46:42.325
You can kind of see it in the pictures

968
00:46:42.585 --> 00:46:44.205
and then if you look at that field, you know,

969
00:46:44.205 --> 00:46:46.125
basically straight down the middle are just

970
00:46:46.315 --> 00:46:48.405
huge patches of dirt.

971
00:46:49.425 --> 00:46:53.165
You know, it's, it's a field that really, it needs

972
00:46:53.305 --> 00:46:56.765
to be upgraded and renovated no matter what.

973
00:46:57.265 --> 00:46:59.405
You know, we're, you know, as we get into this,

974
00:46:59.645 --> 00:47:01.165
we'll make the argument for synthetic,

975
00:47:01.745 --> 00:47:04.485
but certainly, you know, it's a field that we aren't able

976
00:47:04.485 --> 00:47:06.605
to fully use because, because of the conditions.

977
00:47:08.985 --> 00:47:10.485
All right, so this sort of gets into,

978
00:47:11.265 --> 00:47:13.365
and this is I think, you know,

979
00:47:13.385 --> 00:47:16.605
talked about this a little bit last meeting

980
00:47:18.345 --> 00:47:21.645
and the reality is recommended playing hours

981
00:47:21.865 --> 00:47:26.325
for a grass surface or 600, 800 per year with rest

982
00:47:26.615 --> 00:47:28.965
after 25 events.

983
00:47:30.505 --> 00:47:33.285
And the reality is for us,

984
00:47:33.345 --> 00:47:36.605
25 events will occur in probably two

985
00:47:36.605 --> 00:47:37.605
and a half to three weeks.

986
00:47:37.805 --> 00:47:39.525
I would say you just,

987
00:47:39.525 --> 00:47:40.885
because we're using it so often

988
00:47:40.885 --> 00:47:43.365
between school use and youth use.

989
00:47:44.265 --> 00:47:45.405
And then that's a recommended

990
00:47:45.405 --> 00:47:48.285
that you take two weeks off at a minimum at that point,

991
00:47:48.625 --> 00:47:51.445
you know, so we're not able to give the fields,

992
00:47:51.625 --> 00:47:55.805
the grass fields we currently have the rest, they need

993
00:47:56.725 --> 00:47:59.245
synthetic fields, 1200 to 1500 hours.

994
00:47:59.265 --> 00:48:01.485
And then with lighting you can actually extend that

995
00:48:01.985 --> 00:48:04.765
and you do not need to rest synthetic fields.

996
00:48:07.185 --> 00:48:10.685
All right, so our actual field usage at Natick High School

997
00:48:11.385 --> 00:48:12.765
is about two

998
00:48:12.785 --> 00:48:17.285
to three times the recommended use on grass.

999
00:48:17.345 --> 00:48:20.725
So we're, we're using grass fields 1300 to 1500 hours.

1000
00:48:20.785 --> 00:48:24.765
Now this is across, this number is across high school

1001
00:48:24.765 --> 00:48:26.685
and youth usage on the grass fields.

1002
00:48:27.265 --> 00:48:30.925
Our turf field usage is, is probably more like 1400

1003
00:48:30.985 --> 00:48:33.645
to 1700 hours, maybe even a little higher.

1004
00:48:34.005 --> 00:48:35.925
I mean that, and that's just high school usage.

1005
00:48:36.825 --> 00:48:41.605
And again, the reality other than July, you know, we,

1006
00:48:41.785 --> 00:48:44.085
and the winter we're not resting those fields.

1007
00:48:44.145 --> 00:48:48.085
So when we start on 'em in, you know, the third Monday

1008
00:48:48.105 --> 00:48:49.805
of March, we're going all the way

1009
00:48:49.805 --> 00:48:51.045
through basically the end of June.

1010
00:48:51.345 --> 00:48:53.365
And then when we get back on in the middle of August,

1011
00:48:53.375 --> 00:48:55.605
we're going all the way through Thanksgiving, right?

1012
00:48:55.665 --> 00:48:59.285
So the reality is to meet our current needs,

1013
00:48:59.445 --> 00:49:00.525
a new field would need

1014
00:49:00.525 --> 00:49:03.205
to offer 1,215 hours of usage per year.

1015
00:49:03.985 --> 00:49:07.445
So that brings us to, you know, sort of the last piece here

1016
00:49:08.185 --> 00:49:09.885
and we can go on to the next slide.

1017
00:49:13.585 --> 00:49:16.125
And that is the sort of impact

1018
00:49:16.125 --> 00:49:19.005
and benefit of a new turf field.

1019
00:49:19.385 --> 00:49:20.405
All right? So, you know,

1020
00:49:20.405 --> 00:49:23.605
the reality is looking at our current usage in needs,

1021
00:49:24.865 --> 00:49:27.685
we need, you know, our recommendation would be

1022
00:49:27.685 --> 00:49:30.725
for a synthetic turf field, which offers 1200, 1500 hours

1023
00:49:31.145 --> 00:49:34.885
and again with lighting more so the sort of benefits

1024
00:49:34.885 --> 00:49:38.365
of this, we would, we would reduce some of the wear

1025
00:49:38.365 --> 00:49:40.925
and tear on our current turf, you know,

1026
00:49:40.925 --> 00:49:42.645
which does need to be maintained.

1027
00:49:42.645 --> 00:49:45.805
And it's a little bit of a misrepresentation that, you know,

1028
00:49:45.835 --> 00:49:48.925
turf fields do need maintenance, but, and,

1029
00:49:48.985 --> 00:49:51.325
and you can use 'em, but less time

1030
00:49:51.325 --> 00:49:53.285
and less teams at once on those fields.

1031
00:49:54.545 --> 00:49:56.085
So the other thing it would allow us

1032
00:49:56.085 --> 00:49:59.365
to do is utilize the space we have better, you know,

1033
00:49:59.375 --> 00:50:01.725
we're not using some of the open space

1034
00:50:02.745 --> 00:50:03.925
and we would also be able

1035
00:50:03.925 --> 00:50:06.365
to thoughtfully schedule usage better.

1036
00:50:07.105 --> 00:50:10.085
And I, I do think a new synthetic turf field would allow us

1037
00:50:10.425 --> 00:50:13.645
to think about how do we rest the grass fields we have now

1038
00:50:14.025 --> 00:50:17.445
and balance their usage so they stay in better condition.

1039
00:50:17.445 --> 00:50:20.565
So that's another piece of this is, you know,

1040
00:50:20.625 --> 00:50:23.805
we should be able to, you know, rest probably a field,

1041
00:50:24.185 --> 00:50:25.485
you know, whether it's we, you know,

1042
00:50:25.585 --> 00:50:26.885
and we can work with art on this.

1043
00:50:27.065 --> 00:50:28.005
How do you, you know, what's the

1044
00:50:28.005 --> 00:50:29.045
best way to rest these fields?

1045
00:50:29.065 --> 00:50:30.805
Do we shut one down for a week or two?

1046
00:50:31.185 --> 00:50:34.085
Do we give 'em one one to two days of rest a week?

1047
00:50:34.105 --> 00:50:35.325
But that's something we can look at.

1048
00:50:36.225 --> 00:50:38.685
The other thing a, another big piece of this would be

1049
00:50:39.685 --> 00:50:42.725
allowing for multiple competitions at once, which would

1050
00:50:43.345 --> 00:50:47.685
reduce our need to have all of our varsity competitions

1051
00:50:48.195 --> 00:50:51.805
scheduled at night so we could get kids in

1052
00:50:51.805 --> 00:50:53.125
and out of games earlier.

1053
00:50:53.865 --> 00:50:55.765
You know, obviously we value some of

1054
00:50:55.765 --> 00:50:58.445
that night under the lights experience for all our teams,

1055
00:50:58.785 --> 00:51:02.565
but to have to do that for all, you know, eight to 10

1056
00:51:02.565 --> 00:51:05.445
of their home games is, is taxing our athletes.

1057
00:51:05.525 --> 00:51:08.645
I think if we're being honest, it would also allow us

1058
00:51:08.665 --> 00:51:12.045
to have track and field competitions

1059
00:51:12.865 --> 00:51:16.645
and have other competitions at the same time, whether it be

1060
00:51:17.405 --> 00:51:20.205
a lacrosse game as well as the ability

1061
00:51:20.265 --> 00:51:21.845
to practice all our teams at once.

1062
00:51:23.225 --> 00:51:24.805
And then it would give us more equitable

1063
00:51:24.805 --> 00:51:26.325
access for field hockey.

1064
00:51:27.025 --> 00:51:28.405
We would at a minimum be able

1065
00:51:28.405 --> 00:51:32.005
to keep our varsity field hockey team practicing at Memorial

1066
00:51:32.005 --> 00:51:34.445
Stadium, either on the main field

1067
00:51:34.505 --> 00:51:36.085
or the practice field complex

1068
00:51:36.345 --> 00:51:39.085
and bring some of the sub varsity practices home as well.

1069
00:51:40.025 --> 00:51:42.605
And then, you know, lastly, you know, a big benefit of

1070
00:51:42.665 --> 00:51:44.885
of it will be consistent scheduling

1071
00:51:44.885 --> 00:51:47.085
and less cancellations that we're not gonna lose

1072
00:51:47.105 --> 00:51:49.925
as many sub varsity games as we do

1073
00:51:50.755 --> 00:51:52.885
with the current conditions based on, you know,

1074
00:51:52.885 --> 00:51:54.525
weather cancell cancellations.

1075
00:51:55.905 --> 00:51:58.245
So that sort of brings us to the end of,

1076
00:51:58.825 --> 00:52:00.645
you know, my presentation.

1077
00:52:01.405 --> 00:52:02.565
I don't know Matt or Art,

1078
00:52:02.565 --> 00:52:05.045
if you have any things you wanna share as well.

1079
00:52:07.275 --> 00:52:08.495
<v Speaker 1>All right, thank you.</v>

1080
00:52:08.625 --> 00:52:10.615
We're gonna open up to questions

1081
00:52:10.615 --> 00:52:11.855
to the members of the committee.

1082
00:52:12.035 --> 00:52:13.935
Dr. Welch, did you just push a button

1083
00:52:13.935 --> 00:52:15.135
because you were about to raise your hand?

1084
00:52:15.855 --> 00:52:17.575
<v Speaker 9>I, I did. Please.</v>

1085
00:52:19.795 --> 00:52:24.655
So one of the things that's mentioned on slide 10 is

1086
00:52:24.655 --> 00:52:27.975
that there could be additional hosting, not just

1087
00:52:27.975 --> 00:52:32.775
of practices, but of competitions on the field if it's,

1088
00:52:32.775 --> 00:52:37.095
if it's redone, is there the proposal and Mr.

1089
00:52:37.355 --> 00:52:39.375
Gillis, maybe this is partly a question for you, is

1090
00:52:39.375 --> 00:52:41.535
that in the budget that there would be seating

1091
00:52:42.195 --> 00:52:45.615
on the new field in addition to redoing the playing surface?

1092
00:52:49.675 --> 00:52:54.375
<v Speaker 21>So as far as like seating stands for the practice field?</v>

1093
00:52:54.395 --> 00:52:55.655
No, there, there wasn't. Okay.

1094
00:52:55.655 --> 00:52:56.655
There were, there were lights

1095
00:52:56.955 --> 00:53:00.095
and line, you know, the field to be lined for four sports.

1096
00:53:00.445 --> 00:53:03.735
<v Speaker 9>Okay. And my second question is,</v>

1097
00:53:03.985 --> 00:53:06.975
we've gotten an email comment in the past and then a

1098
00:53:06.995 --> 00:53:09.535
and then a public comment this evening from an athletic

1099
00:53:09.535 --> 00:53:12.575
coach about some sort of a path around the edge.

1100
00:53:13.595 --> 00:53:15.735
Is that, was that in the original estimate? No,

1101
00:53:15.835 --> 00:53:17.615
<v Speaker 21>In terms of cost tonight was the first</v>

1102
00:53:18.115 --> 00:53:20.095
that's been brought to my attention. Okay.

1103
00:53:20.935 --> 00:53:22.495
<v Speaker 9>I have no other questions. Thank you. I yield back</v>

1104
00:53:22.915 --> 00:53:23.915
<v Speaker 1>Ms.</v>

1105
00:53:23.915 --> 00:53:24.775
Brunell. Thank you.

1106
00:53:24.785 --> 00:53:25.925
<v Speaker 11>Thank you for being here.</v>

1107
00:53:27.505 --> 00:53:31.645
So a couple questions this week.

1108
00:53:31.825 --> 00:53:35.925
The select board is also looking at the coal north turf

1109
00:53:35.925 --> 00:53:37.525
that was just passed at town meeting

1110
00:53:38.185 --> 00:53:40.845
and there's gonna be a recommendation to use Brockville

1111
00:53:42.025 --> 00:53:43.165
at the coal north.

1112
00:53:43.345 --> 00:53:47.325
And so I was, since we have you here were we

1113
00:53:47.385 --> 00:53:51.765
to take your recommendation on a turf field, do you think

1114
00:53:51.765 --> 00:53:52.805
that a brock fill,

1115
00:53:56.615 --> 00:53:58.485
Brock fill filling, what do you call it?

1116
00:53:58.865 --> 00:54:00.805
Do you, is, does that substance, does

1117
00:54:00.805 --> 00:54:03.325
that hold up on a varsity field?

1118
00:54:05.005 --> 00:54:06.085
<v Speaker 23>Thoughts on that? R</v>

1119
00:54:10.185 --> 00:54:11.185
<v Speaker 1>Yes, thank you.</v>

1120
00:54:11.185 --> 00:54:14.725
For those who may not know, Brockville is a, a white,

1121
00:54:15.125 --> 00:54:18.645
a yellow pine chip versus the crumb rubber, which is the,

1122
00:54:19.745 --> 00:54:21.005
the typical rubber piece.

1123
00:54:22.565 --> 00:54:24.965
I would be concerned with Brockville meeting the

1124
00:54:24.965 --> 00:54:28.805
expectations of what we're looking for at the varsity level.

1125
00:54:29.145 --> 00:54:32.125
So one of the particular challenges that we have,

1126
00:54:32.125 --> 00:54:33.805
especially in the spring for lacrosse

1127
00:54:33.865 --> 00:54:38.445
and whatnot, is if there's an extended winter period is

1128
00:54:38.445 --> 00:54:42.245
to have that rapid melting in to meet that demand

1129
00:54:42.265 --> 00:54:43.845
for the third week of March.

1130
00:54:44.925 --> 00:54:47.485
Crumb rubber generally will melt a lot faster.

1131
00:54:49.095 --> 00:54:52.685
Brockville can freeze and, and become much more firm

1132
00:54:52.785 --> 00:54:55.885
and to a point where it's, you wouldn't use it

1133
00:54:56.445 --> 00:54:57.805
wouldn't meet the standards for that.

1134
00:54:58.065 --> 00:55:02.765
So that's where you, you run into

1135
00:55:02.765 --> 00:55:06.245
that issue is, is getting that rapid spring melt.

1136
00:55:07.825 --> 00:55:09.885
In our experience, you know, as sports tur managers,

1137
00:55:09.905 --> 00:55:12.605
I'm not sure how to melt a brockville field.

1138
00:55:13.285 --> 00:55:14.725
It really hasn't had a life cycle

1139
00:55:16.695 --> 00:55:18.405
experience in the northeast.

1140
00:55:20.275 --> 00:55:23.445
Yeah, Kennedy Middle School is, is the first one for us.

1141
00:55:25.065 --> 00:55:28.325
So when we wanna melt crumb rubber,

1142
00:55:28.505 --> 00:55:31.685
we spread more crumb rubber over to snow and it melts just

1143
00:55:31.725 --> 00:55:33.805
'cause it's black and absorbs the sunlight.

1144
00:55:33.985 --> 00:55:37.165
So that would just be my concern to meet that expectation.

1145
00:55:37.925 --> 00:55:41.645
Then also at the varsity level, just the expectation for

1146
00:55:42.195 --> 00:55:45.765
what that performance is in terms of ball roll, ball, bounce

1147
00:55:46.635 --> 00:55:48.285
footing and leat and stuff like that.

1148
00:55:48.285 --> 00:55:51.405
They're not equal. Brockville is a good alternative

1149
00:55:51.945 --> 00:55:55.085
but does not meet that same standard as crumb rubber.

1150
00:55:55.995 --> 00:55:57.805
<v Speaker 11>Okay, thank you. That's, I hope that's helpful.</v>

1151
00:55:58.545 --> 00:56:01.205
May I, and then about,

1152
00:56:03.945 --> 00:56:06.725
so I, I hear the, the, in the presentation today

1153
00:56:06.725 --> 00:56:08.685
that about the rest, that seems like the very

1154
00:56:09.595 --> 00:56:12.765
important piece that the, the fields need time to rest,

1155
00:56:12.765 --> 00:56:13.925
especially if they're grass.

1156
00:56:14.635 --> 00:56:16.005
I've also heard a town meeting

1157
00:56:16.185 --> 00:56:19.205
and other places that, you know,

1158
00:56:19.205 --> 00:56:20.965
that we're balancing this idea with cost

1159
00:56:21.145 --> 00:56:24.845
and obviously the cost is much higher potentially for grass.

1160
00:56:24.905 --> 00:56:27.205
That's what I'm hearing from the town study.

1161
00:56:28.505 --> 00:56:31.405
On the other side, the people that I'm hearing from,

1162
00:56:31.405 --> 00:56:35.165
they're very concerned about the location to Doug Pond with

1163
00:56:35.825 --> 00:56:36.885
the practice field.

1164
00:56:37.305 --> 00:56:39.805
And so I was wondering if that is the only place,

1165
00:56:40.665 --> 00:56:43.285
say we say we were to wave a magic wand

1166
00:56:43.305 --> 00:56:46.325
and we could put another turf field into Natick.

1167
00:56:47.105 --> 00:56:49.685
Is that practice field, the youth

1168
00:56:50.205 --> 00:56:52.525
football field, the only place?

1169
00:56:53.545 --> 00:56:57.045
Or could there be another spot for a turf field

1170
00:56:57.275 --> 00:56:58.805
that high school teams could access?

1171
00:57:00.275 --> 00:57:04.325
<v Speaker 22>Yeah, I mean I, I certainly think, you know,</v>

1172
00:57:04.375 --> 00:57:07.125
given the choice of like another synthetic field in a

1173
00:57:07.125 --> 00:57:09.845
different location that we had full access to versus

1174
00:57:10.745 --> 00:57:13.965
not having access, not having synthetic field, you know,

1175
00:57:13.965 --> 00:57:15.805
it wouldn't answer all of our issues

1176
00:57:16.005 --> 00:57:19.285
'cause we'd still have to sort of get teams

1177
00:57:19.385 --> 00:57:20.685
to an offsite facility.

1178
00:57:21.185 --> 00:57:24.205
But it would allow us probably to balance that better.

1179
00:57:24.205 --> 00:57:26.285
Especially if you, you know, again, one

1180
00:57:26.285 --> 00:57:28.605
of the limitations we have is really,

1181
00:57:28.705 --> 00:57:33.125
we only have one football field at the complex right now.

1182
00:57:33.405 --> 00:57:36.205
'cause the practice field only has

1183
00:57:37.985 --> 00:57:42.005
the field goal posts on one end, you know, so it's,

1184
00:57:42.035 --> 00:57:44.605
it's not ideal and again, it's not a full width

1185
00:57:45.305 --> 00:57:48.485
and we don't have any other fields lined for football across

1186
00:57:49.905 --> 00:57:50.925
the entire district.

1187
00:57:50.985 --> 00:57:54.325
So if you, if you did a fully lined multipurpose field

1188
00:57:54.325 --> 00:57:56.565
somewhere else, I mean certainly we could work with that

1189
00:57:57.945 --> 00:58:01.725
and think about how to most equitably access it

1190
00:58:01.725 --> 00:58:04.685
and how to equitably balance displacing our teams.

1191
00:58:05.125 --> 00:58:06.565
You know, I think our preference would be

1192
00:58:06.565 --> 00:58:09.685
because we have the space at the high school

1193
00:58:10.065 --> 00:58:13.885
and that grasp the practice field is so underutilized that

1194
00:58:14.705 --> 00:58:19.405
to not fix that field I think would be a miss.

1195
00:58:19.985 --> 00:58:21.565
Now if you add, you know, if you fix that

1196
00:58:21.565 --> 00:58:24.725
and put grass there that we could rest, you know,

1197
00:58:24.725 --> 00:58:26.525
with a turf field, I think we could work with that too.

1198
00:58:29.245 --> 00:58:30.165
<v Speaker 11>I have more, but I'll wait.</v>

1199
00:58:30.535 --> 00:58:31.885
We'll come back to you Dr. Fugman.

1200
00:58:32.545 --> 00:58:35.805
<v Speaker 18>So I know you said you don't represent Naac soccer,</v>

1201
00:58:36.665 --> 00:58:39.925
but I, I'll be honest, my question is basically

1202
00:58:40.665 --> 00:58:43.005
if we do this, who else

1203
00:58:43.065 --> 00:58:45.605
or how else could the rest of the town benefit?

1204
00:58:46.185 --> 00:58:49.565
So I'm wondering if to the extent that you know,

1205
00:58:49.665 --> 00:58:52.405
and you might not know, you're not Naag youth,

1206
00:58:52.425 --> 00:58:56.805
but I mean soccer, youth soccer, would other groups be able

1207
00:58:56.865 --> 00:58:58.765
to, are there other groups who need the space

1208
00:58:58.865 --> 00:59:00.405
who could use it when you don't need it?

1209
00:59:00.405 --> 00:59:02.525
For example, weekends, you know, could

1210
00:59:02.585 --> 00:59:05.365
so could the soccer club use it on Saturdays? Yep.

1211
00:59:05.505 --> 00:59:09.805
<v Speaker 22>And, and we, we do allow access to our facilities,</v>

1212
00:59:10.025 --> 00:59:11.645
to all the youth groups.

1213
00:59:11.925 --> 00:59:14.805
I, you know, this year, you know,

1214
00:59:14.805 --> 00:59:18.525
Natick Soccer Club right now uses the turf field

1215
00:59:19.245 --> 00:59:21.700
Saturdays from two 30 to six throughout their season.

1216
00:59:22.195 --> 00:59:24.885
They've also, they use a lot of our fr when our

1217
00:59:25.565 --> 00:59:27.485
football team is on, on the road on Friday nights,

1218
00:59:27.785 --> 00:59:29.605
Natick Soccer Club is usually hosting one

1219
00:59:29.605 --> 00:59:31.085
to two games on the field.

1220
00:59:31.115 --> 00:59:33.925
Then they use that entire complex

1221
00:59:34.705 --> 00:59:36.165
during, you know, their tournament.

1222
00:59:36.165 --> 00:59:39.685
Obviously, you know, I think the big youth group

1223
00:59:39.685 --> 00:59:42.925
that's looking for field

1224
00:59:43.645 --> 00:59:46.565
renovation in rebuilding is Natick Youth football as well.

1225
00:59:46.865 --> 00:59:49.405
Natick Youth Football has, you know, right now,

1226
00:59:50.195 --> 00:59:53.285
because we're using the turf pretty much every night

1227
00:59:53.795 --> 00:59:55.525
they have five teams.

1228
00:59:55.765 --> 00:59:58.205
I think there's four tackle football teams

1229
00:59:58.425 --> 01:00:02.285
and then their flag football teams use that practice field

1230
01:00:02.285 --> 01:00:06.125
and beyond three nights a week for their practices.

1231
01:00:06.665 --> 01:00:09.005
And you know, I mean that's partly why

1232
01:00:09.005 --> 01:00:10.565
that field gets overused,

1233
01:00:10.565 --> 01:00:13.005
but it also, you know, when you think of putting, you know,

1234
01:00:13.005 --> 01:00:17.285
five different football teams on one grass field at once,

1235
01:00:17.435 --> 01:00:20.605
it's, you know, it's, it's way overusing it, you know,

1236
01:00:20.605 --> 01:00:22.845
so they're a group that would love to see it.

1237
01:00:23.085 --> 01:00:24.685
I know. You know,

1238
01:00:24.685 --> 01:00:27.685
and that's, you know, field hockey is a growing

1239
01:00:27.775 --> 01:00:29.125
sport at our youth level.

1240
01:00:29.465 --> 01:00:32.045
You know, right now they're only using Kennedy Middle School

1241
01:00:32.385 --> 01:00:33.405
as their primary field,

1242
01:00:33.405 --> 01:00:35.245
but that's another group that would want to use it.

1243
01:00:36.205 --> 01:00:39.885
I do know, you know, NA Natick baseball is looking

1244
01:00:39.945 --> 01:00:42.485
for synthetic turf access as well.

1245
01:00:42.505 --> 01:00:45.925
Natick baseball, you know, youth baseball right now doesn't,

1246
01:00:45.995 --> 01:00:48.965
it's the only sport in town that doesn't have access

1247
01:00:49.025 --> 01:00:50.765
to any synthetic turf.

1248
01:00:50.785 --> 01:00:52.965
So they're sort of beholden to weather

1249
01:00:53.995 --> 01:00:55.485
more than any other group.

1250
01:00:56.585 --> 01:01:01.085
So, you know, they, I I think across all our youth groups

1251
01:01:02.815 --> 01:01:04.085
there is significant,

1252
01:01:04.665 --> 01:01:07.765
and if you look at the study in all those interviews

1253
01:01:08.365 --> 01:01:09.925
that they did with those groups, I mean, you know,

1254
01:01:10.175 --> 01:01:13.845
every single of those youth groups was asking for, you know,

1255
01:01:13.905 --> 01:01:15.245
nat lacrosse is what was asking

1256
01:01:15.345 --> 01:01:17.805
for war time on the synthetic surfaces.

1257
01:01:17.965 --> 01:01:20.205
JI mean, in, in, from a sports perspective,

1258
01:01:20.675 --> 01:01:22.885
from a scheduling perspective, it just gives you

1259
01:01:22.885 --> 01:01:24.245
so much more reliability.

1260
01:01:24.315 --> 01:01:27.965
Like, you know, you're gonna have it and consistency

1261
01:01:29.185 --> 01:01:31.565
and then it, I mean, it it, when

1262
01:01:31.565 --> 01:01:36.045
that field's not being used in a structured way go down to,

1263
01:01:36.745 --> 01:01:39.205
you know, Memorial Stadium any night during the summer

1264
01:01:39.425 --> 01:01:42.405
and there's 25 to 40 kids

1265
01:01:43.105 --> 01:01:45.485
out there playing any number of sports,

1266
01:01:45.485 --> 01:01:47.045
there's usually lacrosse going on,

1267
01:01:47.235 --> 01:01:50.085
there's usually soccer going on, there's spike ball,

1268
01:01:50.625 --> 01:01:54.605
you know, there's, so it certainly is a community

1269
01:01:55.725 --> 01:01:56.925
resource, you know, beyond

1270
01:01:56.955 --> 01:01:59.045
what we're using in a structured manner.

1271
01:02:00.455 --> 01:02:02.845
<v Speaker 1>Thank you Ms. Brunell.</v>

1272
01:02:03.965 --> 01:02:05.245
<v Speaker 11>Okay, so back to the funding.</v>

1273
01:02:07.495 --> 01:02:09.725
Right now, there's no money appropriated for this.

1274
01:02:09.985 --> 01:02:12.365
We would have to go to town meeting

1275
01:02:13.185 --> 01:02:14.965
and make a separate warrant article

1276
01:02:15.145 --> 01:02:16.485
or it would be go as part

1277
01:02:16.485 --> 01:02:19.165
of the capital plan in re in recommendation

1278
01:02:19.205 --> 01:02:20.325
of the full capital plan.

1279
01:02:22.275 --> 01:02:24.525
<v Speaker 21>It'd probably be a separate warrant article</v>

1280
01:02:24.525 --> 01:02:26.165
because most of the capital plans

1281
01:02:27.615 --> 01:02:29.325
break out into different warrant articles.

1282
01:02:29.355 --> 01:02:33.285
It's not, not one vote for all, I'm gonna call it 10

1283
01:02:33.285 --> 01:02:34.805
or $20 million worth of expenses.

1284
01:02:36.825 --> 01:02:39.435
<v Speaker 11>Okay. And the reason I ask,</v>

1285
01:02:39.435 --> 01:02:41.955
because we've talked about so many groups and I think Mr.

1286
01:02:41.955 --> 01:02:44.115
Breneman, you've done such a nice job representing all

1287
01:02:44.115 --> 01:02:45.995
of the groups here tonight that I, I know

1288
01:02:45.995 --> 01:02:48.355
that there's a huge investment across this town.

1289
01:02:49.115 --> 01:02:51.595
People have been reaching out to me about funding and,

1290
01:02:51.655 --> 01:02:53.315
and like you mentioned Natick Soccer Club.

1291
01:02:53.915 --> 01:02:55.835
I am actually curious whether

1292
01:02:55.835 --> 01:02:58.035
or not we could work with partners

1293
01:02:59.215 --> 01:03:01.555
and see if we could get some type of funding

1294
01:03:02.855 --> 01:03:04.355
for a synthetic field

1295
01:03:04.495 --> 01:03:08.875
or a field in Natick to sup to support fields

1296
01:03:09.055 --> 01:03:10.075
and with that funding.

1297
01:03:10.275 --> 01:03:14.595
I also wonder about lighting.

1298
01:03:15.995 --> 01:03:18.195
I don't, I didn't follow Kennedy close enough

1299
01:03:18.195 --> 01:03:20.235
to know why there wasn't lighting put up at Kennedy,

1300
01:03:20.375 --> 01:03:23.355
but I wonder if that decision could be revisited

1301
01:03:23.495 --> 01:03:27.075
and if that would extend time for teams.

1302
01:03:28.035 --> 01:03:29.035
I, again, I don't know,

1303
01:03:30.775 --> 01:03:32.875
but I, I am curious about the funding.

1304
01:03:35.215 --> 01:03:37.955
And I guess my last question, so that wasn't a question

1305
01:03:37.955 --> 01:03:40.475
that, well, I guess it was, but you answered it.

1306
01:03:40.475 --> 01:03:42.475
That was my comments. One more question.

1307
01:03:42.935 --> 01:03:47.915
If the, about the Doug Pond location, like if the,

1308
01:03:48.295 --> 01:03:52.515
if the field, if turf field is where the direction we need

1309
01:03:52.755 --> 01:03:56.435
to go because of practical reasons,

1310
01:03:57.725 --> 01:04:00.915
could you make the varsity high school field,

1311
01:04:02.535 --> 01:04:05.395
you know, the one that's behind, that's also in awful shape.

1312
01:04:05.555 --> 01:04:06.835
I practice there twice a week.

1313
01:04:06.935 --> 01:04:10.715
Now the, the field that's behind the turf.

1314
01:04:11.105 --> 01:04:12.275
<v Speaker 22>Exactly. So the varsity,</v>

1315
01:04:12.355 --> 01:04:13.995
I would call it the varsity soccer field.

1316
01:04:14.165 --> 01:04:15.635
<v Speaker 11>Could we make that turf</v>

1317
01:04:16.015 --> 01:04:17.875
to have it further away from Doug Pond?

1318
01:04:17.875 --> 01:04:19.475
Would that make any difference in

1319
01:04:19.475 --> 01:04:24.115
what people are concerned about and, and do drainage

1320
01:04:24.215 --> 01:04:26.075
and proper things to the youth field?

1321
01:04:26.665 --> 01:04:28.515
<v Speaker 22>Yeah, I mean, I think the reason the,</v>

1322
01:04:28.535 --> 01:04:30.515
the practice field is, is seen

1323
01:04:30.515 --> 01:04:32.195
as the primary location right now is

1324
01:04:32.315 --> 01:04:36.795
'cause that, that, that field needs basically a, a gutting,

1325
01:04:36.795 --> 01:04:38.915
it needs to be totally rebuilt.

1326
01:04:39.025 --> 01:04:41.275
Like, I don't know, I mean our, you could probably speak

1327
01:04:41.275 --> 01:04:44.555
to this, like I think over the last 10, 15 years

1328
01:04:45.165 --> 01:04:49.875
we've been sort of trying to piece that back together,

1329
01:04:50.695 --> 01:04:52.395
but now it needs a full rebuild.

1330
01:04:52.835 --> 01:04:55.115
So, I mean at that point you're probably talking about,

1331
01:04:56.135 --> 01:04:57.595
you know, again, a big

1332
01:04:58.345 --> 01:05:02.795
$500,000 plus investment to get that field usable.

1333
01:05:02.795 --> 01:05:06.075
So if you just, if you put the turf just on the varsity

1334
01:05:06.355 --> 01:05:10.875
grass, we'd lose some space that we're utilizing.

1335
01:05:10.995 --> 01:05:11.995
I, it would be a benefit,

1336
01:05:13.295 --> 01:05:16.675
but we would lose some space on grass at that point,

1337
01:05:18.265 --> 01:05:21.165
you know, so it, I mean those are certainly things that

1338
01:05:21.715 --> 01:05:24.125
when, when you go to the design process of it,

1339
01:05:24.145 --> 01:05:25.245
you can sort of bring up.

1340
01:05:26.425 --> 01:05:28.485
But there would, there would be a,

1341
01:05:28.685 --> 01:05:30.405
I think there would be a cost.

1342
01:05:31.575 --> 01:05:35.045
There may be some cost issues with putting it there.

1343
01:05:37.245 --> 01:05:40.085
<v Speaker 1>I, I believe, and someone can correct me if I'm wrong</v>

1344
01:05:40.355 --> 01:05:43.245
with Kennedy, the discussion about lights was

1345
01:05:43.725 --> 01:05:44.765
because of the neighborhood

1346
01:05:45.505 --> 01:05:48.965
and a not wanting to have the light

1347
01:05:49.475 --> 01:05:53.045
pollution at night or a lot of activity at night

1348
01:05:53.045 --> 01:05:55.085
because it's so close to the neighborhood.

1349
01:05:55.545 --> 01:05:57.605
If I remember correctly, I don't know if anybody else

1350
01:05:59.325 --> 01:06:01.565
remembers correctly Dr.

1351
01:06:01.905 --> 01:06:03.405
Fugman and then Dr. Welch.

1352
01:06:04.205 --> 01:06:07.165
<v Speaker 18>I was just gonna say maybe I see Julies on the Zoom.</v>

1353
01:06:07.445 --> 01:06:09.845
I wonder if she would know since she was on that committee.

1354
01:06:09.905 --> 01:06:10.905
She might,

1355
01:06:12.355 --> 01:06:13.975
<v Speaker 1>She can put her hand up if she would like,</v>

1356
01:06:14.115 --> 01:06:15.655
but if, if she wants to answer that question.

1357
01:06:15.715 --> 01:06:18.015
All set for now, yes. Okay.

1358
01:06:18.335 --> 01:06:21.455
I have a, anybody else if I have a couple Dr. Welch please.

1359
01:06:23.025 --> 01:06:25.255
<v Speaker 9>Slide seven refers to the width of the space.</v>

1360
01:06:25.595 --> 01:06:26.735
You know, one of the discussions

1361
01:06:26.735 --> 01:06:27.815
that this committee will have

1362
01:06:27.815 --> 01:06:30.655
to have is do we pursue the allocation of funds

1363
01:06:30.755 --> 01:06:32.455
and then what sort of playing surface,

1364
01:06:33.075 --> 01:06:34.335
but presumably the width

1365
01:06:34.335 --> 01:06:36.415
of the available space is not gonna change.

1366
01:06:36.515 --> 01:06:40.975
And I'm wondering if you could speak to how we might think

1367
01:06:40.975 --> 01:06:42.935
of the purpose of this space and

1368
01:06:42.935 --> 01:06:44.695
therefore what surface we might allocate

1369
01:06:44.695 --> 01:06:46.975
and how much money we might allocate if width is gonna

1370
01:06:47.075 --> 01:06:48.735
remain a limitations. So

1371
01:06:48.735 --> 01:06:50.775
<v Speaker 22>The reason width is an issue right now</v>

1372
01:06:51.355 --> 01:06:53.735
is just over the years there's kind of like,

1373
01:06:53.885 --> 01:06:56.655
it's almost like a ramp for some of the trucks that's sort

1374
01:06:56.655 --> 01:06:59.815
of been built up along that entrance there.

1375
01:07:00.595 --> 01:07:02.895
So where the field and,

1376
01:07:02.915 --> 01:07:04.535
and the way the field is, is

1377
01:07:05.105 --> 01:07:07.655
lined right now is based on the field go post.

1378
01:07:07.925 --> 01:07:11.575
Yeah. So where the field go post currently lies backs up

1379
01:07:11.845 --> 01:07:15.895
into that the space that there's this sort of ramp.

1380
01:07:16.645 --> 01:07:18.175
<v Speaker 9>Yeah, I think I'm looking at it now. So if</v>

1381
01:07:18.175 --> 01:07:21.055
<v Speaker 22>You push that field probably about 15,</v>

1382
01:07:21.055 --> 01:07:24.495
20 yards towards the, the varsity soccer field,

1383
01:07:24.495 --> 01:07:27.575
which there is space for, then you would have room,

1384
01:07:27.725 --> 01:07:30.615
then you would have width enough so that the,

1385
01:07:31.235 --> 01:07:33.255
the whole space is wide enough.

1386
01:07:33.475 --> 01:07:35.815
Got it. Of how it's currently drawn up.

1387
01:07:36.115 --> 01:07:39.615
And again, I don't, I mean those field goalposts go back,

1388
01:07:39.995 --> 01:07:42.135
you know, probably into the 1980s.

1389
01:07:42.285 --> 01:07:43.295
Sure. So Sure.

1390
01:07:43.455 --> 01:07:46.655
I sure it looked different when, when it was put in,

1391
01:07:46.655 --> 01:07:48.175
it was probably a full width field.

1392
01:07:48.995 --> 01:07:51.335
You know, when I was growing up at Natick High School,

1393
01:07:51.715 --> 01:07:53.615
the football team practiced on that field,

1394
01:07:53.615 --> 01:07:54.695
never played in the stadium.

1395
01:07:54.835 --> 01:07:57.015
So it was a full width field

1396
01:07:57.035 --> 01:07:57.935
and that's where actually

1397
01:07:57.935 --> 01:07:59.295
youth football had all their games.

1398
01:07:59.675 --> 01:08:00.815
You know, you didn't use the stadium

1399
01:08:00.955 --> 01:08:02.535
for anything other than really at

1400
01:08:02.535 --> 01:08:04.335
that point varsity football, I think.

1401
01:08:04.365 --> 01:08:07.215
Yeah. So it's, this is a product of

1402
01:08:07.215 --> 01:08:08.735
where the field goal is right now.

1403
01:08:08.835 --> 01:08:12.535
Yep. So that it sort of forces the, the picture

1404
01:08:12.555 --> 01:08:13.815
of the field to be drawn there.

1405
01:08:13.835 --> 01:08:16.685
But if you change that, you would have the width for

1406
01:08:17.325 --> 01:08:18.765
lacrosse fields, soccer fields and

1407
01:08:18.765 --> 01:08:19.765
<v Speaker 9>All those.</v>

1408
01:08:19.765 --> 01:08:21.645
And, and just to put a finer point on it, I don't want

1409
01:08:21.645 --> 01:08:22.765
to ask you to tell me exactly

1410
01:08:22.795 --> 01:08:24.805
what year this was when you were playing ball,

1411
01:08:25.425 --> 01:08:27.525
but when you were playing on that field

1412
01:08:27.785 --> 01:08:30.525
and there was only one game per week in the stadium.

1413
01:08:30.785 --> 01:08:32.445
Yep. To the best of your recollection,

1414
01:08:32.445 --> 01:08:34.205
what was the surface in that stadium

1415
01:08:34.205 --> 01:08:35.445
that was used only once per week?

1416
01:08:35.445 --> 01:08:37.485
That was grass. Thank you. I yield back.

1417
01:08:38.635 --> 01:08:41.165
<v Speaker 1>Alright, Mr. Patel</v>

1418
01:08:41.305 --> 01:08:43.605
and then Ms. Collins. Yeah, go ahead. Yeah,

1419
01:08:43.945 --> 01:08:46.605
<v Speaker 24>As I understand it, the property across from this</v>

1420
01:08:46.765 --> 01:08:49.805
structure is also school committee or school owned property.

1421
01:08:50.745 --> 01:08:53.725
And I know currently it's being discussed

1422
01:08:53.785 --> 01:08:55.405
for potential memorial,

1423
01:08:55.665 --> 01:08:58.685
but should the school committee make a deci building

1424
01:08:58.685 --> 01:09:00.765
committee make a decision to keep memorial

1425
01:09:00.765 --> 01:09:04.325
where it currently is, would this area be appropriate for

1426
01:09:05.035 --> 01:09:06.365
potentially another grass field?

1427
01:09:06.365 --> 01:09:08.885
This way we could have two grass fields, you know,

1428
01:09:09.265 --> 01:09:11.685
as if you updated the practice field as well.

1429
01:09:12.355 --> 01:09:16.405
<v Speaker 22>Yeah, I don't, I I think you just looking at that land,</v>

1430
01:09:17.065 --> 01:09:21.165
the cost to level that for

1431
01:09:21.765 --> 01:09:24.405
a grass field or even a synthetic field would probably be

1432
01:09:24.405 --> 01:09:28.005
pretty prohibitive to put to build the school there I think

1433
01:09:28.275 --> 01:09:31.365
because you're talking about a way more significant natural

1434
01:09:31.365 --> 01:09:32.445
budget just

1435
01:09:32.565 --> 01:09:34.685
'cause if you know that area well it's

1436
01:09:34.685 --> 01:09:36.445
basically, you know, kind of a hill.

1437
01:09:36.445 --> 01:09:39.285
Yeah. So we have like what you can see, if you go back to

1438
01:09:39.285 --> 01:09:41.285
that diagram, you have the parking lot

1439
01:09:41.705 --> 01:09:43.645
and the mehan that are kind of level,

1440
01:09:44.025 --> 01:09:48.485
but everything else in there kind of raises up onto a hill.

1441
01:09:48.605 --> 01:09:50.765
I think that's like Tim Timothy Cool

1442
01:09:50.765 --> 01:09:51.805
hill or something like that.

1443
01:09:52.145 --> 01:09:54.565
So I think to put a there would,

1444
01:09:54.565 --> 01:09:57.165
that you would've significant demolition costs

1445
01:09:57.505 --> 01:09:59.685
to put a grass field in there would be my guess

1446
01:10:01.265 --> 01:10:02.265
<v Speaker 1>All set.</v>

1447
01:10:02.265 --> 01:10:03.245
Thank you. Ms. Collins, did you have something?

1448
01:10:04.345 --> 01:10:07.045
<v Speaker 25>My question is, can I just reserve for questions? Correct,</v>

1449
01:10:07.155 --> 01:10:08.005
<v Speaker 1>Correct. Then</v>

1450
01:10:08.005 --> 01:10:09.005
<v Speaker 25>I have nothing.</v>

1451
01:10:09.005 --> 01:10:11.685
<v Speaker 1>Alright, I have a question or two.</v>

1452
01:10:12.585 --> 01:10:16.525
One not, so not directly related

1453
01:10:16.545 --> 01:10:18.165
to the specific type of field.

1454
01:10:18.305 --> 01:10:20.845
We have one athletic trainer, is that right? Correct.

1455
01:10:21.105 --> 01:10:24.405
In in a world in which we were able to, in a world

1456
01:10:24.525 --> 01:10:27.405
where the choice was and then ultimately town meeting voted

1457
01:10:27.465 --> 01:10:29.965
to approve a synthetic turf field

1458
01:10:29.985 --> 01:10:32.645
to replace the practice field, would that actually mean

1459
01:10:32.995 --> 01:10:36.445
that the field hockey team everybody would be practicing at

1460
01:10:36.445 --> 01:10:39.165
the high school or would we still be going to Cole Mike?

1461
01:10:39.225 --> 01:10:42.605
And the question, the question has to do with the challenge

1462
01:10:42.675 --> 01:10:44.925
that having one athletic trainer who has

1463
01:10:44.925 --> 01:10:46.485
to be at multiple locations now,

1464
01:10:48.705 --> 01:10:50.165
how alleviated would that be?

1465
01:10:51.225 --> 01:10:52.325
<v Speaker 22>It would be alleviated</v>

1466
01:10:52.395 --> 01:10:54.405
that the entire issue would not be solved.

1467
01:10:54.605 --> 01:10:57.365
I mean I, I started to try

1468
01:10:57.365 --> 01:10:59.885
and play around with what the schedule would look like,

1469
01:10:59.905 --> 01:11:01.485
but it's all so theoretical.

1470
01:11:01.805 --> 01:11:06.645
I mean the re it just a quick look.

1471
01:11:06.765 --> 01:11:08.685
I mean I think what you would probably use that,

1472
01:11:08.825 --> 01:11:12.525
the back practice field, if you put that synthetic,

1473
01:11:12.725 --> 01:11:16.045
I think think you could put varsity football, JV football

1474
01:11:16.345 --> 01:11:19.405
and freshman football out all out there together.

1475
01:11:19.525 --> 01:11:21.445
I mean I think that group would work pretty well together.

1476
01:11:21.905 --> 01:11:26.845
And then you'd be looking at some practices on the stadium

1477
01:11:27.235 --> 01:11:31.885
turf, you know, so like when soccer has games,

1478
01:11:32.625 --> 01:11:35.445
you could probably, instead of doing a six o'clock start,

1479
01:11:35.565 --> 01:11:37.085
a four 30 or five o'clock start

1480
01:11:37.505 --> 01:11:41.205
and have, you could probably put varsity field hockey

1481
01:11:41.785 --> 01:11:45.085
and maybe JV field hockey out on those fields.

1482
01:11:45.155 --> 01:11:46.885
They may choose to say we could put

1483
01:11:46.885 --> 01:11:48.005
all three teams out there together.

1484
01:11:48.005 --> 01:11:49.485
We're used to having three teams at once.

1485
01:11:50.065 --> 01:11:52.965
So I think we, that's something we'd have to work through

1486
01:11:53.355 --> 01:11:54.725
with the teams when we get there.

1487
01:11:54.805 --> 01:11:57.805
I mean I, we would love to have, you know, from a

1488
01:11:58.745 --> 01:12:01.405
safety perspective, you know, I think, you know, our

1489
01:12:02.365 --> 01:12:04.365
athletic trainer, Lindsay w would, would love

1490
01:12:04.365 --> 01:12:06.685
to have everybody centered together, you know,

1491
01:12:06.685 --> 01:12:10.645
because obviously in the case of emergency to to know

1492
01:12:10.645 --> 01:12:13.205
that she's there and can respond quickly.

1493
01:12:14.165 --> 01:12:16.205
I can't guarantee that one one

1494
01:12:16.445 --> 01:12:17.645
synthetic field would do that though.

1495
01:12:17.645 --> 01:12:20.925
Right. I would, I I just, I don't,

1496
01:12:21.605 --> 01:12:24.165
I don't anticipate that fully solving that.

1497
01:12:24.165 --> 01:12:28.285
Right. Especially if we want you, we probably could do that,

1498
01:12:28.305 --> 01:12:31.125
but then you're not answering, changing some of the game,

1499
01:12:31.185 --> 01:12:33.525
you know, not having as many six o'clock starts of games.

1500
01:12:33.525 --> 01:12:35.725
Right. So, you know, it's sort of

1501
01:12:35.725 --> 01:12:37.325
what do we value as a community?

1502
01:12:38.525 --> 01:12:39.965
We'd have to sort of look at, I think. Yep.

1503
01:12:40.745 --> 01:12:42.845
<v Speaker 1>The other question I think probably art is for you,</v>

1504
01:12:43.105 --> 01:12:44.325
and I hate to put you on the spot

1505
01:12:44.785 --> 01:12:46.445
and some of this was, this is,

1506
01:12:46.445 --> 01:12:48.805
this is in the field study report, but

1507
01:12:48.805 --> 01:12:52.605
because you're here, can you, I don't want you to have

1508
01:12:52.605 --> 01:12:56.325
to do the whole thing, but can you do a brief summary on the

1509
01:12:56.325 --> 01:12:59.365
maintenance differences for your team?

1510
01:13:00.035 --> 01:13:04.605
Meaning what would you need if it were a natural grass

1511
01:13:04.975 --> 01:13:07.845
field versus if it were a synthetic turf field

1512
01:13:07.865 --> 01:13:09.005
versus it was nothing.

1513
01:13:10.005 --> 01:13:11.165
I mean you don't have to answer that if

1514
01:13:11.165 --> 01:13:12.205
it was nothing, if it was today.

1515
01:13:12.705 --> 01:13:15.845
But if we were to change the field or redo the field

1516
01:13:15.845 --> 01:13:17.285
and make it natural, redo the field

1517
01:13:17.285 --> 01:13:19.085
and make it synthetic, what are the implications for you?

1518
01:13:19.595 --> 01:13:23.725
Alright, so if the practice field were to be natural grass,

1519
01:13:24.185 --> 01:13:27.285
one of my first concerns is just the ability to rest it

1520
01:13:28.665 --> 01:13:32.245
and have that opportunity for re recuperative potential

1521
01:13:32.245 --> 01:13:33.245
and re regrowth.

1522
01:13:33.865 --> 01:13:35.325
So that would require, you know,

1523
01:13:35.325 --> 01:13:37.245
much more overeating than what what we do now.

1524
01:13:37.785 --> 01:13:39.405
It would require rest periods.

1525
01:13:40.585 --> 01:13:43.925
It might limit the opportunity for a phys ed

1526
01:13:43.925 --> 01:13:47.045
during those days that we need to have the, the rest periods

1527
01:13:47.895 --> 01:13:51.565
maybe some other things that weren't accounted for such

1528
01:13:51.585 --> 01:13:54.765
as natural night out uses that space right now currently.

1529
01:13:54.865 --> 01:13:56.965
So maybe some other displacement there.

1530
01:13:58.585 --> 01:14:02.565
But from a maintenance standpoint it's basically, you know,

1531
01:14:02.605 --> 01:14:05.485
watering, reseeding, fertilizing, repeat.

1532
01:14:05.705 --> 01:14:09.045
And that's just constantly what you do with a grass field.

1533
01:14:11.195 --> 01:14:14.975
You do have some risks with natural grass in terms of

1534
01:14:15.855 --> 01:14:20.095
diseases during the summertime, gray leaf spot,

1535
01:14:21.255 --> 01:14:22.775
pythium root rot, those types of things

1536
01:14:22.775 --> 01:14:24.015
that you have to really account for.

1537
01:14:24.395 --> 01:14:26.775
If you're gonna manage that grass feel at the higher level

1538
01:14:26.775 --> 01:14:29.695
and make that investment, then you really need to

1539
01:14:30.295 --> 01:14:32.135
reconsider a maintenance program for those things.

1540
01:14:33.355 --> 01:14:36.215
And then coming out of winter ice damage

1541
01:14:36.995 --> 01:14:38.855
can be a huge issue as well.

1542
01:14:38.875 --> 01:14:43.415
So that might ruin your early opportunity out there.

1543
01:14:44.035 --> 01:14:48.735
So it does have all that, you know, mowing painting a lot

1544
01:14:48.735 --> 01:14:50.655
of work on, on natural grass field.

1545
01:14:51.595 --> 01:14:53.735
Not to say that synthetic doesn't have its own work

1546
01:14:53.835 --> 01:14:55.295
and its own its own issues.

1547
01:14:56.115 --> 01:14:59.215
It does need, you know, grooming, which is the aeration

1548
01:14:59.215 --> 01:15:01.775
and decomp compacting of whatever infill surface

1549
01:15:01.845 --> 01:15:06.495
that you choose to make sure that that head injury criteria

1550
01:15:06.535 --> 01:15:09.455
and that impact and the performance and the pleading

1551
01:15:09.455 --> 01:15:12.615
and the traction rotation stays at the

1552
01:15:12.615 --> 01:15:13.735
expectation that you want it to.

1553
01:15:13.735 --> 01:15:17.255
For player safety right now

1554
01:15:18.315 --> 01:15:21.335
we like to do four visits with our grooming team for

1555
01:15:21.335 --> 01:15:23.735
that, probably do about three.

1556
01:15:23.885 --> 01:15:26.335
It's, it's really difficult to schedule some

1557
01:15:26.335 --> 01:15:28.455
of the maintenance even on the synthetic

1558
01:15:28.815 --> 01:15:29.855
and have the time for that.

1559
01:15:30.035 --> 01:15:34.975
So let for synthetic could be for us less, less painting

1560
01:15:37.875 --> 01:15:42.015
and you know, just a lot less work day

1561
01:15:42.015 --> 01:15:44.215
to day in terms of filling divots

1562
01:15:44.215 --> 01:15:48.095
and trying to get the, the linearity back for the next game.

1563
01:15:48.915 --> 01:15:50.655
And just a high level staffing,

1564
01:15:51.755 --> 01:15:53.215
you have the appropriate people for both.

1565
01:15:54.855 --> 01:15:57.375
I would say for synthetic we would have the appropriate

1566
01:15:57.375 --> 01:16:02.175
people, the, the time commitment for a natural grass field

1567
01:16:02.435 --> 01:16:06.535
to make that investment to be at the varsity level with

1568
01:16:06.535 --> 01:16:08.415
that much potential wear

1569
01:16:08.435 --> 01:16:12.655
and usage would concern me not having to the time

1570
01:16:13.205 --> 01:16:15.815
with our in-house staff to do those maintenance tasks

1571
01:16:16.565 --> 01:16:18.175
that we would do in-house and,

1572
01:16:18.235 --> 01:16:20.975
and where a contractor would not be available

1573
01:16:21.155 --> 01:16:25.575
to do those daily, those daily tasks in terms of, you know,

1574
01:16:25.575 --> 01:16:29.015
fixing irrigation over overseeing

1575
01:16:29.645 --> 01:16:33.335
filling divots gold mouth potential like previous speaker

1576
01:16:33.335 --> 01:16:36.335
mentioned the limitations of the space.

1577
01:16:37.035 --> 01:16:41.135
So it does fit a full-size field, but barely.

1578
01:16:42.035 --> 01:16:44.335
So by doing that, if you were

1579
01:16:44.335 --> 01:16:45.775
to choose a natural grass field,

1580
01:16:46.995 --> 01:16:49.735
you really limit your opportunity to rotate

1581
01:16:49.755 --> 01:16:51.415
and move goalmouth wear.

1582
01:16:51.515 --> 01:16:52.935
So goalmouth wear from soccer,

1583
01:16:53.035 --> 01:16:55.895
go mouth wear from field hockey and lacrosse is the worst.

1584
01:16:56.555 --> 01:16:59.335
So to try to move, move that space around

1585
01:16:59.335 --> 01:17:02.015
and give that grade and area

1586
01:17:02.035 --> 01:17:05.015
and opportunity to re recuperate is very limited.

1587
01:17:06.425 --> 01:17:10.485
Understood. All right, thank you. Anybody else? Dr. Welch?

1588
01:17:13.125 --> 01:17:14.725
<v Speaker 9>I I don't wanna take up too much time,</v>

1589
01:17:14.785 --> 01:17:17.085
but I I'm gonna ask you a question that is something

1590
01:17:17.085 --> 01:17:19.045
that's come to me a lot and since we have somebody

1591
01:17:19.045 --> 01:17:21.325
with your expertise, I'd just love you to speak on it.

1592
01:17:22.265 --> 01:17:24.365
My colleague Ms. Brune mentioned that members

1593
01:17:24.365 --> 01:17:25.845
of the public have come to us and,

1594
01:17:26.105 --> 01:17:29.405
and express some concerns about chemical contamination based

1595
01:17:29.405 --> 01:17:30.565
on the proximity of the field

1596
01:17:30.585 --> 01:17:32.045
to water sources like Doug Pond.

1597
01:17:34.485 --> 01:17:37.725
I, in talking about maintaining a natural grass field,

1598
01:17:38.545 --> 01:17:42.525
you've talked about re-seeding fertilizer disease

1599
01:17:42.525 --> 01:17:44.685
treatment, all that kind of stuff.

1600
01:17:45.685 --> 01:17:48.845
I I mean the, the, the yard in front of my house

1601
01:17:50.225 --> 01:17:52.085
is much smaller than what we're talking about.

1602
01:17:52.185 --> 01:17:53.405
And it is all I can do

1603
01:17:53.405 --> 01:17:55.885
to keep it from basically being a crabgrass farm

1604
01:17:55.945 --> 01:17:57.165
for about a quarter of the year.

1605
01:17:58.225 --> 01:18:01.925
So it's,

1606
01:18:01.995 --> 01:18:03.685
it's, it's hard.

1607
01:18:04.185 --> 01:18:06.365
And so my guess my question is

1608
01:18:06.365 --> 01:18:08.125
what if this is a grass field,

1609
01:18:08.275 --> 01:18:12.245
what are we gonna be treating it with to keep it looking

1610
01:18:12.835 --> 01:18:16.085
like a nice grass field?

1611
01:18:16.195 --> 01:18:18.525
Just to put a, a finer point on this question about

1612
01:18:19.845 --> 01:18:21.645
chemicals and water contamination and,

1613
01:18:21.645 --> 01:18:22.725
and all that sort of thing.

1614
01:18:23.795 --> 01:18:28.045
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, so I, I would say for our practice field,</v>

1615
01:18:28.045 --> 01:18:31.285
if this were to be a natural grass field, it would probably

1616
01:18:32.345 --> 01:18:35.165
mirror our cultural practices for

1617
01:18:35.165 --> 01:18:37.245
what we have on our existing natural grass fields.

1618
01:18:37.525 --> 01:18:39.805
And that does include the use of pesticides,

1619
01:18:40.555 --> 01:18:42.445
pesticide definitions, very broad.

1620
01:18:42.715 --> 01:18:47.165
Yeah. But we do use insecticides

1621
01:18:47.165 --> 01:18:48.205
for white grub control.

1622
01:18:48.305 --> 01:18:52.085
Yep. Which is a necessity for sports fields

1623
01:18:52.145 --> 01:18:53.325
and traction rotation

1624
01:18:53.385 --> 01:18:56.165
and all that type all all those metrics

1625
01:18:57.465 --> 01:18:59.725
we do at times use herbicides

1626
01:19:01.065 --> 01:19:05.445
and we do use other wetting agents

1627
01:19:05.445 --> 01:19:09.005
and those types of things, but that's more organic control.

1628
01:19:09.145 --> 01:19:10.565
So between insecticides

1629
01:19:10.565 --> 01:19:12.405
and herbicides you do have that option

1630
01:19:12.945 --> 01:19:17.165
or that potential for the exposure of the same

1631
01:19:17.715 --> 01:19:20.845
same nature as you would have with other chemicals.

1632
01:19:20.845 --> 01:19:23.165
<v Speaker 9>Yeah, but I mean just, just to put a fine point on,</v>

1633
01:19:23.285 --> 01:19:24.725
'cause these are the questions that I'm gonna get

1634
01:19:24.725 --> 01:19:26.285
and maybe there are other colleagues are gonna get,

1635
01:19:26.445 --> 01:19:27.765
I mean are we talking about

1636
01:19:28.395 --> 01:19:31.445
like the organic milky white spores stuff?

1637
01:19:31.505 --> 01:19:34.205
Are we talking about like insecticide?

1638
01:19:34.205 --> 01:19:35.245
Are we talking about roundup?

1639
01:19:35.265 --> 01:19:39.045
Are we talking about the

1640
01:19:39.075 --> 01:19:40.685
organic we killer?

1641
01:19:40.685 --> 01:19:42.085
Right. The, these are the questions

1642
01:19:42.085 --> 01:19:44.485
that I'm getting when people are trying to push me one way

1643
01:19:44.485 --> 01:19:46.605
or another on, on voting on this field thing.

1644
01:19:46.915 --> 01:19:50.205
<v Speaker 1>Okay. So from an insecticide standpoint,</v>

1645
01:19:51.375 --> 01:19:54.845
there are on this field we would likely not use the

1646
01:19:54.855 --> 01:19:56.445
biological control for that.

1647
01:19:56.445 --> 01:19:59.805
That's the milky spore, that's Steris.

1648
01:20:01.225 --> 01:20:04.525
We do use a product called arine

1649
01:20:04.625 --> 01:20:08.965
or chloro OLE is the active ingredient

1650
01:20:09.115 --> 01:20:11.445
that is a reduced risk pesticide.

1651
01:20:11.465 --> 01:20:15.325
So it's not something that, that you would see

1652
01:20:16.025 --> 01:20:18.485
that's more common in the past of toxicity

1653
01:20:18.745 --> 01:20:21.485
and it has much, much lower toxicity rates

1654
01:20:22.615 --> 01:20:25.765
lower than salt and butter

1655
01:20:25.825 --> 01:20:27.445
and nicotine and those type of things.

1656
01:20:29.265 --> 01:20:31.565
So that would be really important for herbicides.

1657
01:20:31.565 --> 01:20:34.045
We do use a lot of newer technologies which

1658
01:20:34.695 --> 01:20:37.245
don't have the leaching potential, don't have the

1659
01:20:38.405 --> 01:20:39.565
exposure potential, you know,

1660
01:20:39.565 --> 01:20:43.765
after it's, you know, absorbed by the plant Yep.

1661
01:20:43.785 --> 01:20:46.645
And broke, broken down back into carbon hydrant and oxygen.

1662
01:20:47.505 --> 01:20:49.445
So very targeted mode of actions.

1663
01:20:49.825 --> 01:20:52.685
We do tie those applications when they're not

1664
01:20:53.705 --> 01:20:54.725
no school kids are present.

1665
01:20:54.865 --> 01:20:56.085
Yep. The fields aren't being used.

1666
01:20:56.115 --> 01:20:58.205
It's generally the first week of July.

1667
01:20:58.595 --> 01:21:00.165
Agronomically not ideal,

1668
01:21:00.345 --> 01:21:04.285
but we make that sacrifice to avoid any potential exposure

1669
01:21:04.905 --> 01:21:08.245
for people walking their dog and or using the field.

1670
01:21:08.385 --> 01:21:13.285
So, so a a natural grass field

1671
01:21:13.305 --> 01:21:15.685
is not without, it's its

1672
01:21:15.685 --> 01:21:16.805
own concerns for those things, the stuff you

1673
01:21:16.805 --> 01:21:18.325
<v Speaker 9>Have to</v>
<v Speaker 1>Use to treat it, but when it's managed</v>

1674
01:21:18.645 --> 01:21:21.285
properly, you, you don't have the leaching in into the

1675
01:21:21.285 --> 01:21:22.645
groundwater for those type of things.

1676
01:21:23.285 --> 01:21:25.285
A lot of those chemicals that might be referenced

1677
01:21:25.305 --> 01:21:27.965
for groundwater leaching potential Yeah.

1678
01:21:28.865 --> 01:21:32.245
Are older, not used, not or banned in Massachusetts

1679
01:21:32.345 --> 01:21:33.645
or band hunt school property.

1680
01:21:33.865 --> 01:21:37.285
<v Speaker 9>So and that's consistent with your other grass management,</v>

1681
01:21:37.285 --> 01:21:39.005
grass field management practices in other parts

1682
01:21:39.005 --> 01:21:40.325
of the town. Correct.

1683
01:21:40.355 --> 01:21:42.565
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, so everything across town is a,</v>

1684
01:21:42.925 --> 01:21:45.205
I would call it a hybrid approach between synthetic

1685
01:21:45.465 --> 01:21:46.645
and organic.

1686
01:21:46.645 --> 01:21:49.525
Whether it's fertilizer or control products.

1687
01:21:49.525 --> 01:21:51.925
We do use basil genis and other sites.

1688
01:21:52.585 --> 01:21:56.125
It just depends on what your use expectation is. Got it.

1689
01:21:56.505 --> 01:21:58.845
To meet the demand of three to four times

1690
01:21:59.395 --> 01:22:00.605
what where would be

1691
01:22:00.855 --> 01:22:01.855
<v Speaker 9>Understood.</v>

1692
01:22:01.855 --> 01:22:03.405
I appreciate you going into detail about that

1693
01:22:03.405 --> 01:22:05.365
and I appreciate the chair and the committee's patience

1694
01:22:05.365 --> 01:22:06.725
with just trying to get all this

1695
01:22:06.865 --> 01:22:08.845
<v Speaker 1>No, it's good</v>
<v Speaker 9>On the record. So thank I yield</v>

1696
01:22:08.845 --> 01:22:09.845
<v Speaker 1>Back.</v>

1697
01:22:09.845 --> 01:22:11.565
I was not prepared for a full chemistry. I love it.

1698
01:22:12.025 --> 01:22:14.085
All the good chemical stuff. Good stuff.

1699
01:22:14.375 --> 01:22:15.405
Other comments? Just make

1700
01:22:15.405 --> 01:22:16.525
<v Speaker 9>Sure we spell all those words right in.</v>

1701
01:22:16.675 --> 01:22:17.765
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, did we get that in the minute?</v>

1702
01:22:18.105 --> 01:22:19.485
The, the minutes reflect

1703
01:22:19.485 --> 01:22:21.285
because we know Dr. Welch is gonna look

1704
01:22:21.705 --> 01:22:24.325
and make sure that the chemicals are spelled correctly.

1705
01:22:26.025 --> 01:22:30.605
Any other questions? Alright, thank you all for being here

1706
01:22:32.305 --> 01:22:33.965
and we will continue this conversation

1707
01:22:33.965 --> 01:22:36.485
as a committee at our, whatever the next

1708
01:22:36.505 --> 01:22:37.605
school committee meeting is.

1709
01:22:39.385 --> 01:22:43.165
And now December 7th is what I was about to say 'cause

1710
01:22:45.265 --> 01:22:49.405
and now we will go back to, we're gonna do it once

1711
01:22:49.405 --> 01:22:51.485
and for all the school committee goals.

1712
01:22:52.775 --> 01:22:55.485
We're gonna do it. We got this,

1713
01:23:02.095 --> 01:23:04.625
well it's almost December,

1714
01:23:05.945 --> 01:23:07.365
so All right.

1715
01:23:08.225 --> 01:23:12.565
So school committee goals. What do we got?

1716
01:23:13.705 --> 01:23:18.245
We have, does everybody have goals in front of them?

1717
01:23:22.925 --> 01:23:27.235
We're doing goals now. Everybody. We love goals.

1718
01:23:27.775 --> 01:23:31.875
All right, so I'm pulling up

1719
01:23:33.335 --> 01:23:36.555
the document, which is attached to the agenda.

1720
01:23:36.815 --> 01:23:39.835
All right. So we had discussed, I'll just go through 'em

1721
01:23:39.835 --> 01:23:41.515
and we can at,

1722
01:23:41.555 --> 01:23:44.235
I think at the end we will just agree

1723
01:23:44.415 --> 01:23:45.875
on whatever the total set is.

1724
01:23:45.875 --> 01:23:47.035
But I'll just summarize.

1725
01:23:47.695 --> 01:23:52.195
We had talked about goal one a, a sort of resources

1726
01:23:52.195 --> 01:23:54.615
and infrastructure goal.

1727
01:23:55.195 --> 01:23:58.175
We had talked about a goal two of communication

1728
01:23:58.175 --> 01:23:59.215
and community engagement.

1729
01:24:00.555 --> 01:24:04.095
We had talked about a potential goal three having to do

1730
01:24:04.095 --> 01:24:05.215
with policy.

1731
01:24:07.315 --> 01:24:10.895
We had talked about a potential goal four having

1732
01:24:10.915 --> 01:24:12.255
to do with student outcomes.

1733
01:24:14.505 --> 01:24:17.845
So goal one was the resources infrastructure.

1734
01:24:18.075 --> 01:24:20.045
That was Catherine and Elise.

1735
01:24:20.115 --> 01:24:23.125
Catherine, do you wanna, are you prepared

1736
01:24:23.785 --> 01:24:25.405
to discuss or to

1737
01:24:25.925 --> 01:24:26.925
<v Speaker 11>Summarize?</v>

1738
01:24:26.925 --> 01:24:27.845
Well also, Dr. Welch met with us too

1739
01:24:28.185 --> 01:24:30.685
<v Speaker 1>And Dr. Welch. Right.</v>

1740
01:24:31.665 --> 01:24:33.245
<v Speaker 11>So to be honest, I'm still getting</v>

1741
01:24:33.305 --> 01:24:34.325
my computer up and going.

1742
01:24:35.305 --> 01:24:36.285
So if you wanna take another

1743
01:24:36.285 --> 01:24:37.325
goal first. Okay, then I'll come

1744
01:24:37.325 --> 01:24:38.325
<v Speaker 1>Back.</v>

1745
01:24:38.325 --> 01:24:40.525
So Kathy, why don't we talk about the potential goal

1746
01:24:40.635 --> 01:24:42.085
that we were discussing.

1747
01:24:42.105 --> 01:24:46.005
The policy one. Do you, do you wanna speak on it or shall i?

1748
01:24:46.195 --> 01:24:48.965
<v Speaker 25>Sure. Policy</v>

1749
01:24:50.105 --> 01:24:52.365
as everyone at this table knows is one of the few things

1750
01:24:52.365 --> 01:24:55.445
that we are charged by the state with doing.

1751
01:24:56.225 --> 01:25:00.085
We have a standing committee for that reason

1752
01:25:00.585 --> 01:25:02.085
and have had his, since

1753
01:25:02.085 --> 01:25:03.205
before I joined this committee,

1754
01:25:06.715 --> 01:25:08.725
that committee has already come out

1755
01:25:08.725 --> 01:25:13.435
and said, we, our plan is to take on I and J this year

1756
01:25:14.335 --> 01:25:16.435
and, you know, set up a rotation

1757
01:25:16.775 --> 01:25:18.115
for when we're going to do it.

1758
01:25:18.755 --> 01:25:20.635
I don't understand.

1759
01:25:20.695 --> 01:25:23.755
And perhaps I'm just not being creative enough why we would

1760
01:25:23.785 --> 01:25:26.675
need a different goal in our

1761
01:25:28.345 --> 01:25:32.735
goal section than what A,

1762
01:25:32.745 --> 01:25:33.775
we're charged with doing.

1763
01:25:34.095 --> 01:25:38.815
B we've already committed to doing and C seems like an easy,

1764
01:25:38.915 --> 01:25:42.455
but if I might editorialize a little bit of a cheesy cheat

1765
01:25:43.075 --> 01:25:47.335
on our goals, I'd like to see us focused on

1766
01:25:51.055 --> 01:25:52.195
bigger targets, I guess.

1767
01:25:53.225 --> 01:25:56.195
<v Speaker 1>Yeah, I mean I, I, Kathy and I agreed on this.</v>

1768
01:25:56.315 --> 01:26:00.315
I think that the, we discussed the idea that the policy may,

1769
01:26:00.315 --> 01:26:01.475
maybe we didn't fully understand,

1770
01:26:01.475 --> 01:26:06.325
but the, the, the a goal, the po the policies charge is

1771
01:26:06.345 --> 01:26:07.805
to deal with policies.

1772
01:26:07.805 --> 01:26:11.085
To have a goal around that would be just saying do the thing

1773
01:26:11.085 --> 01:26:12.165
that you're already supposed to do.

1774
01:26:13.865 --> 01:26:17.125
As, as Kathy just mentioned there is, there are two for,

1775
01:26:17.145 --> 01:26:21.365
for those who are new to the policy subcommittee work,

1776
01:26:22.335 --> 01:26:23.685
there are generally two types

1777
01:26:24.225 --> 01:26:27.285
or maybe three types of work,

1778
01:26:27.755 --> 01:26:31.285
maintenance work going through routinely going

1779
01:26:31.285 --> 01:26:32.245
through the policies and making

1780
01:26:32.275 --> 01:26:33.325
sure that they're up to date.

1781
01:26:33.795 --> 01:26:36.805
Then reactive work when the state makes a change.

1782
01:26:37.065 --> 01:26:39.205
And that our policy has to reflect that as well.

1783
01:26:40.025 --> 01:26:43.245
And then any policies that we feel like we need

1784
01:26:43.245 --> 01:26:45.605
to change proactively, that is already

1785
01:26:45.605 --> 01:26:47.125
what the policy subcommittee is doing.

1786
01:26:48.905 --> 01:26:51.645
And therefore, you know, in our, in our procedure is

1787
01:26:51.645 --> 01:26:54.165
that the policy subcommittee will do that work

1788
01:26:54.185 --> 01:26:56.845
and then bring proposed changes back to the full committee.

1789
01:26:57.585 --> 01:26:59.525
So we sort of were of the mind,

1790
01:26:59.865 --> 01:27:02.885
and I agree with Kathy that there are other goals that feel

1791
01:27:04.265 --> 01:27:05.645
bigger and better defined

1792
01:27:05.705 --> 01:27:09.405
for the whole school committee given that that one is just

1793
01:27:09.875 --> 01:27:11.205
what the policy subcommittee does.

1794
01:27:12.665 --> 01:27:16.085
So unless there's disagreement, we'll move on.

1795
01:27:18.105 --> 01:27:20.225
So, great.

1796
01:27:20.445 --> 01:27:23.825
So we'll strike that one as a potential Jamon

1797
01:27:24.525 --> 01:27:25.865
HAI or Ms.

1798
01:27:25.915 --> 01:27:28.825
Gomes Ke are you, is it, I don't know if all three of,

1799
01:27:28.825 --> 01:27:30.225
if you had a chance to discuss your,

1800
01:27:30.545 --> 01:27:31.945
the communication and communic engagement call?

1801
01:27:33.525 --> 01:27:35.945
<v Speaker 18>We have not, but we will. We</v>

1802
01:27:36.065 --> 01:27:38.745
<v Speaker 1>Can do it right now or we can do, do you want?</v>

1803
01:27:39.755 --> 01:27:40.865
Let's do it right now. 'cause

1804
01:27:40.865 --> 01:27:43.465
otherwise we're gonna be in 2027.

1805
01:27:44.325 --> 01:27:46.825
So what do we think, I mean we've done this goal

1806
01:27:46.825 --> 01:27:49.745
before, I think we've already established,

1807
01:27:49.745 --> 01:27:51.985
this is obviously a very critical part as elected members

1808
01:27:52.485 --> 01:27:55.585
who are representing the community to, to do a lot

1809
01:27:55.585 --> 01:27:56.865
of community engagement.

1810
01:27:56.965 --> 01:27:59.825
Do we, what, what are specific things I guess

1811
01:27:59.825 --> 01:28:03.065
that we can say we wanna achieve with that goal?

1812
01:28:05.905 --> 01:28:08.585
<v Speaker 18>I can go first, and this is building</v>

1813
01:28:08.645 --> 01:28:09.745
on things we've done before.

1814
01:28:09.785 --> 01:28:13.025
I would say there's three things. One is engage

1815
01:28:13.025 --> 01:28:16.185
with the community through ongoing community events.

1816
01:28:16.565 --> 01:28:18.625
So think about how often do we wanna go

1817
01:28:18.625 --> 01:28:20.225
to the farmer's market, for example,

1818
01:28:21.525 --> 01:28:22.865
the days is part of that.

1819
01:28:23.675 --> 01:28:25.105
Other events y you know,

1820
01:28:25.915 --> 01:28:27.105
which is the one I'm thinking about?

1821
01:28:27.105 --> 01:28:28.625
Oh, the New Year's Eve, which

1822
01:28:28.625 --> 01:28:29.625
<v Speaker 1>Is coming up.</v>

1823
01:28:29.625 --> 01:28:30.175
Yeah.

1824
01:28:31.005 --> 01:28:33.465
<v Speaker 18>So that's kinda being out there more broadly.</v>

1825
01:28:34.855 --> 01:28:39.305
Part two I, I would say is a more

1826
01:28:40.865 --> 01:28:43.665
targeted outreach to groups that

1827
01:28:45.005 --> 01:28:46.345
we might not usually hear from.

1828
01:28:46.605 --> 01:28:48.305
And that obviously includes figuring out

1829
01:28:48.305 --> 01:28:50.385
who we're not usually hearing from and,

1830
01:28:50.685 --> 01:28:52.825
and then how do we reach out to them.

1831
01:28:54.605 --> 01:28:58.705
And then number three, I would say specific engagement

1832
01:28:59.425 --> 01:29:00.825
campaigns around specific decisions,

1833
01:29:00.825 --> 01:29:02.925
major decisions in front of the school committee.

1834
01:29:02.985 --> 01:29:06.205
So for example, you know, Memorial comes

1835
01:29:06.205 --> 01:29:08.565
to mind in the past it was the override.

1836
01:29:08.985 --> 01:29:10.005
So those kinds of like

1837
01:29:10.345 --> 01:29:13.205
how do we engage the community in a proactive way

1838
01:29:13.205 --> 01:29:14.205
around major decisions.

1839
01:29:15.515 --> 01:29:17.125
<v Speaker 1>Okay. Mr. Patel, do you wanna add that?</v>

1840
01:29:18.625 --> 01:29:20.645
<v Speaker 24>Not much to add, but just we already have,</v>

1841
01:29:21.165 --> 01:29:22.885
I think we already have a good slate

1842
01:29:22.945 --> 01:29:25.365
of community engagement events that are happening

1843
01:29:25.365 --> 01:29:26.405
because of the school building

1844
01:29:26.585 --> 01:29:28.605
and obviously New Year's Eve, things like that.

1845
01:29:29.105 --> 01:29:30.965
So I think just getting people

1846
01:29:30.985 --> 01:29:32.885
to know about them I think is the main,

1847
01:29:32.885 --> 01:29:33.965
main goal we need to focus on.

1848
01:29:36.145 --> 01:29:37.845
You know, like the events already exist,

1849
01:29:37.965 --> 01:29:39.245
we just need to communicate that better.

1850
01:29:39.445 --> 01:29:43.245
I think. I don't know how the Instagram is working,

1851
01:29:43.305 --> 01:29:45.565
the Instagram handle, if it's got any followers yet,

1852
01:29:46.435 --> 01:29:47.525
<v Speaker 1>It's got a massive amount.</v>

1853
01:29:47.585 --> 01:29:49.005
We count in three digits.

1854
01:29:49.265 --> 01:29:52.085
<v Speaker 24>Oh, okay.</v>
<v Speaker 1>To the left of the decimal.</v>

1855
01:29:52.675 --> 01:29:54.965
<v Speaker 24>Well I know, you know, I mean I don't know if it's I</v>

1856
01:29:54.965 --> 01:29:56.565
Instagram and Facebook are the same,

1857
01:29:56.565 --> 01:29:58.485
but I know like the town is sort

1858
01:29:58.485 --> 01:30:00.165
of very active actually on Facebook.

1859
01:30:00.305 --> 01:30:04.405
So somehow posting those on Facebook would be a good idea.

1860
01:30:05.545 --> 01:30:07.805
And this, the other thought I had in general was

1861
01:30:08.915 --> 01:30:11.965
when it comes to these like, you know, more

1862
01:30:14.065 --> 01:30:16.325
in depth things like the field

1863
01:30:16.325 --> 01:30:18.125
and things like that, I think those are the things that

1864
01:30:18.865 --> 01:30:20.365
you're gonna get a lot of emails about.

1865
01:30:20.425 --> 01:30:24.845
And I think it'd be nice if the response is that, you know,

1866
01:30:24.865 --> 01:30:27.965
you as a chair or the superintendent sends out, get sort

1867
01:30:27.965 --> 01:30:29.325
of put in as a frequently asked

1868
01:30:29.565 --> 01:30:30.725
questions on the website or something.

1869
01:30:30.825 --> 01:30:33.725
So not only are you not doing the same work again and again,

1870
01:30:33.825 --> 01:30:36.605
but if someone else is looking for that information,

1871
01:30:36.715 --> 01:30:38.085
it's just sort of there

1872
01:30:38.465 --> 01:30:42.365
before having to email you out that there's just

1873
01:30:42.465 --> 01:30:43.465
<v Speaker 1>My thoughts.</v>

1874
01:30:43.835 --> 01:30:44.925
Good. Ms.

1875
01:30:44.975 --> 01:30:46.765
Gomes, would you like, are you, would you like

1876
01:30:46.765 --> 01:30:48.205
to add anything to this one?

1877
01:30:51.735 --> 01:30:53.045
<v Speaker 8>Could you repeat the goal</v>

1878
01:30:53.075 --> 01:30:54.605
like, just so I can hear it in the,

1879
01:30:54.965 --> 01:30:56.165
<v Speaker 1>This is, this is the the com Yeah, sure.</v>

1880
01:30:56.165 --> 01:30:58.405
This is the communication and community engagement goal.

1881
01:31:01.155 --> 01:31:03.775
<v Speaker 8>Do, do we ha, I know we had something, you know,</v>

1882
01:31:03.975 --> 01:31:06.535
formally in writing and I'm happy to connect with Shai

1883
01:31:09.725 --> 01:31:10.895
outside of this meeting,

1884
01:31:11.155 --> 01:31:13.655
but is there anything more specific or is we just

1885
01:31:14.035 --> 01:31:15.035
<v Speaker 1>In general?</v>

1886
01:31:15.035 --> 01:31:16.775
We're just, yeah, we, we, we are just trying

1887
01:31:16.775 --> 01:31:19.175
to ultimately get to something that we could measure

1888
01:31:19.955 --> 01:31:22.855
at the end of the year to say that we, you know, to sort

1889
01:31:22.855 --> 01:31:24.135
of measure the work that we did

1890
01:31:24.165 --> 01:31:25.695
regarding community engagement.

1891
01:31:26.765 --> 01:31:29.295
<v Speaker 8>Okay.</v>
<v Speaker 1>And you can, we can work, we don't have</v>

1892
01:31:29.295 --> 01:31:32.935
to pull teeth here so we can continue

1893
01:31:32.935 --> 01:31:35.215
that conversation on this particular goal if we don't feel

1894
01:31:35.215 --> 01:31:37.095
like we have the measurables just yet.

1895
01:31:38.175 --> 01:31:41.065
<v Speaker 8>Yeah, I would say we definitely maybe have to do some work</v>

1896
01:31:41.065 --> 01:31:42.105
around the measurables,

1897
01:31:42.245 --> 01:31:44.385
but I'd love

1898
01:31:44.385 --> 01:31:47.785
to get more engagement specifically from METCO families

1899
01:31:48.205 --> 01:31:52.265
and establishing maybe some sort of system

1900
01:31:52.275 --> 01:31:54.425
where we can have more streamlined.

1901
01:31:56.985 --> 01:31:59.885
I know you guys obviously make the meetings very accessible

1902
01:31:59.885 --> 01:32:00.925
and it's accessible to the public,

1903
01:32:00.985 --> 01:32:04.245
but maybe finding a way to streamline how we can

1904
01:32:04.865 --> 01:32:08.365
get more engagement from families like to us.

1905
01:32:08.785 --> 01:32:12.565
<v Speaker 1>Yep. Great. I think perhaps what Ms.</v>

1906
01:32:12.565 --> 01:32:14.965
Gomes referencing and what maybe the takeaway is the

1907
01:32:15.125 --> 01:32:18.445
homework here for that particular group is a shy,

1908
01:32:18.445 --> 01:32:21.245
what you referenced in part two, like the targeted outreach.

1909
01:32:21.665 --> 01:32:25.285
So if we could maybe come up with some specific

1910
01:32:25.935 --> 01:32:28.365
which groups we would like to target, how we would like

1911
01:32:28.365 --> 01:32:30.125
to target, what kinds of things that we can do.

1912
01:32:30.795 --> 01:32:33.205
That would be I think a good thing

1913
01:32:33.205 --> 01:32:35.745
that we could measure at the end, right?

1914
01:32:36.085 --> 01:32:37.865
Or is that a You were gonna say something?

1915
01:32:38.505 --> 01:32:39.945
I was gonna say something, but not

1916
01:32:39.945 --> 01:32:40.945
<v Speaker 25>Exactly</v>
<v Speaker 1>That.</v>

1917
01:32:40.945 --> 01:32:42.385
Okay. I wouldn't wanna steal your thunder.

1918
01:32:42.565 --> 01:32:43.945
You can steal my thunder. Go ahead.

1919
01:32:47.425 --> 01:32:49.705
<v Speaker 25>I struggle with this goal, not</v>

1920
01:32:49.705 --> 01:32:53.425
because I don't think it's important but

1921
01:32:53.425 --> 01:32:56.305
because the community engagement piece of

1922
01:32:56.855 --> 01:33:00.265
attending farmer's markets or Natick days or the community

1923
01:33:00.365 --> 01:33:02.105
or New Year's Eve,

1924
01:33:02.305 --> 01:33:04.585
whatever the other thing is, is easy to measure.

1925
01:33:06.005 --> 01:33:09.105
But I don't know how we evaluate to what end.

1926
01:33:09.745 --> 01:33:14.105
Like we had a lot of people stop by at a table that's good

1927
01:33:14.245 --> 01:33:17.985
but I don't know where we've taken it from.

1928
01:33:17.985 --> 01:33:22.225
Then on the other hand, the who are we not hearing from

1929
01:33:22.225 --> 01:33:23.225
and how do we reach them?

1930
01:33:24.575 --> 01:33:29.465
It's hard to measure. So without something

1931
01:33:29.465 --> 01:33:32.265
upfront of of, you know, we're going to make specific

1932
01:33:33.515 --> 01:33:38.365
these specific, please not the right

1933
01:33:38.365 --> 01:33:41.045
word, but it may be to various groups.

1934
01:33:44.085 --> 01:33:46.685
I don't know how we measure it in the end.

1935
01:33:48.485 --> 01:33:52.245
I think one of the things that I appreciate the chair having

1936
01:33:52.575 --> 01:33:57.485
taken an ex a recommendation to add our agenda piece into

1937
01:33:58.265 --> 01:34:03.045
the engage letters so that we tell people more

1938
01:34:03.065 --> 01:34:05.765
of what we're going

1939
01:34:05.765 --> 01:34:07.605
to be discussing at the next meeting rather than,

1940
01:34:07.625 --> 01:34:11.205
oh I happen to see something somewhere on the mom's group at

1941
01:34:11.365 --> 01:34:12.445
midnight because I wasn't sleeping

1942
01:34:13.065 --> 01:34:14.605
but there was nobody to ask at midnight.

1943
01:34:14.845 --> 01:34:16.205
Although the mom's group there probably is.

1944
01:34:18.185 --> 01:34:21.205
So I'm just, as I say, I struggle with it

1945
01:34:21.205 --> 01:34:24.725
because there's the easy to measure but so what piece of it?

1946
01:34:25.585 --> 01:34:29.925
And, and I don't mean, so what as pejoratively as it sounds,

1947
01:34:30.395 --> 01:34:33.085
because I think, you know, seeing people is, is always good,

1948
01:34:33.225 --> 01:34:37.125
but what did we accomplish from it versus the less

1949
01:34:37.125 --> 01:34:38.165
easy to measure piece.

1950
01:34:38.225 --> 01:34:42.325
So I think without some more of a plan,

1951
01:34:42.505 --> 01:34:44.605
I'm a little tweaked in between here

1952
01:34:44.675 --> 01:34:46.165
<v Speaker 1>There's a quality and quantity.</v>

1953
01:34:46.355 --> 01:34:48.605
Yeah. I, you know, shy.

1954
01:34:48.905 --> 01:34:50.565
<v Speaker 18>So I think it's a valid point</v>

1955
01:34:52.185 --> 01:34:56.885
and I have some thoughts being researcher

1956
01:34:56.965 --> 01:34:58.285
and sitting next to a researcher.

1957
01:34:58.705 --> 01:35:00.885
We should be thinking about collecting the data.

1958
01:35:02.105 --> 01:35:04.565
One of my thoughts is, and I don't know if Dr Special

1959
01:35:04.565 --> 01:35:05.805
or others can help me out,

1960
01:35:05.905 --> 01:35:09.085
but when we did the survey for the strategic plan,

1961
01:35:09.585 --> 01:35:11.525
was there anything around school committee engagement?

1962
01:35:11.705 --> 01:35:13.645
And I'm wondering if that there was any baseline

1963
01:35:13.645 --> 01:35:14.805
data that we could use.

1964
01:35:14.915 --> 01:35:17.005
<v Speaker 1>This is about to make us very sad. What?</v>

1965
01:35:17.165 --> 01:35:20.405
'cause I think there was no, no, I'd have to go back

1966
01:35:20.405 --> 01:35:22.005
and look, but I don't think so. And,

1967
01:35:22.025 --> 01:35:23.365
<v Speaker 18>And, and that's fine.</v>

1968
01:35:24.615 --> 01:35:27.645
Today I got the flash vote. I dunno if you people use Yeah.

1969
01:35:27.705 --> 01:35:29.405
Get the flash vote. I'm wondering if

1970
01:35:29.405 --> 01:35:31.085
that's something either the town can help us with

1971
01:35:31.085 --> 01:35:32.325
or even we can do on our own.

1972
01:35:32.785 --> 01:35:34.845
We would have to figure out how to do it in a way, you know,

1973
01:35:34.845 --> 01:35:36.685
we don't wanna overburden people with surveys.

1974
01:35:36.685 --> 01:35:38.205
You know, that's, as researchers,

1975
01:35:38.205 --> 01:35:39.365
that's the first thing we always think about.

1976
01:35:39.485 --> 01:35:41.965
Absolutely. Survey, survey, survey. But I'm wondering if

1977
01:35:41.965 --> 01:35:44.805
once a year, part of the goal could be to figure out how to

1978
01:35:44.835 --> 01:35:46.805
what, what is the right cadence or sequence of,

1979
01:35:48.425 --> 01:35:49.565
and whether it's a school committee

1980
01:35:49.565 --> 01:35:52.565
or this is bigger than that, you know, in collaboration

1981
01:35:52.565 --> 01:35:55.045
with administration to say, to ask a question.

1982
01:35:55.065 --> 01:35:56.845
You know, it could be like early two or three questions.

1983
01:35:56.945 --> 01:35:59.445
You know, have you talked to, you know, are you following

1984
01:35:59.925 --> 01:36:01.125
what the school committee is up to?

1985
01:36:01.145 --> 01:36:03.405
Or you know, do you feel the school committee is

1986
01:36:03.565 --> 01:36:05.605
representing your interest well or something like that.

1987
01:36:08.195 --> 01:36:11.965
Something very simple along with some

1988
01:36:13.115 --> 01:36:17.085
demographic questions so that we can know not only

1989
01:36:18.825 --> 01:36:21.245
in general but how we're reaching people

1990
01:36:21.385 --> 01:36:23.165
and are people feeling heard,

1991
01:36:23.665 --> 01:36:25.005
but also how do we break that down

1992
01:36:25.005 --> 01:36:27.325
to identify who's not being heard.

1993
01:36:27.415 --> 01:36:28.415
Right.

1994
01:36:29.445 --> 01:36:31.065
<v Speaker 1>Dr. Welch. And then back to Ms. Collins.</v>

1995
01:36:31.645 --> 01:36:33.985
<v Speaker 9>One way to maybe operationalize Dr.</v>

1996
01:36:34.095 --> 01:36:37.545
Folkman's point, which is how often do you solicit feedback

1997
01:36:39.645 --> 01:36:43.145
but not so often that people sort of, you know, get tired

1998
01:36:43.145 --> 01:36:45.265
of it and, and stop responding.

1999
01:36:46.765 --> 01:36:50.185
It could be some sort of a major decisions flash survey.

2000
01:36:50.365 --> 01:36:51.745
So people could get accustomed

2001
01:36:51.765 --> 01:36:54.865
to hearing from us every October when we're about

2002
01:36:54.865 --> 01:36:56.865
to vote on the calendar in November.

2003
01:36:57.525 --> 01:37:00.145
And they know that on an annual basis they'll get that one.

2004
01:37:01.485 --> 01:37:05.505
We may not have a major building vote every year,

2005
01:37:05.925 --> 01:37:08.345
but, you know, close by,

2006
01:37:08.635 --> 01:37:10.585
we'll have in close proximity to one another.

2007
01:37:10.635 --> 01:37:12.945
We'll have a vote by this committee on the field.

2008
01:37:13.675 --> 01:37:15.705
We'll also have a vote on the memorial plan.

2009
01:37:15.715 --> 01:37:17.345
We're trying to get feedback on both of those.

2010
01:37:18.295 --> 01:37:19.705
That could be something that happens here.

2011
01:37:19.705 --> 01:37:20.825
That may not happen every year,

2012
01:37:20.845 --> 01:37:21.905
but that would be a second one.

2013
01:37:21.905 --> 01:37:25.505
And then a third would be something around

2014
01:37:26.025 --> 01:37:27.985
specific requests and needs in the schools.

2015
01:37:28.185 --> 01:37:30.185
I know that Mr. Gillis has talked about the shift

2016
01:37:30.185 --> 01:37:33.785
of the capital requests happening in the spring, so

2017
01:37:33.785 --> 01:37:35.865
that could maybe be a, a third occasion.

2018
01:37:36.005 --> 01:37:38.225
So if there was a defined set of occasions

2019
01:37:38.225 --> 01:37:41.865
that were on some sort of annual rotation

2020
01:37:42.085 --> 01:37:45.585
or some kind of annual routine that might address Dr.

2021
01:37:45.585 --> 01:37:48.385
Folkman's concern that it is regular and predictable

2022
01:37:48.845 --> 01:37:50.985
but not so frequent that people don't want to respond.

2023
01:37:53.095 --> 01:37:54.185
<v Speaker 1>Okay. Ms. Collins?</v>

2024
01:37:54.735 --> 01:37:57.325
<v Speaker 25>Yeah, as a former researcher, I will leave it</v>

2025
01:37:57.325 --> 01:38:01.325
to the current researchers to phrase the questions

2026
01:38:01.325 --> 01:38:04.045
because we all know that that's the hardest part

2027
01:38:04.665 --> 01:38:06.045
is writing a good question.

2028
01:38:06.775 --> 01:38:09.125
Quite honestly, I do participate in flash vote

2029
01:38:09.225 --> 01:38:13.205
and the questions there are awful, they are just not

2030
01:38:13.805 --> 01:38:17.645
well-written questions to gather anything of value,

2031
01:38:18.305 --> 01:38:20.365
in my opinion, in my experience.

2032
01:38:21.225 --> 01:38:23.885
And so if that's something

2033
01:38:24.985 --> 01:38:28.285
you guys wanna take on in terms of writing

2034
01:38:28.915 --> 01:38:31.525
good questions on that, I can support.

2035
01:38:32.675 --> 01:38:35.165
It's just the, I I don't want the goal to,

2036
01:38:37.305 --> 01:38:39.805
to be reduced to, well we went to this many events

2037
01:38:39.865 --> 01:38:41.005
and talked to this many people

2038
01:38:41.225 --> 01:38:44.085
and no, we don't really know other than

2039
01:38:44.865 --> 01:38:48.045
our wonderful boards out here that are students participate

2040
01:38:48.045 --> 01:38:50.925
with and I just don't want it to devolve

2041
01:38:51.785 --> 01:38:52.785
<v Speaker 1>Dr.</v>

2042
01:38:52.785 --> 01:38:53.125
Stash. And then Ms. Burnell,

2043
01:38:54.205 --> 01:38:55.445
<v Speaker 12>I just wanna remind the committee,</v>

2044
01:38:55.465 --> 01:38:58.925
and it's been a while that we're, we contracted

2045
01:38:58.925 --> 01:39:02.565
with Panorama who are assisting us with creating staff,

2046
01:39:02.565 --> 01:39:05.685
student and family surveys that are reliable and valid

2047
01:39:06.025 --> 01:39:09.325
and where we are not writing the questions, we are,

2048
01:39:09.745 --> 01:39:13.125
we have a question bank of those that have been tested

2049
01:39:13.345 --> 01:39:14.925
to be free of bias, et cetera,

2050
01:39:14.945 --> 01:39:16.645
and recommended by researchers.

2051
01:39:17.075 --> 01:39:19.045
This is, these are well known surveys.

2052
01:39:19.295 --> 01:39:20.405
We're in the process right now.

2053
01:39:20.425 --> 01:39:23.605
We just backwards plans backwards planned it

2054
01:39:24.305 --> 01:39:26.765
and we plan to invite school committee members

2055
01:39:26.785 --> 01:39:30.125
to take a look at the caregiver when we meet with the PCC

2056
01:39:30.125 --> 01:39:31.365
for what we call member checking.

2057
01:39:31.695 --> 01:39:33.525
We're member checking with students at the high school

2058
01:39:33.745 --> 01:39:35.485
and we're member checking with the EAN.

2059
01:39:35.705 --> 01:39:37.485
So if the school committee would like to participate

2060
01:39:37.485 --> 01:39:40.085
and take a look there, the goal ultimately,

2061
01:39:40.085 --> 01:39:42.445
and you'll, you'll hear this at the January 25th meeting

2062
01:39:42.675 --> 01:39:43.685
from Panorama,

2063
01:39:44.525 --> 01:39:47.885
but the goal is eventually to receive data

2064
01:39:48.835 --> 01:39:51.125
that schools can turn into action

2065
01:39:51.135 --> 01:39:52.645
plans at a localized level.

2066
01:39:52.985 --> 01:39:54.765
But that's not to say there wouldn't be

2067
01:39:54.835 --> 01:39:56.325
some questions we could add in.

2068
01:39:56.405 --> 01:39:59.125
I didn't think of it yet related to the school committee.

2069
01:39:59.265 --> 01:40:01.725
So we could talk about that. So there's an option here.

2070
01:40:01.845 --> 01:40:03.405
I think we were thinking of offering

2071
01:40:03.425 --> 01:40:06.005
to have school committee members join the PCC

2072
01:40:06.465 --> 01:40:07.565
as part of caregivers.

2073
01:40:07.625 --> 01:40:11.565
But wherever you see fit, there's an opportunity to kind

2074
01:40:11.565 --> 01:40:13.525
of review the questions that we've been working on now

2075
01:40:13.545 --> 01:40:15.605
for I think three months with this company.

2076
01:40:16.895 --> 01:40:18.445
<v Speaker 1>Thank you Ms. Bru.</v>

2077
01:40:19.405 --> 01:40:22.645
<v Speaker 11>Thank you. I think that's a great idea.</v>

2078
01:40:22.925 --> 01:40:27.445
I also think that there's a, I would lean more towards the

2079
01:40:28.125 --> 01:40:30.325
communication goals that you initially talked about Dr.

2080
01:40:30.325 --> 01:40:33.005
Folkman, like the, you know, the events

2081
01:40:33.305 --> 01:40:38.065
and the Targeted research,

2082
01:40:38.065 --> 01:40:40.145
like the stuff that we did with the, with the superintendent

2083
01:40:40.965 --> 01:40:42.985
search and the strategic plan.

2084
01:40:43.225 --> 01:40:44.425
I think when we need to show up

2085
01:40:44.425 --> 01:40:46.105
with communication, I think we do it well.

2086
01:40:46.745 --> 01:40:48.905
I think when it gets nebulous, we maybe

2087
01:40:48.905 --> 01:40:51.705
that's when it feels like, you know, it feels like,

2088
01:40:51.705 --> 01:40:52.865
oh, are we really doing anything?

2089
01:40:53.885 --> 01:40:55.645
Ultimately, I think we get evaluated every year

2090
01:40:55.645 --> 01:40:58.845
with elections and so I'm not really interested in a, in a,

2091
01:40:59.225 --> 01:41:03.045
in a survey that goes out to families about on that.

2092
01:41:03.365 --> 01:41:05.285
'cause I hope people use their voice in the election.

2093
01:41:07.725 --> 01:41:11.605
I do think that, for example, the select board has

2094
01:41:12.385 --> 01:41:13.965
off regular office hours

2095
01:41:14.945 --> 01:41:18.405
and I wonder about doing that either as individuals

2096
01:41:18.465 --> 01:41:19.685
or as committee members.

2097
01:41:19.775 --> 01:41:23.005
Again, just to have it set on the calendar so people know

2098
01:41:23.005 --> 01:41:24.205
that they have that outlet.

2099
01:41:25.125 --> 01:41:26.485
I think when we're at our best,

2100
01:41:26.485 --> 01:41:31.085
we can take some heat off the administration sometimes just

2101
01:41:31.085 --> 01:41:33.085
because we, we are as close to some

2102
01:41:33.085 --> 01:41:34.205
of the decisions that you are.

2103
01:41:34.265 --> 01:41:36.525
And so we could, we can share thoughts

2104
01:41:37.025 --> 01:41:38.965
or insights about things instead

2105
01:41:38.965 --> 01:41:40.285
of taking up some of your time.

2106
01:41:40.425 --> 01:41:44.285
So if there is a communication goal,

2107
01:41:44.365 --> 01:41:47.645
I I would lean more towards the, the first items

2108
01:41:47.645 --> 01:41:48.765
that you were talking about.

2109
01:41:49.605 --> 01:41:51.965
I would also suggest that maybe you guys go back so

2110
01:41:51.965 --> 01:41:53.645
that we're not doing this in the middle of the meeting.

2111
01:41:54.315 --> 01:41:57.165
<v Speaker 1>Well, so I was just about to say</v>

2112
01:41:59.105 --> 01:42:00.885
we perhaps have reached the point

2113
01:42:00.885 --> 01:42:02.565
of diminishing returns on this particular topic

2114
01:42:03.025 --> 01:42:06.925
and that it would make sense for that to happen it

2115
01:42:06.945 --> 01:42:09.005
to bring back maybe some actionable,

2116
01:42:09.935 --> 01:42:12.125
measurable goals for the next time.

2117
01:42:12.125 --> 01:42:13.565
And that's given all the feedback.

2118
01:42:13.605 --> 01:42:15.245
I mean I think the point of this discussion is for us

2119
01:42:15.245 --> 01:42:17.125
to work it out as best, as best we can,

2120
01:42:17.185 --> 01:42:18.845
but if we are sort of at a point

2121
01:42:18.845 --> 01:42:20.605
where we have now a thousand ideas,

2122
01:42:21.345 --> 01:42:25.245
we should narrow them down 'cause we are Yeah.

2123
01:42:25.875 --> 01:42:26.965
Significant. Yeah.

2124
01:42:27.105 --> 01:42:30.805
At least down to like maybe just a hundred so we can,

2125
01:42:30.905 --> 01:42:32.605
we can move on from that one if

2126
01:42:32.605 --> 01:42:35.325
that team can perhaps come back at the next meeting

2127
01:42:35.435 --> 01:42:37.165
with just a cup.

2128
01:42:37.285 --> 01:42:39.245
A handful of things. And I don't think it has

2129
01:42:39.245 --> 01:42:40.885
to be like a specific, like we're gonna do these,

2130
01:42:40.885 --> 01:42:42.245
we're always gonna do natick days.

2131
01:42:43.185 --> 01:42:46.005
You know, we, we've done the farmer's market thing,

2132
01:42:46.145 --> 01:42:47.765
office hours is interesting, whatever.

2133
01:42:48.105 --> 01:42:50.525
You know, like generally I think it is a,

2134
01:42:51.825 --> 01:42:53.885
do we wanna do more comms?

2135
01:42:53.885 --> 01:42:56.485
Do we wanna do targeted outreach and to whom?

2136
01:42:56.875 --> 01:42:59.005
Like, and those things. Just some action.

2137
01:43:00.225 --> 01:43:01.875
Alright, great.

2138
01:43:03.905 --> 01:43:05.635
Catherine, do you, do you have

2139
01:43:05.985 --> 01:43:09.755
<v Speaker 11>Yeah, we met, so Matt, Catherine or Matt, myself</v>

2140
01:43:09.755 --> 01:43:13.075
and Elise met a couple, I think a couple

2141
01:43:13.625 --> 01:43:15.115
like maybe a month ago at this point.

2142
01:43:15.175 --> 01:43:17.155
And we discussed goal four and goal three.

2143
01:43:17.825 --> 01:43:20.035
Matt, do you wanna start with goal four?

2144
01:43:22.585 --> 01:43:24.195
<v Speaker 9>Sure. Goal four was focused on,</v>

2145
01:43:24.255 --> 01:43:25.995
or is focused on student outcomes.

2146
01:43:27.575 --> 01:43:30.795
And we attempted to phrase the goal that kept

2147
01:43:31.975 --> 01:43:33.275
the committee's attention on

2148
01:43:33.275 --> 01:43:34.635
student outcomes on a regular basis.

2149
01:43:35.535 --> 01:43:37.515
So the draft phrasing of the goal is

2150
01:43:37.515 --> 01:43:40.235
that we would have increased attention as a committee

2151
01:43:41.135 --> 01:43:44.635
to understanding and tracking student outcomes.

2152
01:43:45.935 --> 01:43:50.115
We proposed three measurable action steps.

2153
01:43:50.495 --> 01:43:54.245
One that there would be one period

2154
01:43:54.545 --> 01:43:56.725
or one event of training

2155
01:43:56.945 --> 01:43:59.245
during the year for the school committee.

2156
01:43:59.945 --> 01:44:02.685
So that by the end of the train, by the end of

2157
01:44:02.685 --> 01:44:03.805
that training, by the end of the year,

2158
01:44:05.225 --> 01:44:08.445
the committee could effectively articulate the definitions

2159
01:44:08.445 --> 01:44:11.645
of both proficiency and growth so that we can explain those

2160
01:44:12.405 --> 01:44:14.085
somewhat complex concepts

2161
01:44:14.785 --> 01:44:16.885
to our constituents if they ask us about them.

2162
01:44:18.345 --> 01:44:21.485
The second would be that there would be three portions

2163
01:44:21.585 --> 01:44:24.525
of three meetings during the year devoted

2164
01:44:24.525 --> 01:44:26.805
to reviewing student benchmark outcomes.

2165
01:44:27.255 --> 01:44:30.085
Those would be beginning, middle, and end of the year.

2166
01:44:31.345 --> 01:44:34.765
And we would put specific emphasis on the

2167
01:44:36.015 --> 01:44:39.525
evaluation or trying to understand the implementation

2168
01:44:40.305 --> 01:44:42.005
of a couple of specific in initiatives

2169
01:44:42.005 --> 01:44:43.285
that the superintendent's leading right now.

2170
01:44:43.505 --> 01:44:45.005
One is the new literacy curriculum

2171
01:44:45.665 --> 01:44:50.405
and the second is the pilot shift

2172
01:44:50.545 --> 01:44:53.045
of intervention structures at lja.

2173
01:44:54.785 --> 01:44:59.725
The third tangible outcome would be to receive an update

2174
01:45:00.505 --> 01:45:03.325
on the district's plan as it relates to

2175
01:45:05.155 --> 01:45:06.765
instruction at the high school

2176
01:45:06.865 --> 01:45:08.325
and the adoption of high

2177
01:45:08.325 --> 01:45:09.925
quality materials at the high school.

2178
01:45:10.125 --> 01:45:12.565
I know that when the elementary

2179
01:45:12.705 --> 01:45:16.925
and high school curricula were adopted in literacy,

2180
01:45:17.705 --> 01:45:21.405
we had some conversations about precisely how to apply the

2181
01:45:22.255 --> 01:45:24.925
definition of HQIM to high school,

2182
01:45:24.935 --> 01:45:26.405
which is a very tricky thing

2183
01:45:27.395 --> 01:45:29.765
when you're talking about the difficulty of trying

2184
01:45:29.765 --> 01:45:32.085
to purchase a, a curriculum

2185
01:45:32.905 --> 01:45:35.045
at the high school level really in any subject,

2186
01:45:35.825 --> 01:45:38.445
but particularly in something like English.

2187
01:45:38.505 --> 01:45:39.965
And I know that they're doing some work on

2188
01:45:39.965 --> 01:45:41.525
instructional practices there.

2189
01:45:41.985 --> 01:45:44.645
So the, this third component would just be

2190
01:45:44.645 --> 01:45:47.765
to receive an update on the current understanding of that.

2191
01:45:48.255 --> 01:45:50.965
Again, just to continue to, to take some of our meeting time

2192
01:45:51.305 --> 01:45:53.365
to continue to devote that to student outcomes

2193
01:45:53.665 --> 01:45:56.525
and to continue to, to maintain some focus on students.

2194
01:45:56.745 --> 01:45:59.245
So those would be the three actionable

2195
01:46:00.025 --> 01:46:01.725
or measurable components

2196
01:46:01.755 --> 01:46:03.165
that we would propose for that goal.

2197
01:46:03.905 --> 01:46:05.365
<v Speaker 1>So let's start with that one.</v>

2198
01:46:06.565 --> 01:46:10.205
I would love to hear from Dr.

2199
01:46:10.475 --> 01:46:15.325
Bash on how you feel about that kind of commitment. I mean

2200
01:46:16.065 --> 01:46:18.605
<v Speaker 12>I'm kind of reading this as asks of us, right?</v>

2201
01:46:18.745 --> 01:46:22.485
So I, I mean I think it's, yes you wanna receive the reports

2202
01:46:22.585 --> 01:46:25.445
and I can think of there's very nice timing here

2203
01:46:25.515 --> 01:46:26.965
with the strategic plan.

2204
01:46:27.545 --> 01:46:29.125
So just going through them, the training

2205
01:46:30.525 --> 01:46:31.845
I think we could readily have

2206
01:46:32.105 --> 01:46:33.605
and she'd be well prepared to do it.

2207
01:46:33.605 --> 01:46:34.805
Sandy Lemon to do that training.

2208
01:46:34.935 --> 01:46:39.085
We've also sort of commissioned ESA to work on literacy.

2209
01:46:39.085 --> 01:46:41.325
So we gotta decide kind of the shared piece there.

2210
01:46:42.805 --> 01:46:46.085
Internal B-O-Y-M-O-I, I kind of look at it as the BOY

2211
01:46:46.195 --> 01:46:50.805
with the reports we do on MCAS or access MOII always.

2212
01:46:50.985 --> 01:46:55.485
We do a renaissance one and EOY. We do my final memo.

2213
01:46:55.825 --> 01:46:57.525
So I think, but I understand

2214
01:46:57.665 --> 01:46:59.845
and appreciate the elevation

2215
01:47:00.065 --> 01:47:01.285
of wanting the school committee.

2216
01:47:01.385 --> 01:47:05.045
You kind of said take time to do that with regard to lilja.

2217
01:47:05.285 --> 01:47:08.005
I agree. I think you're gonna see that as part

2218
01:47:08.005 --> 01:47:09.085
of our budget presentation

2219
01:47:09.085 --> 01:47:12.125
because if we're going to wanna roll out phase two, we feel

2220
01:47:12.125 --> 01:47:14.365
that we need to prepare and the elementary principals are

2221
01:47:14.365 --> 01:47:16.285
already pulling together along with Jackie

2222
01:47:16.345 --> 01:47:18.165
and Matt, the financial side of it,

2223
01:47:18.165 --> 01:47:19.965
but also the outcome side of it, which is,

2224
01:47:19.965 --> 01:47:22.205
and we even pulled in the window for lilja testing

2225
01:47:22.345 --> 01:47:23.605
to make sure we could get that to you

2226
01:47:24.025 --> 01:47:25.605
by the January 25th meeting.

2227
01:47:25.705 --> 01:47:26.765
So you can start to see

2228
01:47:26.785 --> 01:47:28.245
how much it takes very

2229
01:47:28.565 --> 01:47:29.965
advanced planning to even get this stuff.

2230
01:47:30.985 --> 01:47:32.005
The high school measures.

2231
01:47:32.085 --> 01:47:35.565
I just had written Great Minds Friday

2232
01:47:36.825 --> 01:47:38.485
to get an update on the progress there

2233
01:47:38.485 --> 01:47:39.645
and we plan to have an outcome.

2234
01:47:39.755 --> 01:47:41.765
Same discussion we had kind of for the elementary middle,

2235
01:47:41.765 --> 01:47:43.685
which you were referenced by end of year.

2236
01:47:43.825 --> 01:47:45.245
So we're well on track

2237
01:47:45.465 --> 01:47:46.965
to getting all of this in front of you.

2238
01:47:47.725 --> 01:47:50.685
I do the piece I'm thinking about, like

2239
01:47:50.705 --> 01:47:53.565
that's value added feedback I hope to this goal

2240
01:47:54.465 --> 01:47:56.685
is the concurrent one of my goals has to do

2241
01:47:56.685 --> 01:47:58.365
with setting up a progress monitoring

2242
01:47:58.365 --> 01:47:59.525
system for the strategic plan.

2243
01:47:59.905 --> 01:48:04.445
And so the first two priorities are closing achievement gaps

2244
01:48:04.665 --> 01:48:05.765
and growth for all students.

2245
01:48:06.425 --> 01:48:11.125
And so I'm wondering if this goal

2246
01:48:11.185 --> 01:48:14.325
for the committee might be some kind of

2247
01:48:15.635 --> 01:48:18.525
partnership in helping us to make sure we land that well

2248
01:48:18.955 --> 01:48:20.565
because it is complicated.

2249
01:48:20.725 --> 01:48:22.685
I I, I dislike the word complicated,

2250
01:48:23.225 --> 01:48:26.485
but it's, we need to show this in a non jargony way.

2251
01:48:26.905 --> 01:48:29.645
That's the natural cadence of when data comes in

2252
01:48:30.035 --> 01:48:31.405
that can be digested.

2253
01:48:31.625 --> 01:48:35.805
So we actually can say how we're growing,

2254
01:48:36.695 --> 01:48:38.005
which is a very brave thing to do.

2255
01:48:38.005 --> 01:48:40.085
I don't know a district that does it. Lemme just say that.

2256
01:48:41.155 --> 01:48:43.605
I'll also say we can't do straight line depreciation.

2257
01:48:43.825 --> 01:48:45.045
You can't be like, we're gonna get here

2258
01:48:45.045 --> 01:48:46.485
and every year we take an even step

2259
01:48:46.675 --> 01:48:47.765
that doesn't work that way.

2260
01:48:48.115 --> 01:48:49.805
Process comes before outcomes.

2261
01:48:50.425 --> 01:48:53.245
So we, I am thrilled by the desire

2262
01:48:53.305 --> 01:48:54.965
for the committee to focus on outcomes.

2263
01:48:55.035 --> 01:48:58.845
It's, it's a story of so much process

2264
01:48:59.025 --> 01:49:02.205
and people work that we need to all be aware of.

2265
01:49:02.215 --> 01:49:04.245
We're gonna need your help as we move forward.

2266
01:49:05.075 --> 01:49:08.805
It's deeply in our strategic plan in indicators 1.1

2267
01:49:08.825 --> 01:49:11.045
and 1.2 we're 4.3.

2268
01:49:11.325 --> 01:49:13.285
I have it very well memorized is all

2269
01:49:13.285 --> 01:49:16.565
around developing the progress monitoring tool for it.

2270
01:49:17.105 --> 01:49:19.445
I'm not calling it a like a bench.

2271
01:49:19.675 --> 01:49:21.125
What, what was the dashboard?

2272
01:49:21.585 --> 01:49:24.245
We switch that language because it's so static.

2273
01:49:24.825 --> 01:49:27.165
It progress monitoring assumes sort

2274
01:49:27.165 --> 01:49:28.725
of this asset based movement ahead.

2275
01:49:29.585 --> 01:49:31.085
So that's what we're naming it

2276
01:49:31.105 --> 01:49:32.445
and we've been working really hard on it

2277
01:49:32.445 --> 01:49:33.485
and we're not finding it easy.

2278
01:49:34.405 --> 01:49:36.245
And so I'm wondering if the committee

2279
01:49:36.855 --> 01:49:39.765
might be good thought partners for us on that as we sort

2280
01:49:39.765 --> 01:49:41.445
of work to land it over the course of this year.

2281
01:49:41.985 --> 01:49:43.805
So I said a lot, but that's my,

2282
01:49:44.265 --> 01:49:45.685
I'm sure you took that all in.

2283
01:49:45.705 --> 01:49:48.885
So that's kind, I think we're well suited

2284
01:49:48.885 --> 01:49:51.085
and ready to deliver on everything you have here.

2285
01:49:52.075 --> 01:49:54.565
It's more the extra piece, which is helping us

2286
01:49:54.585 --> 01:49:56.925
to land 4.3 in the progress monitoring tool,

2287
01:49:56.935 --> 01:49:58.405
which will not be in one phase.

2288
01:49:58.705 --> 01:49:59.965
You can imagine some of our stuff

2289
01:49:59.965 --> 01:50:01.045
we don't even have data on yet.

2290
01:50:01.045 --> 01:50:02.685
Yeah. So it's gonna be in a few phases.

2291
01:50:02.745 --> 01:50:04.085
I'd love partnership on that as well.

2292
01:50:04.985 --> 01:50:09.605
<v Speaker 1>So I have a question. Can you help me understand,</v>

2293
01:50:10.385 --> 01:50:14.725
and I appreciate the work very much it,

2294
01:50:14.935 --> 01:50:18.045
these feel a little bit like their goals not ours.

2295
01:50:18.235 --> 01:50:21.565
Yeah. Where my goal is to listen. Yeah.

2296
01:50:21.825 --> 01:50:24.285
Not the internal training. I actually really like that,

2297
01:50:24.285 --> 01:50:25.525
that one makes sense to me.

2298
01:50:25.585 --> 01:50:28.165
The other ones how do to doctor's fashion's point, like

2299
01:50:28.165 --> 01:50:29.725
how do we massage it a little?

2300
01:50:29.745 --> 01:50:31.005
So it's like the work we are doing,

2301
01:50:31.835 --> 01:50:33.125
<v Speaker 9>It's a, it's a fair question.</v>

2302
01:50:33.445 --> 01:50:35.845
I think I, I'll represent

2303
01:50:35.845 --> 01:50:37.365
and then I'm happy to yield to Catherine

2304
01:50:37.365 --> 01:50:38.525
if she wants to, to Ms.

2305
01:50:38.525 --> 01:50:40.565
Bruell if she wants to elaborate on this.

2306
01:50:40.585 --> 01:50:43.885
But I think the kind of ad hoc subcommittee

2307
01:50:43.885 --> 01:50:47.245
that was discussing this goal was trying to, one,

2308
01:50:48.635 --> 01:50:51.965
make sure that we devoted a, a, a significant portion

2309
01:50:51.965 --> 01:50:56.365
of our time to talking about student outcomes, particularly

2310
01:50:56.365 --> 01:50:57.765
as they relate to the strategic plan.

2311
01:50:57.765 --> 01:51:00.725
And two, to try to marshal existing resources.

2312
01:51:01.275 --> 01:51:04.565
Because what we were trying not to do is build a new set

2313
01:51:04.565 --> 01:51:06.885
of tasks on top of an existing set of tasks.

2314
01:51:07.625 --> 01:51:08.765
And so I,

2315
01:51:08.965 --> 01:51:12.445
I certainly can understand from both the chair and Dr.

2316
01:51:12.495 --> 01:51:15.085
Stash why this would feel like in some ways a set

2317
01:51:15.085 --> 01:51:17.605
of asks from the committee to the professional staff,

2318
01:51:18.585 --> 01:51:22.605
our intention was not to create new work and new tasks,

2319
01:51:23.065 --> 01:51:25.005
but to use things that already existed.

2320
01:51:25.545 --> 01:51:29.285
So when we put in the notes beginning, middle, end of year

2321
01:51:29.835 --> 01:51:32.285
benchmark outcomes, the thought was well,

2322
01:51:32.285 --> 01:51:34.005
we're already administering those assessments

2323
01:51:34.265 --> 01:51:36.885
and we might already be looking at those anyway.

2324
01:51:37.425 --> 01:51:39.885
Or you just alluded Dr.

2325
01:51:39.955 --> 01:51:42.765
Bash to the the dashboard

2326
01:51:42.825 --> 01:51:45.165
or the, the other measures that we might create

2327
01:51:45.345 --> 01:51:48.205
to assess aspects of the strategic plan.

2328
01:51:48.575 --> 01:51:49.965
Right? I think that would be in

2329
01:51:49.965 --> 01:51:51.165
line with what we talked about.

2330
01:51:51.165 --> 01:51:52.765
Because again, what we were looking at is

2331
01:51:52.995 --> 01:51:55.445
what are existing structures that we could use

2332
01:51:56.105 --> 01:51:59.365
to focus our attention on, on student outcomes

2333
01:52:00.465 --> 01:52:03.085
and more broadly to focus our attention on the strategic

2334
01:52:03.085 --> 01:52:05.165
plan and the way we allocate time and meetings.

2335
01:52:08.045 --> 01:52:09.285
<v Speaker 11>I think that's really well said.</v>

2336
01:52:09.485 --> 01:52:12.125
I also, my understanding is that the most,

2337
01:52:14.425 --> 01:52:16.965
the districts that make the most growth are the districts

2338
01:52:16.965 --> 01:52:17.765
that have the highest

2339
01:52:21.505 --> 01:52:22.505
literacy around data.

2340
01:52:23.525 --> 01:52:25.985
Not just numbers but also the stories behind the data.

2341
01:52:26.645 --> 01:52:30.185
And so if we are making the decisions, not only do we have

2342
01:52:30.185 --> 01:52:31.225
to be able to know it,

2343
01:52:31.225 --> 01:52:33.465
so which is why the first school is just

2344
01:52:33.465 --> 01:52:36.225
to improve our literacy, it's also to be able

2345
01:52:36.225 --> 01:52:37.865
to talk about it with fluency.

2346
01:52:38.885 --> 01:52:43.025
And so that's especially to like during the budget season

2347
01:52:43.165 --> 01:52:45.360
to our stakeholders to town meeting members.

2348
01:52:46.065 --> 01:52:48.165
The more that we have data in front of us,

2349
01:52:49.585 --> 01:52:51.965
the more time we spend in meetings on student data,

2350
01:52:52.065 --> 01:52:53.805
the better I think the whole district will be.

2351
01:52:53.805 --> 01:52:55.205
And so that to Dr.

2352
01:52:55.275 --> 01:52:57.605
Welch's point, this is just to highlight the work

2353
01:52:57.605 --> 01:52:58.765
that you're already doing, but then

2354
01:52:58.765 --> 01:53:00.005
to make sure that it ends up here.

2355
01:53:00.005 --> 01:53:02.925
Because frankly like tonight, the entire meeting,

2356
01:53:03.585 --> 01:53:05.685
we won't talk about student data at all for,

2357
01:53:05.985 --> 01:53:09.325
and we didn't talk about it last week, so, or two weeks ago.

2358
01:53:09.325 --> 01:53:12.605
Right? So you can go surprisingly with,

2359
01:53:12.915 --> 01:53:16.525
with school committee meetings, you can go with long agendas

2360
01:53:16.625 --> 01:53:19.005
and actually never talk about student data.

2361
01:53:20.025 --> 01:53:22.765
So that's that that was the thought. Here

2362
01:53:24.205 --> 01:53:25.205
<v Speaker 12>I add Yeah, go ahead.</v>

2363
01:53:25.515 --> 01:53:26.845
Yeah, very true.

2364
01:53:27.065 --> 01:53:29.005
We don't have data to give you right now, but Very true.

2365
01:53:29.225 --> 01:53:30.845
And I, I know I'm not asking exactly

2366
01:53:30.845 --> 01:53:31.845
<v Speaker 11>What you</v>
<v Speaker 12>Mean I'm asking.</v>

2367
01:53:31.845 --> 01:53:32.845
Okay. No, no, I think it's good

2368
01:53:32.845 --> 01:53:35.085
to just discuss it like data happens at

2369
01:53:35.085 --> 01:53:36.805
certain segments of the year.

2370
01:53:37.105 --> 01:53:41.005
So this is like, we actually need the committee's help

2371
01:53:41.005 --> 01:53:43.405
and it does insert into agendas

2372
01:53:43.995 --> 01:53:47.525
because once we build out this 4.3,

2373
01:53:47.525 --> 01:53:50.645
which is the progress monitoring tool, we're imagining

2374
01:53:51.035 --> 01:53:53.765
that once we actually have the data land on things

2375
01:53:53.955 --> 01:53:55.445
that we would want to bring it in

2376
01:53:55.705 --> 01:53:58.925
and be clear to say we're now gonna report out to you for,

2377
01:53:59.325 --> 01:54:01.125
'cause we do this annually on 1.1

2378
01:54:01.425 --> 01:54:04.445
and we would imagine that would be in October once we have

2379
01:54:04.445 --> 01:54:07.725
all the closeout data from MCAS, same thing with 1.2,

2380
01:54:08.065 --> 01:54:10.085
but 1.3, which is about AI

2381
01:54:10.085 --> 01:54:12.405
and tech, we likely wouldn't do until the end of the year

2382
01:54:12.405 --> 01:54:14.005
because we'd want this survey data.

2383
01:54:14.065 --> 01:54:16.525
And so this is what we're actually trying to figure out

2384
01:54:17.265 --> 01:54:20.645
is take this huge plan that we made, figure out what data's

2385
01:54:20.645 --> 01:54:22.045
behind it, what data needs to be built,

2386
01:54:22.345 --> 01:54:24.485
and when it inserts itself into a

2387
01:54:24.485 --> 01:54:25.805
report to the school committee.

2388
01:54:26.205 --> 01:54:29.765
'cause it's fairly heavy in October and June.

2389
01:54:30.265 --> 01:54:31.885
So we have to kind of figure that out.

2390
01:54:32.305 --> 01:54:34.245
And I think we need some thought partnership on that,

2391
01:54:34.245 --> 01:54:36.685
which would be, would be helpful to us.

2392
01:54:38.565 --> 01:54:40.445
I think it's a little bit, probably

2393
01:54:40.445 --> 01:54:42.365
after January that we'd be able to kind

2394
01:54:42.365 --> 01:54:44.125
of be more coherent on that

2395
01:54:44.125 --> 01:54:45.765
because we're really working hard right now

2396
01:54:45.765 --> 01:54:46.805
on getting the surveys done.

2397
01:54:47.185 --> 01:54:49.125
But that could even be another part of this goal is

2398
01:54:49.125 --> 01:54:50.845
to come be a member check on the surveys.

2399
01:54:51.665 --> 01:54:54.325
So I don't wanna, certainly don't wanna usurp the goal,

2400
01:54:54.325 --> 01:54:56.045
but I'm trying to say the, the layer

2401
01:54:56.075 --> 01:54:58.365
that I think would help get it into the meetings

2402
01:54:58.385 --> 01:54:59.485
as you're talking about.

2403
01:55:00.105 --> 01:55:01.485
But we're gonna have to have a little patience

2404
01:55:01.645 --> 01:55:03.445
'cause it's gonna take a couple years to figure this out.

2405
01:55:05.025 --> 01:55:07.525
<v Speaker 1>So we're gonna now have a discussion about the 2030 goals.</v>

2406
01:55:08.825 --> 01:55:09.825
Ms. Collins.

2407
01:55:10.515 --> 01:55:14.485
<v Speaker 25>Yeah, I also really like the, the, the training piece.</v>

2408
01:55:14.605 --> 01:55:16.725
I, I think as a committee we don't do

2409
01:55:16.725 --> 01:55:18.165
enough training of ourselves.

2410
01:55:19.985 --> 01:55:24.965
So I I really like that the benchmark measures.

2411
01:55:25.965 --> 01:55:29.485
I don't remember a year either when I was on finance

2412
01:55:29.485 --> 01:55:31.765
committee or since I've been on this committee where

2413
01:55:32.005 --> 01:55:36.045
that data wasn't brought forth to the school committee.

2414
01:55:37.905 --> 01:55:39.445
It happens when it happens. So yes,

2415
01:55:39.445 --> 01:55:42.365
we go periods without anything specific.

2416
01:55:42.565 --> 01:55:46.685
I get that and I sometimes, I guess if you think about it,

2417
01:55:46.685 --> 01:55:48.685
you think, well that should be our whole purpose,

2418
01:55:48.905 --> 01:55:50.685
but there's a natural ebb

2419
01:55:50.685 --> 01:55:54.125
and flow of when information becomes available.

2420
01:55:57.745 --> 01:55:59.665
I would also like to revisit the conversation on

2421
01:56:00.585 --> 01:56:05.105
HQIM at high school because we did sort of leave that up.

2422
01:56:05.125 --> 01:56:09.065
But I think that if we do the, the training piece

2423
01:56:09.765 --> 01:56:13.625
and provide assistance to

2424
01:56:15.685 --> 01:56:18.625
the superintendent and her team of getting

2425
01:56:20.725 --> 01:56:24.825
the right things, the right, presented the right way, where

2426
01:56:25.465 --> 01:56:27.025
I think those are the two things that

2427
01:56:27.515 --> 01:56:29.025
where we are value added.

2428
01:56:29.985 --> 01:56:31.705
I don't think saying, well, you need to present

2429
01:56:31.855 --> 01:56:34.785
what you've already presented every year, as I said,

2430
01:56:34.785 --> 01:56:39.585
since 2005 at least I,

2431
01:56:39.745 --> 01:56:41.345
I don't worry that that's not gonna happen.

2432
01:56:43.655 --> 01:56:45.515
So that's my 2 cents on that.

2433
01:56:47.755 --> 01:56:50.885
<v Speaker 1>Okay. Any other thoughts?</v>

2434
01:56:52.435 --> 01:56:56.605
Okay, I, so we'll do one more goal,

2435
01:56:58.985 --> 01:57:03.045
but before we do, maybe the goal

2436
01:57:03.825 --> 01:57:06.685
of the goals should be that each of the groups

2437
01:57:07.785 --> 01:57:10.405
who has worked on a goal comes back together next time

2438
01:57:10.435 --> 01:57:11.525
with a summary.

2439
01:57:12.115 --> 01:57:13.165
This is what our goal is.

2440
01:57:13.545 --> 01:57:15.645
Taking all the feedback, if that makes sense.

2441
01:57:16.345 --> 01:57:17.725
If it doesn't speak

2442
01:57:17.745 --> 01:57:19.325
<v Speaker 11>Now, I, I mean we just have</v>

2443
01:57:19.325 --> 01:57:21.325
to schedule open meetings to do that.

2444
01:57:21.425 --> 01:57:24.285
And so I would rather I've like, I'm happy

2445
01:57:24.305 --> 01:57:27.405
to revise this goal or like, or to the consensus.

2446
01:57:27.405 --> 01:57:30.565
What I'm hearing is that goal four people are happy

2447
01:57:30.565 --> 01:57:31.605
with the internal training.

2448
01:57:32.255 --> 01:57:35.165
Great, let's do it. They, the updates already happen.

2449
01:57:35.425 --> 01:57:36.885
If you guys wanna take that one out

2450
01:57:37.025 --> 01:57:41.605
and the high school HQ IM materials, like, I, I don't,

2451
01:57:41.605 --> 01:57:43.565
I don't, I personally don't feel like this goal

2452
01:57:43.565 --> 01:57:44.685
needs to have another meeting.

2453
01:57:45.545 --> 01:57:47.485
I'm having too many meetings right now in my life.

2454
01:57:47.865 --> 01:57:49.525
<v Speaker 1>If you, if you think that that it's ready,</v>

2455
01:57:50.205 --> 01:57:52.445
I just think like for us to actually put it into a,

2456
01:57:52.925 --> 01:57:54.445
a single document, I just,

2457
01:57:54.845 --> 01:57:56.685
I think it one individual can just send them to me.

2458
01:57:57.025 --> 01:57:58.325
It doesn't have to be a meeting. Right.

2459
01:57:58.325 --> 01:58:00.565
Like you could, because I, I wanna ultimately have one

2460
01:58:00.565 --> 01:58:03.405
artifact that has the goals with the action steps

2461
01:58:03.715 --> 01:58:04.925
that we're looking to achieve.

2462
01:58:05.305 --> 01:58:09.205
And so one representative from each

2463
01:58:09.205 --> 01:58:11.045
of the groups can just wants to take it on and do it.

2464
01:58:11.045 --> 01:58:12.485
That's a, it doesn't have to be a meeting.

2465
01:58:13.725 --> 01:58:15.445
I just think it would be nice for us to sort

2466
01:58:15.445 --> 01:58:16.765
of put a bow on it

2467
01:58:17.385 --> 01:58:19.525
and we might not be able to do that tonight.

2468
01:58:21.625 --> 01:58:22.885
All right. One more goal.

2469
01:58:23.785 --> 01:58:25.125
And that was the resources

2470
01:58:25.125 --> 01:58:26.485
and infrastructure. That's you again. Yes.

2471
01:58:26.845 --> 01:58:29.485
<v Speaker 11>Resources and infrastructure. So we were thinking</v>

2472
01:58:29.485 --> 01:58:32.725
that this would be, you know, it's very much like

2473
01:58:32.725 --> 01:58:34.725
what the budget subcommittee is working on

2474
01:58:35.385 --> 01:58:36.405
in general right now.

2475
01:58:36.465 --> 01:58:40.285
But just to, just to make it a little bit more specific,

2476
01:58:41.585 --> 01:58:42.845
to increase our understanding,

2477
01:58:42.985 --> 01:58:44.125
the full committee's understanding

2478
01:58:44.125 --> 01:58:45.485
of a long-term capital plan

2479
01:58:45.485 --> 01:58:48.045
and how it's going to support student learning and outcomes.

2480
01:58:50.065 --> 01:58:54.605
So the first action step is

2481
01:58:54.605 --> 01:58:58.125
to review the current capital plan with the outcome

2482
01:58:58.125 --> 01:59:00.405
of understanding the current items on the plan,

2483
01:59:00.585 --> 01:59:02.285
how they've been graded, what they've,

2484
01:59:02.285 --> 01:59:03.485
what they've been graded and,

2485
01:59:03.505 --> 01:59:05.965
and you know, like the priority level and why.

2486
01:59:07.145 --> 01:59:09.845
And then to review items on the capital plan in the context

2487
01:59:09.905 --> 01:59:12.565
of current policies to identify if there are any gaps

2488
01:59:14.275 --> 01:59:19.215
that in terms of, I don't know, sorry, from the oh,

2489
01:59:19.635 --> 01:59:22.055
to Val, to see if anything on the capital plan needs

2490
01:59:22.055 --> 01:59:24.015
to adjust based on the strategic plan

2491
01:59:27.115 --> 01:59:29.615
and that we should perhaps consider a policy

2492
01:59:30.365 --> 01:59:32.735
that would influence it.

2493
01:59:33.595 --> 01:59:34.935
The capital plan in general.

2494
01:59:37.355 --> 01:59:41.815
For example, how are the decisions made?

2495
01:59:43.355 --> 01:59:46.695
Are we thinking about when we think about the capital plan?

2496
01:59:46.715 --> 01:59:48.895
Are we thinking about first about health and safety?

2497
01:59:49.035 --> 01:59:50.295
Are we thinking about energy?

2498
01:59:51.395 --> 01:59:52.695
Indoor air quality is something

2499
01:59:52.695 --> 01:59:53.695
that's come up in the meetings,

2500
01:59:53.755 --> 01:59:58.015
but just is like, is would it be helpful for us to have sort

2501
01:59:58.015 --> 01:59:59.415
of a, a,

2502
02:00:01.665 --> 02:00:03.425
a transparent document to share

2503
02:00:03.425 --> 02:00:05.545
with the public about why we move certain things

2504
02:00:05.545 --> 02:00:06.905
forward on the capital plan?

2505
02:00:07.285 --> 02:00:09.785
Is it use, is it health, is it safety, is it energy?

2506
02:00:09.955 --> 02:00:14.305
Those kinds of things. And

2507
02:00:16.535 --> 02:00:19.305
yeah, I think I've lost everyone at this point.

2508
02:00:19.305 --> 02:00:21.305
No, no, I think so I think I, we should just move on.

2509
02:00:21.665 --> 02:00:22.905
<v Speaker 1>I think that that's a, a, a good one.</v>

2510
02:00:22.945 --> 02:00:25.145
I wonder if the artifact at the end

2511
02:00:25.145 --> 02:00:27.825
of the year is like a one sheet, like a cheat sheet

2512
02:00:27.885 --> 02:00:29.065
of capital plan.

2513
02:00:29.085 --> 02:00:31.145
Is it for us, do you mean? Or for the whole community?

2514
02:00:32.085 --> 02:00:33.425
<v Speaker 11>No, it's for our whole committee.</v>

2515
02:00:33.625 --> 02:00:35.065
I mean, we do, there's a great,

2516
02:00:35.255 --> 02:00:37.345
Matt works on a great capital plan.

2517
02:00:37.745 --> 02:00:40.985
I just think that at some point it kind

2518
02:00:40.985 --> 02:00:43.345
of dawned on me this week actually thinking about this field

2519
02:00:43.925 --> 02:00:46.265
at some point, I think the school committee stopped

2520
02:00:46.705 --> 02:00:49.465
considering that this, the capital plan was our part

2521
02:00:49.465 --> 02:00:50.505
of our budgeting process

2522
02:00:51.175 --> 02:00:54.065
because it was just something that was managed internally.

2523
02:00:54.405 --> 02:00:56.905
And then it's also the way that we fund it.

2524
02:00:57.065 --> 02:00:58.985
I mean, Kathy, you know much more about the funding

2525
02:00:58.985 --> 02:01:00.225
of the capital plan than I do,

2526
02:01:00.245 --> 02:01:03.265
but like the way we always fund it with free cash,

2527
02:01:03.645 --> 02:01:07.265
so it's like, or you know, or debt borrowing.

2528
02:01:07.285 --> 02:01:11.185
And so it's like, it always seems as if it's an afterthought

2529
02:01:11.205 --> 02:01:13.025
and because it's become an afterthought,

2530
02:01:13.145 --> 02:01:14.865
I think our school committee has not been

2531
02:01:14.865 --> 02:01:16.465
as active in the capital plan,

2532
02:01:16.875 --> 02:01:19.225
which is why we have issues in our playgrounds.

2533
02:01:19.375 --> 02:01:21.545
It's why we have not issues,

2534
02:01:21.605 --> 02:01:23.785
but it's why we have, you know, a desire

2535
02:01:23.885 --> 02:01:25.065
to upgrade our playgrounds.

2536
02:01:25.135 --> 02:01:27.345
It's why our fields have gone neglected, right?

2537
02:01:27.345 --> 02:01:28.825
Like there's certain things

2538
02:01:29.105 --> 02:01:31.785
that I think if the school committee could use our advocacy

2539
02:01:31.885 --> 02:01:34.185
and really start to really pay attention

2540
02:01:34.245 --> 02:01:39.105
to the capital plan, we could bring a little bit more muster

2541
02:01:39.225 --> 02:01:43.005
to the capital plan for the benefit of all of our students.

2542
02:01:43.905 --> 02:01:46.965
<v Speaker 1>That's a, I think that's a good summary. Ms. Collins.</v>

2543
02:01:47.135 --> 02:01:48.885
<v Speaker 25>Could, could I just ask you about</v>

2544
02:01:49.785 --> 02:01:50.845
to make sure I understand.

2545
02:01:51.645 --> 02:01:53.405
I think what you're saying is how do we

2546
02:01:53.405 --> 02:01:57.085
as a committee define our priorities for capital?

2547
02:01:57.225 --> 02:01:59.005
Is that a fair restatement? Yeah.

2548
02:01:59.035 --> 02:02:00.445
<v Speaker 11>Okay. And I think that like,</v>

2549
02:02:00.445 --> 02:02:03.965
because the budget subcommittee is new or newer, right?

2550
02:02:04.025 --> 02:02:06.685
It, we don't have this like just like tried

2551
02:02:06.685 --> 02:02:08.605
and true method that every October the,

2552
02:02:08.665 --> 02:02:10.925
the budget subcommittee makes a recommendation about

2553
02:02:10.925 --> 02:02:12.005
the capital plan, right?

2554
02:02:12.005 --> 02:02:15.725
Or we warrant articles sometimes surprise us, right?

2555
02:02:15.785 --> 02:02:18.125
So how do we get into a place as a committee

2556
02:02:18.155 --> 02:02:21.525
that we're fully functioning on the capital plan so

2557
02:02:21.525 --> 02:02:22.885
that there's not these gaps.

2558
02:02:23.715 --> 02:02:25.565
<v Speaker 25>Okay. To then to follow onto that.</v>

2559
02:02:25.845 --> 02:02:30.605
I think moving it to our principles in the spring will help.

2560
02:02:31.425 --> 02:02:34.885
But I think that, yes, I think this is an area that

2561
02:02:35.665 --> 02:02:37.165
by the time we fought for budget.

2562
02:02:37.845 --> 02:02:39.245
A lot of times we're tired of fighting

2563
02:02:39.665 --> 02:02:41.365
and we don't do it for capital Bingo.

2564
02:02:41.945 --> 02:02:43.965
And, and so I think that we do need to keep,

2565
02:02:43.965 --> 02:02:46.325
because this whole, it's the whole package

2566
02:02:47.035 --> 02:02:50.765
that funds our school and, and, you know, serves our kids.

2567
02:02:50.865 --> 02:02:54.645
And so yeah, as long as I,

2568
02:02:54.765 --> 02:02:55.845
I just wanna make sure I understood it.

2569
02:02:55.945 --> 02:02:58.045
If I understood it that I'm okay with it

2570
02:02:58.665 --> 02:02:59.665
<v Speaker 1>Now we have a goal.</v>

2571
02:02:59.745 --> 02:03:01.645
That's a good goal. Thank you.

2572
02:03:02.985 --> 02:03:05.445
All right, so we're gonna, do you, you have,

2573
02:03:06.185 --> 02:03:08.165
<v Speaker 18>Are we going to the MSBA item?</v>

2574
02:03:08.655 --> 02:03:10.285
Sorry, I, I didn't mean to cut you off.

2575
02:03:10.435 --> 02:03:15.285
Yeah, I have to leave soon. 'cause of family situation.

2576
02:03:15.525 --> 02:03:17.005
Everything is fine. But can we,

2577
02:03:17.125 --> 02:03:18.965
I have a question about the educational visioning session.

2578
02:03:19.025 --> 02:03:20.485
Can we do take that one first? Yes.

2579
02:03:20.715 --> 02:03:21.925
<v Speaker 1>Okay. All right.</v>

2580
02:03:21.925 --> 02:03:23.485
We're gonna move on from goals and,

2581
02:03:23.585 --> 02:03:26.005
and maybe individuals can send me summaries, sum

2582
02:03:26.665 --> 02:03:28.845
and No, we're gonna, I, I'm gonna summarize it.

2583
02:03:28.845 --> 02:03:31.205
It's gonna be an artifact of the next meeting. Great.

2584
02:03:31.825 --> 02:03:34.925
All right, let's move on. And Dr.

2585
02:03:34.975 --> 02:03:37.165
Stash is ready with the slide.

2586
02:03:37.365 --> 02:03:39.085
<v Speaker 12>I have it in front of mind, but there we go.</v>

2587
02:03:39.085 --> 02:03:40.245
You're so fast. Thank you.

2588
02:03:40.585 --> 02:03:42.005
So I think this is what you're talking about.

2589
02:03:42.875 --> 02:03:46.205
This is us providing an invitation to the school committee

2590
02:03:46.205 --> 02:03:47.805
to either of these sessions.

2591
02:03:48.145 --> 02:03:50.885
You can attend one, both, none. It's up to you.

2592
02:03:51.985 --> 02:03:53.605
We just learned about this in the school

2593
02:03:53.965 --> 02:03:55.085
building committee on Monday.

2594
02:03:55.105 --> 02:03:57.525
And this comes from the architect who is hosting this.

2595
02:03:58.065 --> 02:04:00.965
So one of them on the 18th, which is really

2596
02:04:01.025 --> 02:04:03.485
for memorial staff, but the school committee is invited.

2597
02:04:04.835 --> 02:04:09.405
It's a exercise that they'll facilitate would to define

2598
02:04:09.405 --> 02:04:11.365
what success looks like for memorial students

2599
02:04:11.385 --> 02:04:13.125
and what they need as they head to middle school.

2600
02:04:13.595 --> 02:04:14.645
That meetings for staff

2601
02:04:14.665 --> 02:04:16.125
and school committee, you're invited to that.

2602
02:04:16.385 --> 02:04:18.685
The other one is a very open session for the community,

2603
02:04:18.685 --> 02:04:20.445
which is on the eighth and it's at the Kennedy

2604
02:04:20.445 --> 02:04:21.525
Middle School auditorium.

2605
02:04:22.655 --> 02:04:24.285
These are, you know,

2606
02:04:24.395 --> 02:04:27.085
what the architect does in order to listen.

2607
02:04:27.505 --> 02:04:29.605
So we actually envision, we will not come to you

2608
02:04:29.605 --> 02:04:32.485
with a final Ed plan until December 21 so

2609
02:04:32.485 --> 02:04:33.645
that we can take this into account.

2610
02:04:33.785 --> 02:04:35.045
I'm not sure if that's where you were headed,

2611
02:04:35.585 --> 02:04:36.805
but really by then,

2612
02:04:36.865 --> 02:04:39.925
and I don't, I hope not to delay it a day past them

2613
02:04:39.925 --> 02:04:42.085
because really this is like an essential step

2614
02:04:42.305 --> 02:04:43.325
to moving this along.

2615
02:04:43.345 --> 02:04:45.445
We learned about that. They're really a,

2616
02:04:45.725 --> 02:04:47.165
a January due date for that.

2617
02:04:47.705 --> 02:04:50.205
So these are the two sessions that start to listen

2618
02:04:50.205 --> 02:04:52.485
to the public, to the staff, to the school committee.

2619
02:04:53.065 --> 02:04:55.165
And then we'll incorporate things

2620
02:04:55.165 --> 02:04:56.765
that we hear into our final plan.

2621
02:04:58.545 --> 02:05:01.005
<v Speaker 18>So actually that was you, you're getting at my question.</v>

2622
02:05:03.545 --> 02:05:06.005
So in terms of the timeline, I guess my, my question is,

2623
02:05:06.175 --> 02:05:08.285
where does the school committee besides participating

2624
02:05:08.285 --> 02:05:10.525
or listening in, we will have the opportunity

2625
02:05:10.525 --> 02:05:12.885
and thank you for inviting us to listen to the community.

2626
02:05:13.625 --> 02:05:15.285
I'm wondering, and,

2627
02:05:15.345 --> 02:05:16.845
and if I missed the opportunity

2628
02:05:16.935 --> 02:05:18.285
weeks ago, let me know that too.

2629
02:05:18.345 --> 02:05:20.645
But at what point is it,

2630
02:05:20.645 --> 02:05:23.165
because I know we've talked a lot about the education plan

2631
02:05:23.545 --> 02:05:25.285
as opposed to the education vision.

2632
02:05:25.745 --> 02:05:28.205
And this is about the vision I'm wondering is

2633
02:05:28.315 --> 02:05:31.245
what is the opportunity for the committee

2634
02:05:31.345 --> 02:05:32.885
to provide a vision?

2635
02:05:33.935 --> 02:05:35.725
<v Speaker 12>These, these are called visioning</v>

2636
02:05:35.765 --> 02:05:37.525
sessions for the ED program.

2637
02:05:38.235 --> 02:05:40.165
Okay. So it's just semantics.

2638
02:05:40.515 --> 02:05:41.765
It's what the, it's ed program

2639
02:05:41.935 --> 02:05:43.445
engagement is what I would call it.

2640
02:05:43.515 --> 02:05:45.085
This is what the architect calls it. Yeah.

2641
02:05:45.425 --> 02:05:47.605
So anytime in these meetings, you don't have

2642
02:05:47.605 --> 02:05:49.325
to be a silent participant in these either.

2643
02:05:49.465 --> 02:05:53.125
You absolutely can participate just alongside everyone else.

2644
02:05:53.395 --> 02:05:56.005
<v Speaker 18>Yeah. Well 'cause I'm wondering, I mean if we attend,</v>

2645
02:05:56.135 --> 02:05:59.045
there will be things that we'll hear from the public

2646
02:05:59.945 --> 02:06:01.925
and I think would be helpful to have.

2647
02:06:02.185 --> 02:06:03.725
And I know if others feel the same way,

2648
02:06:04.025 --> 02:06:05.845
to have the opportunity to be able to digest it

2649
02:06:05.845 --> 02:06:07.605
and kind of say, this is what we heard, this is

2650
02:06:07.605 --> 02:06:09.845
what we think as a committee is important.

2651
02:06:11.985 --> 02:06:14.245
And I don't know if that's something that we can, I,

2652
02:06:14.365 --> 02:06:18.845
I also don't wanna delay or detract the process

2653
02:06:19.205 --> 02:06:20.845
'cause I know we're in a timeline, but I'm wondering if

2654
02:06:20.845 --> 02:06:21.925
that's something that can be built on,

2655
02:06:21.925 --> 02:06:24.405
and maybe that is December 21st meeting or,

2656
02:06:25.865 --> 02:06:27.285
but for us to kind of come together

2657
02:06:27.285 --> 02:06:28.725
and say, this is what we hear, this is

2658
02:06:28.725 --> 02:06:29.925
what we're hearing from these sessions.

2659
02:06:29.945 --> 02:06:32.365
But also from, 'cause I'm already getting some people's

2660
02:06:32.525 --> 02:06:33.845
comments, feedback, thoughts and I,

2661
02:06:33.985 --> 02:06:36.525
and I'm thinking, I hope I'm not too late to like bring this

2662
02:06:36.545 --> 02:06:38.085
and say this is what I,

2663
02:06:38.185 --> 02:06:39.645
I'm hearing from the community are some

2664
02:06:39.645 --> 02:06:41.405
of the important, I don't think themes.

2665
02:06:41.805 --> 02:06:43.565
<v Speaker 12>I don't think you're too late. But I also think this has</v>

2666
02:06:43.565 --> 02:06:45.005
been on our agenda since May 4th.

2667
02:06:45.155 --> 02:06:48.045
Yeah. And so there was some discussion to kind

2668
02:06:48.045 --> 02:06:49.365
of delay it and I'm like, no, we're not.

2669
02:06:49.825 --> 02:06:51.845
I'm not gonna recommend we delay it a minute further.

2670
02:06:52.615 --> 02:06:54.605
We've had opportunities here in these meetings

2671
02:06:54.605 --> 02:06:55.965
that you guys have put on your website

2672
02:06:56.025 --> 02:06:57.605
for the community to weigh in.

2673
02:06:57.985 --> 02:07:01.005
So I'm happy if it's the committee's recommendation

2674
02:07:01.005 --> 02:07:03.045
to move it out, I'm happy to hear that.

2675
02:07:03.345 --> 02:07:05.765
But my recommendation is we gotta land this plane.

2676
02:07:06.805 --> 02:07:09.765
I do hear you that these visioning, we don't have a meeting

2677
02:07:10.235 --> 02:07:11.405
between December 8th

2678
02:07:11.405 --> 02:07:14.525
and December 21st when we come with that final version.

2679
02:07:15.665 --> 02:07:19.205
And so if the committee wants to entertain a special meeting

2680
02:07:19.305 --> 02:07:22.285
to do that, I can tell you that Karen Gani mlis

2681
02:07:22.285 --> 02:07:25.645
and the Chris Cook who are kind of interpret taking these in

2682
02:07:25.645 --> 02:07:27.445
and incorporating alongside the architect

2683
02:07:28.275 --> 02:07:30.085
will absolutely be incorporated.

2684
02:07:30.085 --> 02:07:32.165
And that's the whole point of the sessions is to incorporate

2685
02:07:32.165 --> 02:07:34.965
what we hear and we're happy to kind of

2686
02:07:35.045 --> 02:07:38.885
however the, if there's, if we need another meeting to do so

2687
02:07:39.735 --> 02:07:41.725
we'll do whatever the te the committee wants.

2688
02:07:42.065 --> 02:07:44.045
<v Speaker 18>And it's, if it's easier, I'd be happy.</v>

2689
02:07:44.165 --> 02:07:45.765
I mean, and again, I don't know if other committee members

2690
02:07:45.765 --> 02:07:47.405
feel the same way, but I could even put it in writing

2691
02:07:47.615 --> 02:07:50.045
after December 8th, you know, so that, so that you come

2692
02:07:50.045 --> 02:07:52.925
to December 21st, having had that in writing before, I

2693
02:07:52.925 --> 02:07:54.685
<v Speaker 1>Think that that would be appropriate no matter what.</v>

2694
02:07:54.685 --> 02:07:56.485
Yeah. The topic was Right. That's one of our norms.

2695
02:07:56.485 --> 02:08:00.285
If people, certainly if people have comments on any topic,

2696
02:08:00.635 --> 02:08:02.125
they can come in via email.

2697
02:08:02.635 --> 02:08:05.325
<v Speaker 18>Yeah. And I, I really, you know, I do apologize.</v>

2698
02:08:05.525 --> 02:08:07.205
I mean, not apologize. I well I apologize too,

2699
02:08:07.205 --> 02:08:09.565
but I, I am a, I know we started this

2700
02:08:09.565 --> 02:08:10.765
conversation a long time ago.

2701
02:08:11.325 --> 02:08:12.485
I feel like the community,

2702
02:08:12.585 --> 02:08:13.605
I'm hearing from the community

2703
02:08:13.675 --> 02:08:15.165
more in the past couple weeks.

2704
02:08:15.405 --> 02:08:17.245
'cause I feel like now with all the Facebook posts

2705
02:08:17.245 --> 02:08:18.525
and people are starting to pay attention,

2706
02:08:19.025 --> 02:08:20.325
so I'm hearing more about it.

2707
02:08:20.665 --> 02:08:23.005
And so I'm, I'm trying to like digest it all and,

2708
02:08:23.025 --> 02:08:25.045
and say, okay, here's what I'm hearing the community wants.

2709
02:08:25.445 --> 02:08:26.405
And it's nothing that different

2710
02:08:26.405 --> 02:08:27.565
by the way, from what we already have.

2711
02:08:28.125 --> 02:08:31.965
It's just wanting to be able to articulate

2712
02:08:32.105 --> 02:08:33.925
and sup, you know, support the process

2713
02:08:34.105 --> 02:08:36.645
by putting it all into kind of some of the,

2714
02:08:37.605 --> 02:08:38.645
I I wrote wrote it down

2715
02:08:38.645 --> 02:08:39.805
like four or five themes I'm hearing.

2716
02:08:39.805 --> 02:08:40.965
Yeah. You know, people kind of talk about,

2717
02:08:41.235 --> 02:08:44.085
<v Speaker 12>We'd love that feedback as you've seen before.</v>

2718
02:08:44.235 --> 02:08:46.765
When we present a new version, we try to name the shifts

2719
02:08:46.905 --> 02:08:49.045
or name anything that's changed and why.

2720
02:08:49.505 --> 02:08:51.125
So kind of the themes we might be hearing.

2721
02:08:51.265 --> 02:08:53.565
So we'll take your lead.

2722
02:08:53.665 --> 02:08:54.805
But I do think we need to,

2723
02:08:54.815 --> 02:08:57.125
we're starting budget season also on the 21st.

2724
02:08:57.145 --> 02:08:59.565
We have a really robust season for that that runs through,

2725
02:08:59.945 --> 02:09:01.445
you guys know like March.

2726
02:09:02.305 --> 02:09:04.805
And so it's my recommendation we try

2727
02:09:04.805 --> 02:09:05.805
to land this on the 21st,

2728
02:09:05.825 --> 02:09:07.405
but I'm really happy to hear

2729
02:09:07.755 --> 02:09:09.605
that we have a lot more community engagement.

2730
02:09:09.605 --> 02:09:14.125
That's great. So yeah. Good. I, I think you,

2731
02:09:14.915 --> 02:09:15.915
<v Speaker 18>That was good.</v>

2732
02:09:15.915 --> 02:09:16.725
Good. Okay. Good.

2733
02:09:16.855 --> 02:09:21.245
<v Speaker 1>Sorry I have no good one. One more. Next agenda item.</v>

2734
02:09:21.275 --> 02:09:23.205
Yeah. Before we get to the subcommittee updates,

2735
02:09:23.225 --> 02:09:24.365
but we'll move on to the,

2736
02:09:24.665 --> 02:09:26.005
<v Speaker 12>So we'll do the option E.</v>

2737
02:09:26.025 --> 02:09:26.925
Yep. Great.

2738
02:09:31.345 --> 02:09:32.845
So after our meeting,

2739
02:09:33.365 --> 02:09:35.405
I don't know when it was a couple weeks ago

2740
02:09:35.915 --> 02:09:39.525
when we discussed kind of the MOU for east,

2741
02:09:40.285 --> 02:09:41.405
I have good news on that front.

2742
02:09:42.025 --> 02:09:45.765
We, we wanted to think about how do we

2743
02:09:46.675 --> 02:09:48.205
give some flexibility to this?

2744
02:09:48.205 --> 02:09:49.765
To this and sort of see it in phases.

2745
02:09:49.785 --> 02:09:53.005
So we're coming to you with a little bit of an update.

2746
02:09:54.305 --> 02:09:57.805
So on June 15th, this is last spring,

2747
02:09:58.145 --> 02:09:59.725
the committee supported option B,

2748
02:09:59.975 --> 02:10:02.765
which was four classrooms at the new memorial

2749
02:10:02.865 --> 02:10:06.725
and six at East we're offering tonight option E,

2750
02:10:06.725 --> 02:10:07.805
which is a new option.

2751
02:10:07.945 --> 02:10:09.285
We had A through D before,

2752
02:10:10.135 --> 02:10:13.725
which would put five classrooms at East four at the new

2753
02:10:13.965 --> 02:10:15.685
memorial and maintain one at Behe.

2754
02:10:16.905 --> 02:10:19.805
The compromise is retaining three preschool sites.

2755
02:10:20.065 --> 02:10:22.605
So before it was two, this would be back to three.

2756
02:10:23.585 --> 02:10:25.405
We would maintain 10 classrooms

2757
02:10:25.425 --> 02:10:27.685
and move the preschool out of NHS

2758
02:10:27.685 --> 02:10:28.725
or the high school beginning

2759
02:10:28.725 --> 02:10:31.245
with classrooms in FY 28, which is also a change.

2760
02:10:31.865 --> 02:10:35.045
So next slide please. This just shows

2761
02:10:35.045 --> 02:10:38.045
that original option B in case it's helpful to see it

2762
02:10:38.175 --> 02:10:41.005
where you see the four classrooms at New Memorial

2763
02:10:41.225 --> 02:10:44.365
and six at East, none at the high school and none at Behem.

2764
02:10:45.385 --> 02:10:48.405
And go the next one please. I wish that thing was here.

2765
02:10:49.705 --> 02:10:52.365
I'm missing it. This is our proposal

2766
02:10:52.505 --> 02:10:55.325
or classroom distribution by phase, which is also new

2767
02:10:55.325 --> 02:10:56.365
because before we were kind

2768
02:10:56.365 --> 02:10:58.365
of looking at it like now and later.

2769
02:10:58.985 --> 02:11:01.125
So the FY 27 baseline is the four

2770
02:11:01.125 --> 02:11:02.605
classrooms at East are currently there.

2771
02:11:02.705 --> 02:11:06.605
One at Behe, five at the high school in FY 28.

2772
02:11:06.865 --> 02:11:08.165
We had new information we

2773
02:11:08.165 --> 02:11:09.405
couldn't have proposed this last June.

2774
02:11:10.225 --> 02:11:13.445
We would pro propose getting five classrooms into east

2775
02:11:13.755 --> 02:11:16.365
that requires us to move the ASAP offices out,

2776
02:11:16.535 --> 02:11:19.725
which we have a plan for which we could convert that space

2777
02:11:20.275 --> 02:11:23.885
into a classroom and move an additional classroom into Behe,

2778
02:11:23.975 --> 02:11:25.685
which we feel secure that we can do.

2779
02:11:26.265 --> 02:11:29.685
So we'd be able to re alleviate two classrooms worth

2780
02:11:29.685 --> 02:11:31.605
of space, which they are very thrilled to hear.

2781
02:11:31.605 --> 02:11:33.525
This could happen at the high school.

2782
02:11:33.585 --> 02:11:36.085
It would leave three classes still at the high school.

2783
02:11:36.705 --> 02:11:39.165
Am I making sense so far? Okay.

2784
02:11:40.185 --> 02:11:42.445
It still keeps with the 10 preschool classrooms

2785
02:11:42.445 --> 02:11:44.765
that are available and then when Memorial opens,

2786
02:11:45.065 --> 02:11:48.005
the remaining three high school classrooms would move over

2787
02:11:48.625 --> 02:11:50.445
and the one Behem class would move.

2788
02:11:51.235 --> 02:11:53.485
Okay. So the end gets to,

2789
02:11:53.605 --> 02:11:54.965
I think I have it in another slide.

2790
02:11:56.265 --> 02:11:58.685
Oh well this just shows that movement.

2791
02:11:58.965 --> 02:12:01.045
I can't even see it hardly from here. The PHAs. Yep.

2792
02:12:01.115 --> 02:12:05.605
Next one. This just describes the fifth classroom

2793
02:12:05.905 --> 02:12:07.925
at East and the fact that we're pretty confident we

2794
02:12:07.925 --> 02:12:08.965
can move that fifth classroom.

2795
02:12:09.255 --> 02:12:11.325
We've asked to move the ASAP offices

2796
02:12:11.465 --> 02:12:12.805
to the interim space at Johnson.

2797
02:12:13.195 --> 02:12:14.325
That may or may not happen,

2798
02:12:14.425 --> 02:12:17.005
but the Jamie Erickson, the town administrator

2799
02:12:17.025 --> 02:12:19.845
and I, he has another plan if that one weren't to to happen.

2800
02:12:20.025 --> 02:12:23.125
So we feel pretty confident we can move those offices out

2801
02:12:23.125 --> 02:12:25.045
and retrofit the room over this summer

2802
02:12:25.625 --> 02:12:27.885
to make a classroom for the preschool.

2803
02:12:28.465 --> 02:12:30.965
That's still in progress in the next slide.

2804
02:12:32.845 --> 02:12:35.385
In terms of the East MOU, I'm happy

2805
02:12:35.385 --> 02:12:36.945
to say I have a draft MOU

2806
02:12:37.135 --> 02:12:39.385
that I received today from the town administrator that goes

2807
02:12:39.385 --> 02:12:42.825
through 2032, which is good.

2808
02:12:43.645 --> 02:12:46.345
And so we're finalizing that from what that means for me.

2809
02:12:46.825 --> 02:12:49.305
I know Jamie used the template that we use for MOUs,

2810
02:12:49.325 --> 02:12:51.305
but I wanna go over it with Aaron and Matt

2811
02:12:51.565 --> 02:12:53.625
and the high school, the preschool director.

2812
02:12:53.885 --> 02:12:56.505
And so we'll do that sometime within the next week or so.

2813
02:12:56.505 --> 02:12:57.585
But I feel really confident

2814
02:12:58.165 --> 02:13:00.305
that's not something I would normally bring to the committee

2815
02:13:00.305 --> 02:13:01.505
that's operational.

2816
02:13:02.025 --> 02:13:03.065
And these are things we do,

2817
02:13:03.365 --> 02:13:05.145
but I wanted to update the committee

2818
02:13:05.145 --> 02:13:06.465
that we have that well underway.

2819
02:13:06.465 --> 02:13:10.985
So thank you for that. And then last one, next slide.

2820
02:13:10.985 --> 02:13:14.025
Yeah, there we go. That's the one I was looking at that kind

2821
02:13:14.025 --> 02:13:16.625
of shows B, the prior option that the school committee voted

2822
02:13:17.485 --> 02:13:20.945
and EI cannot see it very well, but I'll look at it on mine.

2823
02:13:22.135 --> 02:13:26.585
Here we go. So you can see we move to

2824
02:13:27.815 --> 02:13:31.925
east being five classrooms and then Memorial being four

2825
02:13:32.265 --> 02:13:34.005
and one at Behe is the ultimate.

2826
02:13:35.235 --> 02:13:38.885
Okay. Two preschool sites not in move to three,

2827
02:13:38.935 --> 02:13:41.445
which is the kind of compromise we

2828
02:13:41.445 --> 02:13:42.605
move everything out of the high school.

2829
02:13:42.625 --> 02:13:43.805
We stay at 10 classrooms,

2830
02:13:45.025 --> 02:13:46.525
so the trade off is going to three sites.

2831
02:13:50.905 --> 02:13:54.005
And so we're kind of seeking some direction if this option

2832
02:13:54.005 --> 02:13:57.445
that we've come up with, given the more recent movement

2833
02:13:57.465 --> 02:14:02.205
of the, of the ASAP offices to hopefully Johnson made

2834
02:14:02.305 --> 02:14:04.085
for some flexibility in this plan.

2835
02:14:04.565 --> 02:14:06.885
I have talked to Jamie. I think there is still an opening

2836
02:14:06.985 --> 02:14:09.205
to a six classroom east scenario,

2837
02:14:09.945 --> 02:14:12.085
but it, it might take some time

2838
02:14:12.085 --> 02:14:13.805
and we have to understand kind of the park

2839
02:14:14.605 --> 02:14:16.045
classification of that property.

2840
02:14:16.725 --> 02:14:18.525
And so it's probably gonna take some joint work,

2841
02:14:18.525 --> 02:14:20.245
which I feel confident we'll both look into

2842
02:14:22.665 --> 02:14:23.925
<v Speaker 1>Ms. Collins and Mr. Patel.</v>

2843
02:14:25.655 --> 02:14:29.645
<v Speaker 25>Thank you in the explanation of</v>

2844
02:14:33.625 --> 02:14:37.245
how we would end up you keeping one at, at Behe.

2845
02:14:39.115 --> 02:14:41.255
I'm assuming we have room at Behe to go to two,

2846
02:14:42.135 --> 02:14:43.375
but you talk about staff,

2847
02:14:44.655 --> 02:14:48.815
I don't think flexibility was the word you used, but, and

2848
02:14:48.835 --> 02:14:53.755
and sharing of resources, is that our

2849
02:14:54.615 --> 02:14:58.315
choice or is that staff choice

2850
02:14:58.455 --> 02:14:59.835
or who's who's,

2851
02:14:59.945 --> 02:15:01.395
<v Speaker 12>What do you mean sharing of resources?</v>

2852
02:15:01.495 --> 02:15:03.195
I'm I'm trying to make sure I understand the question.

2853
02:15:03.995 --> 02:15:05.715
<v Speaker 25>I I was pulling them from what you said.</v>

2854
02:15:06.375 --> 02:15:09.435
<v Speaker 12>Did you catch that?</v>
<v Speaker 1>Do you mean</v>

2855
02:15:10.265 --> 02:15:12.475
splitting like the director having to go

2856
02:15:12.475 --> 02:15:13.555
to three locations or are you

2857
02:15:13.555 --> 02:15:14.715
talking about something else? Well

2858
02:15:15.295 --> 02:15:17.475
<v Speaker 25>Go one, go past one, one past here.</v>

2859
02:15:17.775 --> 02:15:20.955
No I was wrong. We're going in the wrong direction. I that

2860
02:15:21.775 --> 02:15:22.835
<v Speaker 1>The trade off thing, right?</v>

2861
02:15:22.935 --> 02:15:25.155
The trade-offs. Three sites retain the staff travel

2862
02:15:25.155 --> 02:15:26.395
and service coordination needs.

2863
02:15:26.535 --> 02:15:27.635
<v Speaker 25>Yes. Service</v>
<v Speaker 12>Coordination. Yes. Okay.</v>

2864
02:15:28.575 --> 02:15:30.795
You wanna go to that? Yeah. Thank you. So service

2865
02:15:31.155 --> 02:15:34.235
<v Speaker 11>Providers right now at Benham actually the Benham service</v>

2866
02:15:34.635 --> 02:15:36.435
providers, OTs, pt, so forth,

2867
02:15:36.505 --> 02:15:38.035
they service those students over there.

2868
02:15:38.095 --> 02:15:39.155
So we would still think if

2869
02:15:39.155 --> 02:15:41.275
that's reasonable FTE to be able to do that.

2870
02:15:41.575 --> 02:15:42.755
If not, we would think about

2871
02:15:42.755 --> 02:15:45.395
how we're gonna allocate the preschool staff

2872
02:15:46.335 --> 02:15:47.355
across three sites.

2873
02:15:47.455 --> 02:15:48.995
But we've, we've been able

2874
02:15:49.015 --> 02:15:52.755
to maintain some higher staffing ratios over at Ben Hem

2875
02:15:52.755 --> 02:15:54.195
because we have two programs there

2876
02:15:54.495 --> 02:15:56.635
and they've been able to support some of the needs there.

2877
02:15:56.655 --> 02:15:58.835
Adding an additional classroom, yes, we're gonna have

2878
02:15:58.835 --> 02:16:02.755
to reevaluate that, but I'm confident we have the FTEs PEs

2879
02:16:03.345 --> 02:16:05.475
with amongst the preschool that we can

2880
02:16:06.195 --> 02:16:08.875
allocate appro ac appropriately across all three sites.

2881
02:16:08.975 --> 02:16:11.395
In terms of teaching staff, Jackie

2882
02:16:11.455 --> 02:16:12.955
and I had a conversation with the,

2883
02:16:12.955 --> 02:16:15.115
with preschool staff today to give 'em an update

2884
02:16:15.115 --> 02:16:16.395
that we we're having this conversation.

2885
02:16:16.455 --> 02:16:17.875
So there will be no surprises about that

2886
02:16:18.455 --> 02:16:22.635
and there's an understanding that there will be some TE

2887
02:16:23.155 --> 02:16:24.595
teachers and paraprofessionals

2888
02:16:24.615 --> 02:16:27.475
who will be relocated as a result of this.

2889
02:16:27.575 --> 02:16:29.075
And there's an understanding around that,

2890
02:16:29.345 --> 02:16:33.125
around the interim plan before getting to the memorial.

2891
02:16:33.125 --> 02:16:34.725
Okay. The memorial plan. Thank

2892
02:16:34.725 --> 02:16:35.725
<v Speaker 25>You.</v>

2893
02:16:35.725 --> 02:16:37.205
And I'm assuming we don't have

2894
02:16:37.205 --> 02:16:39.965
to retrofit anything at Benham do, what is the cost

2895
02:16:39.965 --> 02:16:42.005
of retrofitting at the school?

2896
02:16:43.065 --> 02:16:46.285
<v Speaker 12>We don't have that at the well to retrofit.</v>

2897
02:16:46.625 --> 02:16:48.725
We don't know what it would cost to do asap.

2898
02:16:48.845 --> 02:16:50.805
I mean, unless you guys have a estimate for that,

2899
02:16:52.025 --> 02:16:53.845
but we feel confident we could fit it into this

2900
02:16:53.845 --> 02:16:54.965
year's budget with a transfer.

2901
02:16:55.235 --> 02:16:58.845
<v Speaker 11>Yeah, I I actually think the ASAP space is actually,</v>

2902
02:16:59.155 --> 02:17:03.245
there's some other classroom space at the pre at the E

2903
02:17:03.245 --> 02:17:05.565
school that we might be able to use as classroom

2904
02:17:05.565 --> 02:17:07.245
and then move some offices,

2905
02:17:07.595 --> 02:17:10.445
some service delivery space into the ASAP space.

2906
02:17:10.465 --> 02:17:11.965
We might be able to use the ASAP space

2907
02:17:11.965 --> 02:17:14.285
as a more flexible multipurpose space.

2908
02:17:15.745 --> 02:17:18.245
We have to really map out the visioning for it.

2909
02:17:18.245 --> 02:17:20.645
But there's a lot of, there's a lot of options to use

2910
02:17:20.915 --> 02:17:23.765
with existing front classroom space that our offices

2911
02:17:23.905 --> 02:17:25.365
and OT room now that we,

2912
02:17:25.395 --> 02:17:27.405
that could be ample classroom space.

2913
02:17:27.745 --> 02:17:28.885
<v Speaker 25>But you're comfortable</v>

2914
02:17:28.885 --> 02:17:32.845
that this can happen in the 28 budget without

2915
02:17:35.135 --> 02:17:38.175
restrictions on programs that we also would like to keep.

2916
02:17:39.355 --> 02:17:42.175
<v Speaker 12>Yep. I think that</v>
<v Speaker 25>Or over the 27. So</v>

2917
02:17:42.175 --> 02:17:45.055
<v Speaker 12>We kind of need to land on like the direction we wanna</v>

2918
02:17:45.055 --> 02:17:47.415
take and this interim use is new

2919
02:17:47.475 --> 02:17:49.735
and we don't have an answer yet from the town

2920
02:17:49.735 --> 02:17:50.735
because they're working on that.

2921
02:17:50.875 --> 02:17:52.695
But if we were to secure

2922
02:17:52.755 --> 02:17:56.375
and be able to retrofit east, we are confident

2923
02:17:56.375 --> 02:17:59.575
that we could work with efficiency of money

2924
02:17:59.715 --> 02:18:04.175
and resources to expend the least amount possible

2925
02:18:04.175 --> 02:18:07.615
to make a really viable space there with FY $27

2926
02:18:07.645 --> 02:18:10.095
that would require a transfer and be done

2927
02:18:10.315 --> 02:18:12.615
and maybe some summer resources.

2928
02:18:12.615 --> 02:18:14.375
But we feel like that is not prohibitive

2929
02:18:15.395 --> 02:18:17.335
and the budget in terms of like the resources

2930
02:18:17.595 --> 02:18:19.575
for next year wouldn't change in terms

2931
02:18:19.575 --> 02:18:21.015
of the allocations of staff.

2932
02:18:22.055 --> 02:18:25.535
FY $28 could be some summer dollars if it extends

2933
02:18:25.535 --> 02:18:26.535
because it is summer work.

2934
02:18:26.715 --> 02:18:28.775
So that's what we'd have to figure out.

2935
02:18:29.205 --> 02:18:31.695
<v Speaker 25>Well I'm thrilled that you think we can reallocate.</v>

2936
02:18:32.695 --> 02:18:36.415
I I don't want that to be the default all the time

2937
02:18:36.725 --> 02:18:40.255
because well if you can always reallocate then you didn't

2938
02:18:40.255 --> 02:18:42.295
need it the first time And I don't wanna hear that from,

2939
02:18:42.445 --> 02:18:44.175
<v Speaker 12>Well I can happily tell consumers,</v>

2940
02:18:44.375 --> 02:18:46.575
I tell you the source here, I mean, I'm just gonna say it.

2941
02:18:46.885 --> 02:18:48.935
I've been without an executive assistant since

2942
02:18:49.085 --> 02:18:50.575
July or whenever it was.

2943
02:18:50.635 --> 02:18:53.775
So that's been fun and,

2944
02:18:54.315 --> 02:18:56.815
but it did alleviate some money so

2945
02:18:57.475 --> 02:18:58.975
you're very right to bring that up.

2946
02:18:58.995 --> 02:19:00.535
But it's not like there was money hiding.

2947
02:19:00.605 --> 02:19:01.975
It's literally unspent dollars.

2948
02:19:01.975 --> 02:19:03.055
That's what I wanna be clear. Thank

2949
02:19:03.055 --> 02:19:04.055
<v Speaker 25>You.</v>

2950
02:19:04.055 --> 02:19:05.335
We had programs that we didn't need to do

2951
02:19:05.365 --> 02:19:09.015
because you lost your executive assistant as opposed

2952
02:19:09.075 --> 02:19:10.535
to we padded the budget.

2953
02:19:10.535 --> 02:19:12.895
Yeah, that's the message that I want to be out there.

2954
02:19:13.035 --> 02:19:14.535
<v Speaker 12>Always ask that question if it needs</v>

2955
02:19:14.535 --> 02:19:15.735
to be clarified because thank you.

2956
02:19:15.915 --> 02:19:19.095
It need, you know, and, and that's neither here nor there.

2957
02:19:19.095 --> 02:19:20.135
It's just a source of some

2958
02:19:20.135 --> 02:19:21.455
additional funds for the transfer.

2959
02:19:22.005 --> 02:19:23.255
<v Speaker 25>Fine,</v>
<v Speaker 12>Thank you. But I can't wait</v>

2960
02:19:23.255 --> 02:19:25.015
to get an executive system.

2961
02:19:25.315 --> 02:19:30.085
<v Speaker 25>Mr. Patel,</v>
<v Speaker 24>With regards to the MOU currently proposed</v>

2962
02:19:30.085 --> 02:19:33.525
through thir 2032, is it four or five or six classrooms?

2963
02:19:33.915 --> 02:19:35.045
<v Speaker 12>Four.</v>
<v Speaker 21>Four.</v>

2964
02:19:35.075 --> 02:19:38.005
<v Speaker 12>Okay. Well it's, it's our existing footprint</v>

2965
02:19:38.855 --> 02:19:42.045
which we are looking to convert into a fifth classroom.

2966
02:19:42.345 --> 02:19:44.245
So essentially we actually, Jamie

2967
02:19:44.265 --> 02:19:45.445
and I really talked about that.

2968
02:19:45.575 --> 02:19:47.165
Let's not name the number of classrooms

2969
02:19:47.165 --> 02:19:49.245
because as long as it's our existing footprint

2970
02:19:49.585 --> 02:19:51.685
and I think ar we, we walk the space,

2971
02:19:51.985 --> 02:19:54.525
we feel comfortable we can fit a fifth in classroom.

2972
02:19:54.985 --> 02:19:56.845
We just aren't unsure where we'd put it yet.

2973
02:19:56.845 --> 02:19:58.325
And we wanna look at the cost analysis.

2974
02:19:58.945 --> 02:20:01.725
So it's the existing footprint which we are confident

2975
02:20:01.725 --> 02:20:03.405
with yield at least one more classroom.

2976
02:20:03.555 --> 02:20:05.805
<v Speaker 24>Okay. So that would negate the option B</v>

2977
02:20:05.805 --> 02:20:07.765
that we sort of voted on, right. With six rooms.

2978
02:20:08.405 --> 02:20:09.845
<v Speaker 12>I would say it negates it for now,</v>

2979
02:20:10.745 --> 02:20:13.525
but I I, I really have talked to Jamie about it

2980
02:20:13.525 --> 02:20:14.965
and we talked about it just today.

2981
02:20:15.525 --> 02:20:17.685
I think he can see the advantage of having all

2982
02:20:17.685 --> 02:20:20.365
of east be a preschool eventually, but it's gotta phase in

2983
02:20:20.365 --> 02:20:21.845
because there's so much moving.

2984
02:20:22.145 --> 02:20:24.405
The why is MO would potentially move

2985
02:20:24.405 --> 02:20:25.685
some places over to Johnson.

2986
02:20:25.795 --> 02:20:27.365
Like all of this is still in motion

2987
02:20:27.785 --> 02:20:30.765
and we need to be, I feel like we need to be good partners

2988
02:20:32.545 --> 02:20:33.885
and see where that all lands

2989
02:20:33.885 --> 02:20:35.605
before we kind of take that next phase

2990
02:20:36.585 --> 02:20:37.585
<v Speaker 24>And just follow up.</v>

2991
02:20:37.685 --> 02:20:39.925
When would be, if if it were to be five,

2992
02:20:40.035 --> 02:20:42.645
like let's say we move along with option E,

2993
02:20:42.795 --> 02:20:45.085
when would the transition of that one classroom

2994
02:20:46.035 --> 02:20:47.035
<v Speaker 12>This summer?</v>

2995
02:20:47.035 --> 02:20:50.125
Okay we want, we'd want both of these classrooms open

2996
02:20:50.825 --> 02:20:53.285
by the start of the school year in FY 28 so

2997
02:20:53.285 --> 02:20:55.485
that we had two classrooms freed up for the high school

2998
02:20:55.825 --> 02:20:59.125
to use next year we would abs I know this question is coming

2999
02:20:59.365 --> 02:21:00.485
'cause I would be asking it.

3000
02:21:00.905 --> 02:21:02.765
We will absolutely preserve the pathway

3001
02:21:03.025 --> 02:21:04.485
for the early childhood program.

3002
02:21:04.715 --> 02:21:05.845
That is not gonna change

3003
02:21:06.185 --> 02:21:07.645
and we'll figure out a way to do that

3004
02:21:08.185 --> 02:21:10.845
for now in the existing high school space is what I assume.

3005
02:21:11.025 --> 02:21:13.365
But we are, that is absolutely not gonna go away.

3006
02:21:13.705 --> 02:21:15.445
We don't, we know how much the committee values

3007
02:21:15.445 --> 02:21:16.765
it and we value it.

3008
02:21:17.815 --> 02:21:19.485
<v Speaker 24>Thank you</v>
<v Speaker 11>Mr.</v>

3009
02:21:19.835 --> 02:21:22.885
<v Speaker 21>Your</v>
<v Speaker 11>Question, are we certain that the MSBA is gonna</v>

3010
02:21:24.445 --> 02:21:27.125
reimburse us for four preschool classrooms

3011
02:21:27.225 --> 02:21:28.365
at the new memorial

3012
02:21:30.855 --> 02:21:33.205
<v Speaker 21>Based on the enrollment letter that they sent?</v>

3013
02:21:33.505 --> 02:21:34.505
Yes.

3014
02:21:35.135 --> 02:21:37.645
<v Speaker 11>Great. So that's a we're confirmed for</v>

3015
02:21:37.915 --> 02:21:40.525
because they said, I guess the que my que the reason I'm

3016
02:21:40.525 --> 02:21:41.725
asking is

3017
02:21:41.955 --> 02:21:45.125
because it said neighborhood so that

3018
02:21:45.265 --> 02:21:46.765
that's up to us to decide.

3019
02:21:46.825 --> 02:21:49.565
But at this point the, the space has been approved.

3020
02:21:50.235 --> 02:21:54.565
<v Speaker 21>There's an, there's an educational program of pre-K</v>

3021
02:21:54.565 --> 02:21:58.925
to 4 570 students plus four well

3022
02:21:59.565 --> 02:22:02.285
neighborhood pre-K classrooms.

3023
02:22:02.785 --> 02:22:05.805
And so we kind of get to determine

3024
02:22:05.835 --> 02:22:07.165
what the neighborhood's gonna be.

3025
02:22:07.235 --> 02:22:09.485
Okay. And the, the new neighborhood

3026
02:22:09.545 --> 02:22:11.885
for a new memorial could change

3027
02:22:13.555 --> 02:22:15.645
depending on the location of the school

3028
02:22:15.825 --> 02:22:17.125
and and the size of it.

3029
02:22:17.275 --> 02:22:19.485
Okay. So with that

3030
02:22:20.185 --> 02:22:23.285
we logically deduced four classrooms.

3031
02:22:23.595 --> 02:22:28.005
<v Speaker 11>Okay. And with that logical deduction,</v>

3032
02:22:28.265 --> 02:22:29.325
the money comes with it.

3033
02:22:31.595 --> 02:22:33.605
<v Speaker 21>They hold the gold, they make the rules,</v>

3034
02:22:33.745 --> 02:22:34.885
but that's what it looks like.

3035
02:22:35.445 --> 02:22:37.245
I can't say that it's automatically gonna happen

3036
02:22:37.245 --> 02:22:42.085
because we have to provide a preferred option.

3037
02:22:42.235 --> 02:22:46.045
They have to approve it, then we have to design it

3038
02:22:46.045 --> 02:22:48.285
and then they approve that and then we construct it

3039
02:22:48.625 --> 02:22:51.285
and then they audit that.

3040
02:22:51.505 --> 02:22:54.325
And then eventually everything, you know,

3041
02:22:54.325 --> 02:22:57.805
that they say they were gonna do, they do almost all of it.

3042
02:22:57.805 --> 02:23:00.325
They have auditors, they almost always find something that

3043
02:23:00.955 --> 02:23:02.005
they pull out.

3044
02:23:02.915 --> 02:23:04.965
<v Speaker 11>Okay. And let me just be transparent.</v>

3045
02:23:04.985 --> 02:23:08.485
The reason I'm asking, so the Memorial Building school

3046
02:23:08.485 --> 02:23:10.165
committee, I gotta encourage you guys

3047
02:23:10.165 --> 02:23:11.685
to put minutes up again

3048
02:23:11.685 --> 02:23:13.045
because your minute, the minutes are

3049
02:23:13.045 --> 02:23:14.125
not up to date on the website.

3050
02:23:14.275 --> 02:23:17.405
Okay. But the presentation is up from the architect

3051
02:23:17.905 --> 02:23:21.565
and so there's a slide that shows two sites,

3052
02:23:22.175 --> 02:23:23.685
which was a surprise to me.

3053
02:23:24.645 --> 02:23:26.325
Somebody called me. I didn't realize that we had

3054
02:23:26.395 --> 02:23:29.005
that it had already been narrowed so closely to two sites.

3055
02:23:29.865 --> 02:23:32.125
So maybe it hasn't, but the person said to me,

3056
02:23:32.585 --> 02:23:34.205
it seems like you're telling me

3057
02:23:34.595 --> 02:23:37.045
that there's either not gonna be four classrooms there

3058
02:23:37.045 --> 02:23:39.365
for preschools there because there's no way they would fit

3059
02:23:39.365 --> 02:23:41.565
on one or that you're gonna put many more

3060
02:23:41.565 --> 02:23:43.045
because the other side is big.

3061
02:23:43.665 --> 02:23:46.045
So lots of lots of, yeah,

3062
02:23:46.105 --> 02:23:47.105
<v Speaker 12>Go ahead.</v>

3063
02:23:47.105 --> 02:23:48.685
So that's a question best put to the SBC. Okay.

3064
02:23:48.785 --> 02:23:51.485
Not to the administration. Okay. I would say. Okay.

3065
02:23:51.885 --> 02:23:54.205
I would say this was a robust conversation in our meeting on

3066
02:23:54.205 --> 02:23:58.125
Monday night and it was determined to not rush towards this.

3067
02:23:58.395 --> 02:24:03.125
Okay. I'm speaking from being a participant at that meeting

3068
02:24:03.985 --> 02:24:08.685
and I know we have initiated a title investigation

3069
02:24:08.705 --> 02:24:11.285
to make sure that that's a viable parcel

3070
02:24:11.625 --> 02:24:13.805
and there's a reason there's nothing yet out.

3071
02:24:13.905 --> 02:24:15.605
And nor would it be my thing

3072
02:24:15.865 --> 02:24:19.125
to be broadcasting about site selection.

3073
02:24:19.445 --> 02:24:21.405
That would be the MSBC not our job.

3074
02:24:21.435 --> 02:24:24.765
Like we're on the committee. Yeah. But that's the MSBC.

3075
02:24:24.825 --> 02:24:26.885
So those questions should be directed there. Okay.

3076
02:24:29.125 --> 02:24:31.165
<v Speaker 11>I just bring it up tonight because the people were</v>

3077
02:24:31.165 --> 02:24:35.205
thinking that it was, it was sort of foreshadowing

3078
02:24:35.305 --> 02:24:37.085
how many preschool classrooms we're going

3079
02:24:37.085 --> 02:24:38.925
to be at a certain site.

3080
02:24:39.065 --> 02:24:40.445
And so I wanna just kind of nip

3081
02:24:40.445 --> 02:24:41.965
that in the bud right now. Then there's

3082
02:24:41.965 --> 02:24:43.285
<v Speaker 12>Gonna be four at the new memorial.</v>

3083
02:24:43.355 --> 02:24:45.725
<v Speaker 11>Okay. Thank you.</v>
<v Speaker 12>As long as that's</v>

3084
02:24:45.725 --> 02:24:47.085
what this committee votes for an ED program

3085
02:24:48.865 --> 02:24:49.865
<v Speaker 21>Go.</v>

3086
02:24:49.865 --> 02:24:51.845
Just in regards to the sites, the

3087
02:24:53.005 --> 02:24:55.805
MSBA won't give you any money unless you own the land.

3088
02:24:56.335 --> 02:24:59.045
Right. And based on the size of the sites

3089
02:25:00.595 --> 02:25:04.605
that we have, there seemed to be two practical options

3090
02:25:06.015 --> 02:25:09.185
because we can't fit a school for 570 kids

3091
02:25:10.095 --> 02:25:14.705
plus some preschool rooms on things that are,

3092
02:25:14.925 --> 02:25:16.265
you know, less than an acre

3093
02:25:16.405 --> 02:25:19.425
or an acre plus it, it just doesn't,

3094
02:25:19.775 --> 02:25:21.545
it's not practical, it's not gonna work.

3095
02:25:21.725 --> 02:25:25.405
So we gave the list of all of our properties

3096
02:25:27.065 --> 02:25:30.085
to the architects in the beginning to help kind

3097
02:25:30.085 --> 02:25:33.645
of move this process along unless the town

3098
02:25:33.665 --> 02:25:36.525
or the school committee planned on buying some more land

3099
02:25:37.185 --> 02:25:38.605
in the very near future,

3100
02:25:39.415 --> 02:25:42.045
which I don't think there's an appropriation to do.

3101
02:25:42.045 --> 02:25:44.805
So that's kind of what we're working with.

3102
02:25:46.565 --> 02:25:50.665
So it's, it's a, it's a practical logical deduction.

3103
02:25:50.685 --> 02:25:53.865
If you look at the list when you see parcels

3104
02:25:53.865 --> 02:25:55.465
that are fractions of an acre,

3105
02:25:56.285 --> 02:25:58.505
you know you're not gonna fit a school that size.

3106
02:25:58.735 --> 02:26:00.945
Just off the top of my head,

3107
02:26:01.245 --> 02:26:03.905
the Benham site is like 10 acres

3108
02:26:04.565 --> 02:26:08.065
and we don't have many sites that are, that are that big.

3109
02:26:08.685 --> 02:26:11.585
And that's a school that was built for 500 plus kids.

3110
02:26:13.075 --> 02:26:15.905
<v Speaker 26>Thank you.</v>
<v Speaker 1>All right.</v>

3111
02:26:16.645 --> 02:26:17.985
Do you need something from us tonight

3112
02:26:18.005 --> 02:26:19.305
or are we just discussing

3113
02:26:21.605 --> 02:26:23.105
or would you like something? Well

3114
02:26:23.405 --> 02:26:25.665
<v Speaker 12>It depends on where the, we continue to</v>

3115
02:26:26.415 --> 02:26:27.585
formulate the ED program

3116
02:26:27.765 --> 02:26:30.905
and we're really, this, the decision

3117
02:26:30.905 --> 02:26:32.505
of the committee whether to stick with B

3118
02:26:32.685 --> 02:26:36.185
or go to E matters in terms of how

3119
02:26:36.495 --> 02:26:39.425
that final document, what that final document looks like.

3120
02:26:39.885 --> 02:26:41.825
So if the committee needs time, that's fine,

3121
02:26:41.825 --> 02:26:44.145
we could do it on the seventh, but we would eventually

3122
02:26:44.195 --> 02:26:47.505
appreciate the committee's support of either continuing

3123
02:26:47.505 --> 02:26:49.705
to support B or supporting E.

3124
02:26:50.345 --> 02:26:52.865
I appreciated the conversation last week about the MOU

3125
02:26:52.965 --> 02:26:55.825
and I think that helped us to kind of get to a point

3126
02:26:56.025 --> 02:26:57.865
where we, I'm very grateful to have one

3127
02:26:57.865 --> 02:26:59.665
through 2032, which is great.

3128
02:27:00.525 --> 02:27:02.185
So I don't, I'd like to know

3129
02:27:02.185 --> 02:27:04.665
what else the committee might need if there's some further

3130
02:27:04.665 --> 02:27:05.665
deliberation on that.

3131
02:27:06.215 --> 02:27:07.465
<v Speaker 1>Okay. Dr. Welch,</v>

3132
02:27:07.705 --> 02:27:09.945
<v Speaker 9>I just wanna put a finer point on the differences</v>

3133
02:27:09.945 --> 02:27:11.545
between B and E.

3134
02:27:12.935 --> 02:27:16.825
Obviously three sites as opposed to two is one difference.

3135
02:27:16.825 --> 02:27:20.745
Yeah. Is the fact that next school year

3136
02:27:21.705 --> 02:27:24.065
FY 28, that

3137
02:27:24.095 --> 02:27:25.545
that would already have some

3138
02:27:25.545 --> 02:27:26.865
additional space at the high school?

3139
02:27:26.965 --> 02:27:30.105
Is that one practical effect of switching to option E?

3140
02:27:32.025 --> 02:27:35.385
<v Speaker 12>I think that could happen with B as well. Okay.</v>

3141
02:27:35.485 --> 02:27:37.145
So no, no, it's just new

3142
02:27:37.905 --> 02:27:39.705
because we did not have information about the

3143
02:27:39.705 --> 02:27:40.905
potential of Johnson space.

3144
02:27:40.905 --> 02:27:43.665
Yeah. Last June when we gave you the options,

3145
02:27:44.945 --> 02:27:48.025
<v Speaker 9>I I also just want to get a sense of like how,</v>

3146
02:27:48.085 --> 02:27:50.625
how many bullseye do we have to hit for this to work?

3147
02:27:50.885 --> 02:27:53.625
So if we go with option E or

3148
02:27:53.805 --> 02:27:56.065
or option B, it sounds like both

3149
02:27:56.065 --> 02:27:59.985
of those are contingent upon both extending the MOU at east

3150
02:27:59.985 --> 02:28:01.105
through 2032

3151
02:28:01.285 --> 02:28:04.265
and having an agreement on Johnson so

3152
02:28:04.265 --> 02:28:06.665
that the ASAP offices could move and make room.

3153
02:28:06.765 --> 02:28:09.105
Is that we, we'd have to, we'd have

3154
02:28:09.105 --> 02:28:10.265
to hit both those targets.

3155
02:28:10.265 --> 02:28:11.265
Is that correct?

3156
02:28:12.045 --> 02:28:15.145
<v Speaker 12>The, the Johnson I've, I feel very confident on both</v>

3157
02:28:15.145 --> 02:28:17.505
of those that, that they're not something

3158
02:28:17.505 --> 02:28:19.705
that the committee should concern be concerned with.

3159
02:28:19.705 --> 02:28:22.725
Those are operational. I think I have them well in hand.

3160
02:28:25.125 --> 02:28:26.925
I have affirmation from the town administrator

3161
02:28:26.925 --> 02:28:29.885
that if Johnson doesn't end up being the space for asap,

3162
02:28:29.885 --> 02:28:31.565
he has addit other space elsewhere.

3163
02:28:31.595 --> 02:28:33.165
Yeah. And we're in different where we are,

3164
02:28:33.515 --> 02:28:35.725
like Megan Zi is very flexible.

3165
02:28:35.985 --> 02:28:37.725
If she were at a different location, she'd be fine.

3166
02:28:38.065 --> 02:28:39.045
So I'm like, we don't care,

3167
02:28:39.065 --> 02:28:40.285
we don't need to know that right now.

3168
02:28:40.305 --> 02:28:43.805
So I'm confident on that. I have a draft MOU in hand. Yeah.

3169
02:28:44.125 --> 02:28:45.325
And so I feel confident on that.

3170
02:28:45.965 --> 02:28:48.685
<v Speaker 9>I, I'll just put my cards on the table for,</v>

3171
02:28:48.865 --> 02:28:50.325
for my colleagues, which are that

3172
02:28:51.675 --> 02:28:54.605
freeing up more space at the high school was a goal I wanted

3173
02:28:54.605 --> 02:28:58.805
to achieve doing that at the lowest possible cost

3174
02:28:59.655 --> 02:29:01.845
using an existing building that the building

3175
02:29:01.875 --> 02:29:03.685
that the taxpayers have already made an investment

3176
02:29:03.825 --> 02:29:04.885
in that's east.

3177
02:29:05.715 --> 02:29:08.765
That was a, a goal that I would like to achieve

3178
02:29:09.495 --> 02:29:11.485
maximizing the MSBA contribution,

3179
02:29:11.485 --> 02:29:12.565
which we've just discussed.

3180
02:29:12.665 --> 02:29:15.445
So putting things over at putting four classrooms over

3181
02:29:15.765 --> 02:29:18.965
Memorial was something I'd like to achieve.

3182
02:29:19.505 --> 02:29:22.365
The, the only I guess concern,

3183
02:29:22.465 --> 02:29:24.965
and it's a minor concern, is the fact

3184
02:29:24.965 --> 02:29:27.245
that from an operational perspective on the preschool

3185
02:29:28.385 --> 02:29:31.325
we had a plan that was putting them down to, to two sites,

3186
02:29:31.415 --> 02:29:32.965
which I was under the impression

3187
02:29:32.965 --> 02:29:34.445
would simplify their operations.

3188
02:29:34.605 --> 02:29:36.645
I asked the director about that when she was here

3189
02:29:37.185 --> 02:29:39.045
the night we presented school improvement plans.

3190
02:29:40.915 --> 02:29:42.285
This wouldn't do that,

3191
02:29:42.385 --> 02:29:44.285
but it would still accomplish the other things

3192
02:29:44.285 --> 02:29:46.685
that were really important, at least for me,

3193
02:29:47.385 --> 02:29:50.165
if this option does not overly complicate the lives

3194
02:29:50.265 --> 02:29:51.365
of the professional staff

3195
02:29:51.365 --> 02:29:53.085
and particularly the staff at the preschool,

3196
02:29:54.445 --> 02:29:57.485
I personally could live with staying with option B

3197
02:29:57.545 --> 02:29:58.885
or moving to Option E.

3198
02:29:59.085 --> 02:30:01.205
'cause the other priorities that I have are achieved

3199
02:30:01.945 --> 02:30:03.165
on under both options.

3200
02:30:03.345 --> 02:30:06.525
So I'll, I'll just put those out there as my own priorities

3201
02:30:06.525 --> 02:30:07.845
and I'll, I'll yield back to the chair

3202
02:30:07.845 --> 02:30:09.125
to direct to, to vote or not.

3203
02:30:09.315 --> 02:30:12.325
<v Speaker 1>Yeah. So a a couple of things and I'll get to everybody.</v>

3204
02:30:12.395 --> 02:30:14.645
I'll get to everybody just for a little bit of context.

3205
02:30:14.925 --> 02:30:16.525
I believe, and Ms. Brunell can correct me if I'm wrong,

3206
02:30:16.805 --> 02:30:19.805
I believe on December 2nd the select board will be

3207
02:30:19.805 --> 02:30:22.045
discussing the recommended the,

3208
02:30:22.045 --> 02:30:24.685
like the report on the Johnson interm.

3209
02:30:25.265 --> 02:30:26.405
So for anybody who's interested.

3210
02:30:26.865 --> 02:30:30.245
So we should I think have a good sense from the select board

3211
02:30:30.545 --> 02:30:33.685
on that pretty soon also.

3212
02:30:34.225 --> 02:30:36.845
And we should continue to get everybody's feedback on this.

3213
02:30:38.565 --> 02:30:43.205
I am, my gut tells me that we have the discussion now,

3214
02:30:43.205 --> 02:30:44.925
but that we don't, if we're gonna vote on something,

3215
02:30:44.945 --> 02:30:47.005
we wouldn't vote on it until our December 7th meeting,

3216
02:30:47.485 --> 02:30:50.125
particularly because two members are not here

3217
02:30:50.145 --> 02:30:51.565
for this discussion and this is a big deal

3218
02:30:51.945 --> 02:30:53.125
and it's a big deal

3219
02:30:53.125 --> 02:30:55.445
and we shouldn't, I think it's okay to sit on it

3220
02:30:55.625 --> 02:30:57.445
for two weeks and think about it

3221
02:30:57.465 --> 02:30:59.005
and make sure that we have the,

3222
02:30:59.025 --> 02:31:01.045
the community has an opportunity to give feedback.

3223
02:31:02.825 --> 02:31:04.605
So with that, we have other comments

3224
02:31:04.625 --> 02:31:06.685
and Mr. Patel, and then Mr. Brunell,

3225
02:31:07.675 --> 02:31:09.645
<v Speaker 24>Just in case I'm not here for the next meeting,</v>

3226
02:31:09.765 --> 02:31:11.165
I just wanna let it know, be known.

3227
02:31:11.565 --> 02:31:13.005
I agree with what Dr. Welt said.

3228
02:31:13.085 --> 02:31:15.285
I think option E also checks off most of the boxes.

3229
02:31:15.545 --> 02:31:18.685
So while B is preferable to somewhat consolidate

3230
02:31:18.685 --> 02:31:21.245
<v Speaker 1>Better, I'm amenable to both, so, okay.</v>

3231
02:31:21.245 --> 02:31:24.205
Okay. Thank you Ms. Purnell.

3232
02:31:24.885 --> 02:31:25.885
<v Speaker 11>Initially I thought</v>

3233
02:31:25.885 --> 02:31:28.605
that the real benefit was the high school being able

3234
02:31:28.605 --> 02:31:30.485
to move the two classes because of e

3235
02:31:31.345 --> 02:31:33.405
but hearing that you can, we could do it either way.

3236
02:31:34.145 --> 02:31:37.405
To me this, the real benefit is one, you were able

3237
02:31:37.525 --> 02:31:41.085
to move on the MOUI really appreciate the town doing that

3238
02:31:41.345 --> 02:31:42.965
and you sticking with it.

3239
02:31:43.625 --> 02:31:45.965
And it also sounds like you're being, we are

3240
02:31:46.535 --> 02:31:49.405
being good partners to the town and to the YMCA.

3241
02:31:49.425 --> 02:31:50.525
Yes. Because we're saying, look,

3242
02:31:50.525 --> 02:31:51.685
we don't need all of the space.

3243
02:31:52.185 --> 02:31:55.205
We can shift and be flexible here

3244
02:31:55.265 --> 02:31:56.805
and use some space at Benham.

3245
02:31:57.015 --> 02:31:58.565
Right. So the, it,

3246
02:31:58.585 --> 02:32:01.565
it seems like we are not really gaining all

3247
02:32:01.565 --> 02:32:06.525
that much an E except that we are allowing other programs

3248
02:32:06.525 --> 02:32:08.645
to run in a way that need

3249
02:32:08.645 --> 02:32:10.445
to run right now in the context of everything.

3250
02:32:10.465 --> 02:32:12.285
And I think that's a really positive sign for

3251
02:32:12.285 --> 02:32:14.725
what we want Na, how we want native to be.

3252
02:32:15.945 --> 02:32:19.165
So I also support option E on that front

3253
02:32:19.385 --> 02:32:21.965
and I like that Behem is close to eSchool so

3254
02:32:21.965 --> 02:32:23.805
that if the staff does have to go back

3255
02:32:23.805 --> 02:32:26.005
and forth, at least they're on that side of Route nine.

3256
02:32:27.795 --> 02:32:29.285
Yeah. So thank you for thinking of it.

3257
02:32:30.635 --> 02:32:32.205
<v Speaker 1>Okay. Does that, is that all right</v>

3258
02:32:32.205 --> 02:32:33.365
with you for us to wait two weeks?

3259
02:32:33.365 --> 02:32:35.445
Yeah, very much so. It, there's a, there's a,

3260
02:32:35.915 --> 02:32:39.685
what I would say is an informal sounding soft support for E

3261
02:32:39.705 --> 02:32:43.485
but we'll talk about it more in two weeks and go from there.

3262
02:32:44.035 --> 02:32:47.045
Last things on the agenda are the subcommittee updates.

3263
02:32:47.065 --> 02:32:48.765
Do we have a policy subcommittee update?

3264
02:32:49.825 --> 02:32:52.805
<v Speaker 25>We did not meet the last time we were scheduled to meet</v>

3265
02:32:52.985 --> 02:32:54.925
as we were missing two of the three members.

3266
02:32:56.105 --> 02:32:57.125
And it doesn't work that way.

3267
02:32:58.225 --> 02:33:01.965
But our next scheduled meetings are on December 4th at

3268
02:33:01.965 --> 02:33:05.885
4:00 PM and believe it or not, December 22nd at 3:00 PM

3269
02:33:06.235 --> 02:33:07.235
<v Speaker 1>Okay.</v>

3270
02:33:07.835 --> 02:33:09.765
<v Speaker 25>Because Sue can't get enough of</v>

3271
02:33:09.765 --> 02:33:12.565
<v Speaker 1>Me and loves those meetings. All right. Ms. Brunell,</v>

3272
02:33:13.005 --> 02:33:15.045
<v Speaker 11>The budget subcommittee has a meeting scheduled.</v>

3273
02:33:15.765 --> 02:33:18.885
I don't. Anyway. December. Thank you. December 7th. Yeah.

3274
02:33:20.065 --> 02:33:23.405
Of which we will be talking about fees and capital plan

3275
02:33:23.625 --> 02:33:25.325
and FY eight budget 28 budget.

3276
02:33:25.665 --> 02:33:26.845
So things are moving ahead

3277
02:33:27.745 --> 02:33:29.285
<v Speaker 1>And didn't you have one more thing</v>

3278
02:33:29.285 --> 02:33:30.405
you just wanted to say just now

3279
02:33:30.995 --> 02:33:31.965
<v Speaker 11>Move to adjourn. Oh,</v>

3280
02:33:32.395 --> 02:33:33.395
<v Speaker 1>Alright.</v>

3281
02:33:33.395 --> 02:33:37.445
Well, any debate? All in favor? Any opposed?

3282
02:33:37.675 --> 02:33:39.325
5 0 0. Thank you everybody.

